News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Steve Jobs isn’t our Dad by saurik on Saturday July 09, 2011 @10:53AM (#2745655)
> "We started formally distributing free apps in early 2005 and are among the pioneers of the modern direct-to-consumer (D2C) app store distribution space when the iPhone was just an R&D project in Steve Job’s head."

> "GetJar has been using the term “App Store” in press releases and in it’s positioning with consumers, trade, analysts and press since early 2009 and it’s only now that Apple has decided to send us a C&D."

Is it just me, or is this actually a good argument /for/ Apple owning the term "App Store"? People keep making the claim "it is an obvious name", but apparently it wasn't for GetJar: it wasn't until Apple gave that term meaning by applying it to their product that GetJar decided to use the term.

> "In conclusion, GetJar won’t be subject to this kind of bullying. We’re not going to “Cease & Desist”. We were here long before Steve & Co. We were built by developers, to help developers."

As for this statement... I don't know... this entire article somehow makes it sound like Apple is telling them to stop running their service, when in fact all Apple is doing is asking them to stop using the term "App Store".

I mean, seriously: my full time job is complaining about Apple being a closed ecosystem, but there's something about this blog post that is off-putting and misses the mark; in fact, I don't even see how Apple being a closed ecosystem is relevant to this specific argument.

Re:Steve Jobs isn’t our Dad by ggchappell on Saturday July 09, 2011 @01:43PM (#2745955)
> Is it just me, or is this actually a good argument /for/ Apple owning the term "App Store"? People keep making the claim "it is an obvious name", but apparently it wasn't for GetJar: it wasn't until Apple gave that term meaning by applying it to their product that GetJar decided to use the term.

It's a good argument for the term "app store" being original with Apple. However, being the first one to use a term, does not mean you "own" it.

Under the law, one can register a trademark, which gives one exclusive rights to the term under certain restricted conditions. However, as the article points out, Apple did not get a trademark free & clear.

Re:Steve Jobs isn’t our Dad by saurik on Saturday July 09, 2011 @02:27PM (#2746061)
Obviously, I mean in the restricted area of "term used to describe a software product or service", and "under the law" you don't need to successfully register a trademark for that (although trying and actively failing to register the mark will make your life very difficult in court); also, I feel like you are putting too much emphasis on the word "own" here as if I was going for some technical definition, as opposed to "when people think of that word, they immediately associate with Apple's App Store" (which really is all that trademarks really come down to: whether there would be viable confusion in the market if other people co-opted the name).
Re:Steve Jobs isn’t our Dad by sunchild on Saturday July 09, 2011 @06:16PM (#2746459)
The test is whether a mark has "secondary meaning". http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/metaschool/fisher/domain/tm.htm
Re:Steve Jobs isn’t our Dad by kalleboo on Saturday July 09, 2011 @09:02PM (#2746733)
They presumably started calling it an App Store after people started referring to mobile software as "Apps" (which seems to have started with the iPhone). If a piece of mobile software is called an "App", then calling the place you got it an "App Store" is pretty natural.

So if Apple want to own "App Store", they also ought to go after everyone calling them "Apps". If "App" is generic, so should "App Store".

Re:Steve Jobs isn’t our Dad by Gormo on Sunday July 10, 2011 @04:50PM (#2748596)
People have been using "app" as an abbreviated form of "application" for decades.
Re:Steve Jobs isn’t our Dad by dorian-graph on Saturday July 09, 2011 @10:58PM (#2746900)
> .. but there's something about this blog post that is off-putting and misses the mark; in fact, I don't even see how Apple being a closed ecosystem is relevant to this specific argument.

Re-read the second half of the whole blog post (Specifically at the paragraph that starts with "Second, ...'), he kind of explains how it's all connected.

Re:Steve Jobs isn’t our Dad by saurik on Saturday July 09, 2011 @11:26PM (#2746948)
That paragraph kind of thrashes around trying to find a point, and then certainly doesn't lead to the "In conclusion..." paragraph, which simply looks to be a non-sequitor. :(

This is the blog post of a company (a fairly large one, actually, that has in thr last 7 years it is operating become the default marketplace for some entire carriers) that is trying to use a confusing twist of logic to avoid talking about the actual trademark dispute, and instead focus on one of Apple's weak PR points.

