Requiring a purchase through Amazon would drastically cut down on the number of reviews they would get; lots of people own lots of books and movies and albums they purchased before Amazon existed and can give good reviews of them. I don't think it's reasonable to expect Amazon to shut those reviews out.
I don't think so. For a very popular book, the resources needed for this would be enormous, as there would be thousands of other, legitimate buyers.
For less popular books, noone would bother anyways.
Of course giving a bully pulpit to people who can leave consequence-free complaints and negative feedback is key to Amazon's bogus sense of "community".
So following your protocol would get rid of these useful reviews which benefit me and others.
In the case being discussed, the customers that returned it as "not as described" did in fact purchase it from amazon, otherwise they would not be able to return it to amazon. So they would still be included.
I do agree with your view (directly below at the time of writing) that the root problem may be Amazon's refund mechanism which requires you to provide a reason. "Not as described" covers everything from "you said it was a book, I received a bag of carrots" to "I didn't understand it" or "I didn't agree with it".
I absolutely love Amazon, but they need preventive measures against these forms of manipulation.
For example:
- Prevent people who haven't bought the book from Amazon to leave a review. People may still abuse the review system, but it will be less people, and they'll make the author and publisher slightly richer in the process.
- If you complain about a book not being as good as advertised, you need to provide proof. Explain in detail what is wrong with it, and provide photographic proof, a scan, or send the book back for inspection. Issue a refund by all means, but don't just trust them and pull the book from the shelves.
Right now, anyone could tank any new book published on Amazon with very little work on their part.