News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Purchasing power of one US dollar in every year from 1635... by arcticbull on Thursday June 10, 2021 @02:44PM (#27464050)
> I could not disagree more. For much of human history, and most of American history, saving currency was exactly how you saved value.

For much of human history we pooped in the street and murdered each other with reckless abandon - then we found a better way. I'm not sure the rose colored glasses mean much here.

That may have been how we did things in the past, but there's no reason to couple a medium of exchange (short term) and a store of value (long term). There's really no justification for it, and the economy has been much better off for it. Stability has improved dramatically over a gold standard.

> The fact that putting money under your mattress is no longer a viable strategy is why we have massive and growing wealth inequality.

As I explained these are completely unrelated. You're conflating a social policy issue with a fiscal policy issue. There's no reason to believe that if inflation were 0% wages would not have remained exactly constant in notional dollars, and if there was deflationary currency they wouldn't have just gone down in notional dollars.

> It is horribly unrealistic to assume that every person can or should become financially savvy enough to make smart investments in the global economy, and it is naive to think that just buying some index is efficiently allocating capital.

http://betterment.com

> Wages have barely kept up with CPI [0], which is not true inflation (see my other comment on this thread).

Agree to disagree.

> While I don't agree with most of their economically illiterate proposed solutions (minimum wages, wealth taxes, etc.), the people clamoring about a living wage have a point these days.

Works all over the world, why not here?

Re:Purchasing power of one US dollar in every year from 1635... by lend000 on Thursday June 10, 2021 @03:04PM (#27464293)
> For much of human history we pooped in the street and murdered each other with reckless abandon. I'm not sure the rose colored glasses mean much here.

Is this a straw man or a red herring? Try to avoid your logical fallacies on HN, regardless.

> That may have been how we did things in the past, but there's no reason to couple a medium of exchange (short term) and a store of value (long term). There's really no justification for it, and the economy has been much better off for it. Stability has improved dramatically over a gold standard.

There is a reason. Normal, hard-working people can thrive under that simple system, and wealth inequality does not systematically increase to the betterment of the financially savvy. Which is exactly what is happening in our inflationary utopia you are describing. Where have you been? I don't know what metric you are using to define stability, but keep in mind bear markets are the only periods in American history where wealth inequality reliably decreases as capital is reallocated [0]. Staving them off at all costs benefits the wealthy more than the many.

Betterment, which you linked, is a free market solution to a policy problem, but it's about 50 years too late, and unless they capture 100% market share, they aren't going to solve the problem going forward (and of course they will scoop some nice fees off your savings).

> Agree to disagree.

With data?...

All of your points hinge on CPI being a correct measure of inflation. It isn't [1]. CPI quite literally measures what typical Americans are buying, and how much of it they are buying. I.e. their budget. A budget directly set by their wages.

[0] https://www.federalreserve.gov/releases/z1/dataviz/dfa/distr... [1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/perianneboring/2014/02/03/if-yo...

Re:Purchasing power of one US dollar in every year from 1635... by arcticbull on Thursday June 10, 2021 @03:17PM (#27464460)
Btw, re: #2, you linked to a Forbes opinion piece. Forbes opinion section is basically a glorified Medium. Not only is that write-up from 2004, so almost 18 years old, it was written by someone unaffiliated with Forbes. I would encourage you to put as much stock in a Forbes opinion piece as something you read on Medium. In a lot of was its worse because it lends them the credibility of Forbes - but you wouldn't believe the garbage you find mixed in there.
Re:Purchasing power of one US dollar in every year from 1635... by lend000 on Thursday June 10, 2021 @03:58PM (#27465008)
Some people would naturally respond to the content of the article. Others would naturally appeal to authority or ad hominem the author. Some food for thought.

CPI ostensibly worked the same way in 2004, by the way. Based on your other comment linking the definition of CPI, it seems like you have no idea how it's calculated. Even I didn't know the details until recently -- I just knew the numbers weren't matching up with my models and very obvious price data.

So here's how it works. In the US, a consumer expenditure survey is obtained by the BLS [0]. This determines what items account for typical Americans' spending, and in what quantity, to determine weights [1]. Price data is obtained, with in-house selected indices and hedonic adjustments [2]. These prices are multiplied against the weights, summed, and reflected as a ratio compared to the previous year. The Wikipedia page provides a nice summary [3].

What is the problem with this? Well, the problem is in the consumer expenditure survey.

