News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Kelly Criterion – how to calculate optimal bet sizes by LudwigNagasena on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @09:20PM (#27455639)
Kelly Criterion maximizes the wealth in the long-run. It doesn’t take asymmetric utility into account. It just happens to coincide with log-utility. If there is a fixed amount of bets the Kelly criterion will be suboptimal, but as the number of bets grows the optimal strategy will asymptotically reach the Kelly criterion.
Re:Kelly Criterion – how to calculate optimal bet sizes by srinivgp on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @10:38PM (#27456095)
It does not. It maximizes log-wealth. Maximizing expected wealth gives a strategy which results in $0 a lot of the time but much much more than Kelly occasionally, achieving a higher average wealth. Kelly gives that up, getting far less expectation of actual wealth, but far more expectation of log-wealth (which is -inf at $0 so avoids the $0 results). If you don't believe this, pick any one scenario and actually do the math, take the limits, etc.
Re:Kelly Criterion – how to calculate optimal bet sizes by LudwigNagasena on Thursday June 10, 2021 @12:40AM (#27456721)
> It does not. It maximizes log-wealth. Maximizing expected wealth gives a strategy which results in $0 a lot of the time but much much more than Kelly occasionally, achieving a higher average wealth.

Log utility function is u(w) = log(w), that’s what it is called in economics. Surely maximizing log of wealth means you are maximizing log utility function.

> Kelly gives that up, getting far less expectation of actual wealth, but far more expectation of log-wealth (which is -inf at $0 so avoids the $0 results).

That’s a crucial misunderstanding of the Kelly’s result. He doesn’t give anything up. He showed than in a nonterminating game the strategy of betting as if you have log utility will give you superior results to any other strategy in terms of long-term wealth growth. What if the game is terminating? Well, in that case you need to know the utility function of the gambler to determine a superior strategy. But in a non-terminating game it is a bit irrelevant because almost all strategies will lead to infinite utility.

Re:Kelly Criterion – how to calculate optimal bet sizes by eru on Thursday June 10, 2021 @01:45AM (#27457164)
(If memory serves right), for bets that either win or double, the Kelly criterion is equivalent to maximize the median wins. Which coincidentally also maximizes expected log wins.
Re:Kelly Criterion – how to calculate optimal bet sizes by kqr on Thursday June 10, 2021 @01:50AM (#27457193)
That's an interesting connection! I've heard risk managers talk about how people put too much faith in the mean outcome and don't focus enough on the median outcome. I didn't know there's a correspondence to the Kelly criterion.
Re:Kelly Criterion – how to calculate optimal bet sizes by eru on Thursday June 10, 2021 @01:18PM (#27463094)