News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. Consumer Prices Rose Strongly Again in May by whb07 on Thursday June 10, 2021 @10:41AM (#27461314)
All of these “technical” measures are the work of people trying to explain and come up with clever ways to argue for their jobs and continuous involvement in monetary experiments.

I want deflation to occur. There are enormous sectors where deflation is seen and everyone sees the obvious benefits[0]. But when it runs up against the work of the state printing money to finance the destruction of society, then deflation is seen as dangerous.

The main argument the inflation lovers propose is, “well if the prices keep going down then people won’t buy anything as they’ll just wait longer for the product to get cheaper.”

This is clearly false as the wants/needs are a “now” problem, and the PhDs at the FED have never seen the lines for Black Friday to purchase TVs and other consumer electronics. Why buy an iPhone 12 when in 2 years that same iPhone will be 50% off?

Not only that, there is also an increase in sales by volume which could lead to more profits by lowering the price of a widget. There are huge segments of consumers that would consume at a lower price point!

[0] Electronics/computing is an extremely obvious sign of deflation. Prices lowered, or goods improved and everyone benefits.

Re:U.S. Consumer Prices Rose Strongly Again in May by imtringued on Thursday June 10, 2021 @11:06AM (#27461587)
>I want deflation to occur. There are enormous sectors where deflation is seen and everyone sees the obvious benefits[0]. But when it runs up against the work of the state printing money to finance the destruction of society, then deflation is seen as dangerous.

Greece has deflation and Japan is very close to deflation. Are those countries examples to look up to? I don't think so.

>The main argument the inflation lovers propose is, “well if the prices keep going down then people won’t buy anything as they’ll just wait longer for the product to get cheaper.”

The argument in favor of inflation is that future incomes are greater than past incomes, therefore inflation is a tax on old money and helps new people enter into the economy and encourage them to keep working. The other factor is that inflation is like a bluing dye used in machining. It shows the high spots that you have to scrape off to get a flat surface. It can therefore be used to reallocate limited resources to more productive sectors of the economy. Inflation is an incentive to invest your money, as otherwise it would sit in your bank account and do nothing except cause unemployment, which causes the productivity of the country to go down.

“well if the prices keep going down then people won’t buy anything as they’ll just wait longer for the product to get cheaper.”

We have reached a point where billionaires (and companies) have more money than they could possibly spend in a lifetime. One billionaire doing nothing with his money is equivalent to a million poor people ($1000 in their bank account) not doing something with their money. As inflation is a percentage it affects people proportional to their savings, billionaires lose the most and are forced to invest their money for the benefit of the rest of the economy. Meanwhile poor people lose the least, because they don't have that many savings to begin with and the loss that they experience would be more than recovered by finding a better paying job or by finding a job at all.

>[0] Electronics/computing is an extremely obvious sign of deflation. Prices lowered, or goods improved and everyone benefits.

With inflation incomes go up and prices stay roughly the same. Therefore you benefit from productivity growth but not by hoarding old money earned hundreds of years ago.

Meanwhile deflation works exactly the opposite way. The richer you are, the more you benefit from deflation. The earlier you have earned your money, the better.

Re:U.S. Consumer Prices Rose Strongly Again in May by bko on Thursday June 10, 2021 @12:06PM (#27462293)
> Greece has deflation and Japan is very close to deflation. Are those countries examples to look up to? I don't think so.

As though the defining characteristic of those two countries is near deflation. Under the veil of ignorance I would choose to live in a low/deflationary country than a high inflation country. Every single time

> Inflation is an incentive to invest your money, as otherwise it would sit in your bank account and do nothing except cause unemployment, which causes the productivity of the country to go down.

What about those that are living paycheck to paycheck? What about those that are retired or near retirement?

> As inflation is a percentage it affects people proportional to their savings, billionaires lose the most and are forced to invest their money for the benefit of the rest of the economy.

According to the IMF and world bank this is wrong. Just look at countries that have high inflation. Inflation hurts the poor the most

IMF: High inflation tends to lower the share of the bottom quintile and the real minimum wage -and tends to increase poverty

https://openknowledge.worldbank.org/bitstream/handle/10986/1...