If wealth inequality is stagnant, this is actually a decent measure of inflation in so far as it affects people's personal expenses. However, if wealth inequality is increasing (and the assets and expenses of the wealthy are not factored into this survey, which they are not), inflation can only increase so much as median Americans' wages increase (plus their debt). When prices are increasing, Americans buy dramatically different amounts of the expensive items (you can see that in the weights in [1] in the mid 2000's when gas prices varied significantly) to fit their budget, under-weighting the items that are manifesting high inflation. Inaccurate hedonic adjustments and any other adjustments done behind closed doors could also account for why CPI veers so far from independently calculated inflation measures like the Big Mac Index, but the core of the problem is that the inflation weights are reactionary to inflation and there isn't much of a delay on letting weights change each year.

So, that is why real wages adjusted for "inflation" is a straight line.

[0] https://www.bls.gov/cex/ [1] https://www.bls.gov/cpi/tables/relative-importance/2019.pdf [2] https://www.bls.gov/cpi/quality-adjustment/questions-and-ans... [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Consumer_Price_I...

Re:Purchasing power of one US dollar in every year from 1635... by arcticbull on Thursday June 10, 2021 @04:30PM (#27465377)
> Some people would naturally respond to the content of the article. Others would naturally appeal to authority or ad hominem the author. Some food for thought.

This was a general comment on the quality of Forbes opinion pieces not an ad hominem attack. It's worth mentioning it because I think there's a strong tendency to trust the Forbes brand, but it doesn't extend to their blogging platform. That's why I actually separated it from my other reply.

Inflation is defined relative to basic goods and necessities, not to all goods - or to luxury goods, and there's a reason for that. Prices of goods change all the time for all sorts of reasons. Lobster used to be garbage food, now it's luxury. Same with sushi, monkfish, oyster and pig trotters. If the quantity of lobsters in the ocean start going down and the price of lobster increases, does that mean inflation is happening? Even if people switched from lobster to salmon? Certainly not in my opinion. Nobody's not entitled to a constant basket of necessities isolated from the world around them.

Basing the inflation definition on basic goods and needs at the time is a reasonable proxy due to their broad-based requirement by individuals. Nobody needs luxuries by definition. Luxuries are expensive by definition. Luxuries tend to be scarce and their price as a result fluctuates substantially. But further, they're a product of social tastes that change for any reason or no reason.

Weights are adjusted because the price of things changes for all sorts of reasons, and the goal is to index against a basket of common necessities - not specific necessities for that reason.

A good analog would be the S&P 500 and the Dow Jones. Those index components change regularly as some companies fall out of favor and others rise to prominence. They reflect the economy but not specific companies. That's not a bug, it's a feature IMO.

The weights being adjusted is reactionary to the cost and availability of goods and the preferences of consumers, and that's totally fine. A platonic, isolated increase in price is not inflation, it's just what it says on the tin - an increase in price.

Re:Purchasing power of one US dollar in every year from 1635... by reedjosh on Thursday June 10, 2021 @04:58PM (#27465748)
> Basing the inflation definition on basic goods and needs at the time is a reasonable proxy due to their broad-based requirement by individuals

But what of non-luxury goods that aren't included like housing? If the CPI is to measure essentially the value of the dollar to what is required to live, isn't it useless without housing?

Why is housing left out? I surmise it wouldn't fit the inflation targets the fed claims to be attempting.

Either way, when a measure becomes a target it fails to be a measure.

Edit: Just another thought. Is today's produce even equivalent to that of 60 years ago?

Today's corn is genetically modified and soaked in `safe` glyphosate. If the CPI was honest they'd at least have to acknowledge that the food we eat today is of extremely so lesser quality.

Today's nearest equivalent would be to eat a wholly organic diet. If one were to hold the quality of food stable, that too would have to show a _much_ higher rate of inflation.

Re:Purchasing power of one US dollar in every year from 1635... by arcticbull on Thursday June 10, 2021 @06:07PM (#27466439)
> But what of non-luxury goods that aren't included like housing? If the CPI is to measure essentially the value of the dollar to what is required to live, isn't it useless without housing?

Housing is included by proxy of rent. [1]

I think you'll generally find that rent growth has significantly outpaced mortgage costs, and therefore housing is overrepresented in the CPI. [2] This makes intuitive sense, after all, people tend to refinance into lower interest rates (and the general trend has been down) whereas rents seem to only go up. So, by using rents your housing costs go up a lot more over time (indicating higher inflation) as compared to using mortgage principal and interest payments.

[1] https://arbor.com/blog/how-does-rent-factor-into-the-consume...

[2] https://www.businessinsider.com/monthly-mortgage-vs-monthly-...

