News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:"Yes, but what are your credentials, Mr Stross?" by rfrey on Saturday July 09, 2011 @06:38PM (#2746494)
It sounds like high school policy debates teach the opposite of rational thought

It's always been so. Socrates' greatest enemy wasn't Aristophanes. They were the Sophists - teachers who would teach debating skills with no regard for truth. This kind of "debate" and the worldview behind it is the most insidious kind of cynicism.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sophism

Re:"Yes, but what are your credentials, Mr Stross?" by wisty on Saturday July 09, 2011 @08:07PM (#2746637)
That could just be Socrates' (well, really Plato's) somewhat sophistic portrayal of them. The Sophists were a sort of combination of academics, scientists, philosophers, politicians, and lawyers. So they got a fair share of distain.

I'm guessing that calling someone a "Sophist" was like calling them an "academic". Even people who are academics themselves will do it, to try and drum up a bit of street cred.

Re:"Yes, but what are your credentials, Mr Stross?" by dgabriel on Saturday July 09, 2011 @08:03PM (#2746629)
Agreed. In my experience, the debaters don't have any conviction at all, just a folio of out-of-context quotes and a strong grasp of technicalities. That said, in an ideal world debate teaches thorough research and rhetorical skills, and I found that learning "flowing," was pretty helpful in other areas of my life.
Re:"Yes, but what are your credentials, Mr Stross?" by Tichy on Sunday July 10, 2011 @04:34AM (#2747342)
The problem might be that this is how the real world works, or the minds of most of the people who vote in democracies. While I admire Socrates more, didn't he essentially live like a bum? Maybe to really get enough influence to move something, you have to play the game.

Not that I like it - that is why I am a software developer, not a politician. The real hacker mindset would be to try to figure out how people's minds work and take advantage of it (for a greater good, of course).

Re:"Yes, but what are your credentials, Mr Stross?" by kmfrk on Saturday July 09, 2011 @08:31PM (#2746692)
Good thing some of us are able to refrain from referring to external sources as appeals to authority to legitimize our own arguments, right? :)
Re:"Yes, but what are your credentials, Mr Stross?" by rfrey on Saturday July 09, 2011 @09:27PM (#2746774)
I was pointing out that this problem has existed and been recognized for at least 2500 years, as evidenced by extant writings of Plato. How is that an appeal to authority?