Re:U.S. Consumer Prices Rose Strongly Again in May by throwaway34241 on Thursday June 10, 2021 @02:56PM (#27464212)
> Under the veil of ignorance I would choose to live in a low/deflationary country than a high inflation country

Well, few people would disagree with you that high inflation is bad.

Between steady low inflation and deflation though, there's problems with deflation related to the fact that it's hard for the interest rate to go below zero (since people can just put money in their mattress to get a zero return).

Basically, the Fed lowers the interest rate to limit recessions (and raises it to fight inflation). But what really matters is the real (inflation adjusted) interest rate.

If the Fed cuts interest rates to zero, but deflation is 3%/yr, that raises the real interest rate to 3%. And raising the interest rate is itself deflationary, so I'm sure you can see the problem with this - it's a positive feedback loop. Deflation raises the real interest rate leading to more deflation, less investment, more loan defaults, etc. That's the classic deflationary depression spiral that often ends in massive, rapid currency debasement and/or political instability.

Because that's so undesirable (and historically the currency ends up debased anyway after a lot of chaos) there's an argument for targeting a small, but positive, amount of inflation every year just to be on the safe side.

Re:U.S. Consumer Prices Rose Strongly Again in May by whb07 on Thursday June 10, 2021 @02:29PM (#27463851)
The issue with Greece is that they aren’t very productive and live beyond their means against the savings of the Germans and others. So no, you cannot use that as an example. As for Japan, they have had massive population drop and inefficiencies from closed borders that probably reflects a greater reason why there has been a deflationary period.

For a better idea, you could look at say the cost of a loaf of bread from late 18th century to 19th century and it remained flat in the US.

In the late 1800s-1920s, was the greatest growth period for the US and AFAIK the cost of living fell from increased productivity and technological improvements.

Inflation destroys savers, which leads to reduction of investments.

savings = investments

People forget that somehow.

Re:U.S. Consumer Prices Rose Strongly Again in May by ericmay on Thursday June 10, 2021 @10:57AM (#27461496)
> The main argument the inflation lovers propose is, “well if the prices keep going down then people won’t buy anything as they’ll just wait longer for the product to get cheaper.”

I'm not sure if I have seen that argument very often. It's not a great one, for sure, because at some point prices kind of just stabilize long enough for people to decide it's time to make a purchase. So sure maybe that happens in the short term, but not the long term. The inverse is true too - people are rushing out to buy cars and things anticipating the prices will continue to go up.

The strongest argument I've seen against strict deflation just comes down to competitiveness of exports.

Re:U.S. Consumer Prices Rose Strongly Again in May by TheCoelacanth on Thursday June 10, 2021 @05:27PM (#27466072)
I don't want deflation for one very obvious reason: I have a mortgage and it is much larger than the amount of cash I keep on hand.

Deflation is very bad for average consumers because most average consumers are in debt.

Re:U.S. Consumer Prices Rose Strongly Again in May by lg on Thursday June 10, 2021 @10:53AM (#27461440)
deflation is a tax on borrowing which discourages growth, causing more deflation ad nauseam.
Re:U.S. Consumer Prices Rose Strongly Again in May by bngybmgrglflps on Thursday June 10, 2021 @12:58PM (#27462881)
Not ad nauseam. There's a floor, an equilibrium where countercyclical forces take over. (Besides: many people agreeing with this sentiment maintain that growth _per se_ is already an existential threat to human existence.)

Inflation is a tax on saving which encourages malinvestment "bubbles" that fail catastrophically.

Monetary policy addresses them by creating ever more money to encourage ever more synthetic growth. Once debt service threatens to consume the sovereign budget, monetary tightening ceases to be politically viable.

Not for nothing, we appear to be living in the Keynesian "long run."

Re:U.S. Consumer Prices Rose Strongly Again in May by whb07 on Thursday June 10, 2021 @07:25PM (#27467366)
There’s massive deflation in consumer electronics and anything related to software and we’re seeing more consumption not less.

“Hey Joe, I know you like that $1000 machine, but are you willing to buy a better one for $500?”

“Gee, no thanks!”