Re:Purchasing power of one US dollar in every year from 1635... by frankenst1 on Friday June 11, 2021 @06:35AM (#27471504)

    Cost of a Big Mac in 2000: $2.51 (in 2000 dollars)
    $2.51 (2000) in 2021:      $3.92 (in 2021 dollars, CPI adjusted)
    Cost of a Big Mac in 2021: $5.66 (in 2021 dollars)
So a Big Mac in 2021 is 44% more expensive than what CPI would explain.

If the Big Mac would be an item in the CPI, it would gradually be removed from it because the more expensive it becomes, the less Big Mac's a person would buy.

Arguing that items which become more expensive are rightly removed from the CPI because they become "unnecessary luxury items" is fine for modelling consumer behaviour, but misleading for establishing inflation metrics.

Re:Purchasing power of one US dollar in every year from 1635... by arcticbull on Friday June 11, 2021 @11:52AM (#27474921)
I think the Big Mac index is an excellent measure of the inflation of Big Macs. However, it is not designed to measure inflation as felt by the average consumer, it is designed to measure purchasing power parity. How far a given unit of one currency will go in one country versus another.

The CPI basket includes all sorts of non-big Mac related items. For instance, residential housing, commute costs and so on.

Even within the CPI basket, the basket is an average. Certain things will go up more than the average in certain things will go up less, but that’s how averages work. Check out the breakdowns on how the various index components of gone up and down over time.

Re:Purchasing power of one US dollar in every year from 1635... by frankenst1 on Tuesday June 15, 2021 @04:14PM (#27520903)
The price of a Big Mac is an aggregate of the costs of its ingredients, labor, production, storage, distribution, marketing, etc...

A Big Mac can also be considered to deliver roughly the same perceived value to the customer over decades which is useful for an inflation metric. This is in contrast to items prone to technological efficiency gains which are getting cheaper and are favoured by CPI weighting adjustments.

And still, even considering the efficiency gains and cost reduction for energy and transportation the cost of a Big Mac still does not fluctuate around the CPIs 2% average. Its average annual inflation over the last 20 years is ~4% and roughly twice as high as CPI claims.

Re:Purchasing power of one US dollar in every year from 1635... by imtringued on Friday June 11, 2021 @02:35AM (#27470022)
>Which is exactly what is happening in our inflationary utopia you are describing.

Unfortunately, we are in a deflationary utopia. The only thing that changed that is the pandemic and it won't last for long.

Re:Purchasing power of one US dollar in every year from 1635... by arcticbull on Thursday June 10, 2021 @03:11PM (#27464392)
> Is this a straw man or a red herring? Try to avoid your logical fallacies on HN, regardless.

Neither, I was pointing out that just because we used to do things a certain way doesn't meant they were inherently better. In fact, "for much of human history" things were much worse, and we were approaching them in ways that are by and large inferior.

This is a kind of declinism bias or rosy retrospection bias. [1]

> There is a reason. Normal, hard-working people can thrive under that simple system, and wealth inequality does not systematically increase to the betterment of the financially savvy.

You're once again missing the forest for the trees. The unit itself doesn't matter. How much of it you have matters and what you put it to work doing matters.

> Where have you been? I don't know metric you are using to define stability, but keep in mind bear markets are the only periods in American history where wealth inequality reliably decreases as capital is reallocated.

Boom and bust cycles under the gold standard were dramatically exaggerated, in part because no entity could stabilize the medium of exchange. As bad as 2008 was, I guarantee you the Great Depression was worse.

> Betterment, which you linked, is a free market solution to a policy problem, but it's about 50 years too late, and unless they capture 100% market share, they aren't going to solve the problem going forward (and of course they will scoop some nice fees off your savings).

It's not a public policy problem, it's a public policy solution. Your job in a capitalist economy is to allocate capital to the most productive investment. If you choose to abdicate that responsibility you can pay a fee to Wealthfront of Betterment to do it for you, or you can pay a 2% per annum fee and keep it at home.

However, money only has value when it changes hands, not when its jammed under your gramma's mattress. Inflation encourages investment to keep capital flow moving. GDP is in fact money supply times velocity. This is how the economy functions.

> All of your points hinge on CPI being a correct measure of inflation. It isn't.

> The Consumer Price Index (CPI) is a measure that examines the weighted average of prices of a basket of consumer goods and services, such as transportation, food, and medical care. It is calculated by taking price changes for each item in the predetermined basket of goods and averaging them. Changes in the CPI are used to assess price changes associated with the cost of living. The CPI is one of the most frequently used statistics for identifying periods of inflation or deflation. [2]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Declinism

[2] https://www.investopedia.com/terms/c/consumerpriceindex.asp