They may as well be making an argument through "social justice" to "sustainability" in order to invoke the "Apple ships their products using ecologically unfriendly packaging" card: it would sound about the same. They should stick to the issue at hand, and try to win on the merit of their points.

Re:Steve Jobs isn’t our Dad by floppydisk on Saturday July 09, 2011 @08:52PM (#2746725)
This will turn out to being a strong argument for Apple that they pioneered the use of App Store to describe a store for mobile applications. If someone can find prior at least one prior instance of the phrase App Store being used in the context of software, GetJar, Amazon, and other users of the phrase might have a case of it being a common term. (standard disclaimer: IANAL)
Re:Steve Jobs isn’t our Dad by ignifero on Saturday July 09, 2011 @11:16AM (#2745696)
I believe they are overreacting, but on the other hand, if they don't cease, the cost of a litigation by apple might hurt them significantly.

What i dont get is why apple doesn't just rename their store to something distinctive, since it's obvious they are going to create lots of confusion by using 2 words that have been extensively used in the same business and similar contexts in the past, and they'll keep stumbling with that application. It's not like their new name won't become a household name within a month (given the extensive media coverage they get).

Re:Steve Jobs isn’t our Dad by amalcon on Saturday July 09, 2011 @11:26AM (#2745718)
They have already spent many marketing dollars on "App Store". They are probably just hesitant to write that off.
Re:Steve Jobs isn’t our Dad by ignifero on Saturday July 09, 2011 @11:31AM (#2745729)
they did the same for apple TV, i dont see it as a big deal.
Re:Steve Jobs isn’t our Dad by GHFigs on Saturday July 09, 2011 @01:28PM (#2745920)
They changed iTV to AppleTV before the product launched, not after three years.
Re:Steve Jobs isn’t our Dad by amalcon on Saturday July 09, 2011 @11:55AM (#2745764)
Oh yes, I'm sure they will if push comes to shove. It only makes sense (from a business perspective) to try to avoid that write-off, at least while the costs are low.
Re:Steve Jobs isn’t our Dad by bakbak on Saturday July 09, 2011 @01:28PM (#2745919)
Also Federal Judge rejected Apple's bid for injunction against Amazon for using the term "App Store".... So why are they after the small people like GetJar??
Re:Steve Jobs isn’t our Dad by saurik on Saturday July 09, 2011 @02:31PM (#2746069)
Lest your comment cause any confusion, it should be made clear that the court denied their request for a /preliminary/ injunction (which seems to be very common, but you request it anyway); but, as far as I understand the situation, the judge agreed to hear the case and, after all arguments are weighed, Amazon could still well lose.

The idea is that the case does not seem obvious enough and important enough to stop Amazon from using the term /before/ Apple wins the lawsuit (which is what would make this a "preliminary" injunction), but the judge actually went ahead and claimed that Apple seemed to have at least some merit to their argument.

Re:Steve Jobs isn’t our Dad by cshenoy on Saturday July 09, 2011 @01:56PM (#2745986)
>So why are they after the small people like GetJar??

To be consistent. They're not out to get Amazon. They're out to own the term "App Store" and are proving it by going after anyone who tries to use it. So in court they can say that it isn't just the big guys that are infringing but also smaller players.

Re:Steve Jobs isn’t our Dad by shareme on Saturday July 09, 2011 @02:10PM (#2746024)
but they lost that right with the Amazon judgement, the original question remains why now go after anyone using Appstore words combination?
Re:Steve Jobs isn’t our Dad by 0x44 on Saturday July 09, 2011 @02:28PM (#2746065)
The Amazon judgment only denied the preliminary injunction, it didn't resolve the ownership of the trademark (if any). The case is still on-going and Apple may introduce additional evidence as the case continues.