Re:Allies Believe U.S. 'No Longer a Good Model of Democracy,...
by austincheney on Friday June 11, 2021 @08:04AM
(#27472172)
I would so love to eliminate winner takes all from states as part of the electoral college. California is slightly purple and Texas extremely so. That should be represented in their massive vote counts.
Re:Allies Believe U.S. 'No Longer a Good Model of Democracy,...
by dragonwriter on Friday June 11, 2021 @10:56AM
(#27474245)
> I would so love to eliminate winner takes all from states as part of the electoral college
The manner of Presidential elections is a whole lot less important to having a partisan duopoly than the manner of legislative elections and the fact we have a strong Presidency.
Re:Allies Believe U.S. 'No Longer a Good Model of Democracy,...
by salawat on Friday June 11, 2021 @09:07AM
(#27472788)
The electoral college was never meant to be influenced at all by political party membership; and Washington warned against the siren call of the National political party when he left office.
Re:Allies Believe U.S. 'No Longer a Good Model of Democracy,...
by dragonwriter on Friday June 11, 2021 @11:02AM
(#27474332)
> The electoral college was never meant to be influenced at all by political party membership;
Then, frankly, the framers were completely incompetent, because they couldn't have designed a system designed better to guarantee a stable national partisan duopoly if that had been their intent.
> and Washington warned against the siren call of the National political party when he left office.
That wasn't a forward looking warning; the duopoly guaranteed by the Constitutional structure of government had already been firmly established by the end of Washington's first term, with the leaders of both factions in his Cabinet.
There are hundreds of political parties in the US; the stable equilibrium is only two competitive factions because of the electoral system. Breaking up currently dominant parties without addressing the electoral system won’t change anything meaningful. You need to fix the electoral system.
Specifically, the solid evidence from across modern democracies is that if you want multiple competitive parties, you need to adopt a system which tends toward proportional representation, like STV with multimember districts, and it helps further to maximize the relative power of the proportionally representative body (Tinkering with voting methods for single-member legislative districts wouldn't actually help much.)
Having winner-take-all elections for thr legislature, investing wxtra power in the less represntative body within the legislature, and having a strong Presidency that is indirectly elected all tend against having multiple competitive parties.