Sure there are some issues with js, eg binary support in browser is painful, and it is slow, but Java started off slow and lacking features too. It is improving.
Is now a good time to work on things like this? Why not. Especially if they feed into language and API improvements.
Not sure. Lots of people reimplemented lots of stuff for Java, but it turns out Java was only successful in the sweet spot for it (networked server side language); it never replaced C/C++ in any meaningful way.
I expect the same with JavaScript, it will flourish in its niche (in particular as it has a monopoly as the in-browser-language), but it won't replace established languages on their respective home turf.
Maybe "replace" is a bad word though. Java complimented C/C++, creating a whole new market.
Essentially Java replaced C++ in most of the enterprise programming market.
I beg to differ. By using a custom look and feel or rendering your own UI using Java2D, it is entirely possible to make attractive software in Java.
I also neglected to mention that people are making attractive apps using Java on Android.
However there is great benefit to this young language when a popular utility can be implemented to highlight the weakness of a particular runtime implementation, or even the underlying language.
Git/Hg clients touch network io, file io, and rudimentary hashing in the normal execution path. So it makes for a good subject.
There's more than one way to do it.
If history has a lesson, most of this will not be wildly successful, because the js environment is not suitable for the task to be an actual practical solution.