News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Surveilled Student by version_five on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @06:31PM (#27454142)
> “When you consider the hundreds of thousands of people who have died in this pandemic, is it too much to ask to share your heart rate or temperature?”

This is honestly disgusting, it's the worst kind of lazy "think of the children" style rhetoric. I'd like to think this kind of argument stands on it's own as ridiculous, I guess we'll see.

Re:The Surveilled Student by alert0 on Friday June 11, 2021 @02:03AM (#27469850)
I am really sick of the word share. Share your data with us, share your heart rate with us, we just share this with a few of our partners. Sharing is caring, I guess.
Re:The Surveilled Student by Red_Leaves_Flyy on Friday June 11, 2021 @09:04AM (#27472754)
An appropriate response to a company asking anyone to share anything is asking for revenue share.
Re:The Surveilled Student by taneq on Friday June 11, 2021 @11:20AM (#27474553)
I mean we're sharing things, after all. It only seems fair.
Re:The Surveilled Student by alibarber on Friday June 11, 2021 @02:33AM (#27470009)
Yes I’ve struggled to take it seriously since day one - ‘the sharing economy’, like I’m paying you to rent a room in your house (Airbnb). That’s just ‘the economy’.
Re:The Surveilled Student by jjeaff on Friday June 11, 2021 @03:09AM (#27470211)
I think maybe they mean something along the lines of, you, the individual, provide the capital and the labor and take on the risk, and then you "share" some or most of the revenue with us.
Re:The Surveilled Student by BostonEnginerd on Friday June 11, 2021 @08:02AM (#27472147)
That’s my biggest issue with “sharing” economy companies. They are asking people to take on enormous risks -buying homes and cars - and then just algorithmically delist them when a problem occurs with no liability.
Re:The Surveilled Student by blacksmith_tb on Friday June 11, 2021 @01:57PM (#27476503)
Yes, that's pretty much the business model right there - taking advantage of loopholes in the regulations (until they're patched), it's version 2.0 of 'privatize the profits, socialize the costs'.
Re:The Surveilled Student by eesmith on Friday June 11, 2021 @02:51AM (#27470119)
Agreed. In the previous paragraph to that quote:

> As he sees it, handing over health information is a relatively small price to pay if it means halting the spread of a virus that has ravaged the nation.

That "if" is doing a lot of work. Does BioButton actually help? Does it help even after mass vaccinations?

If it doesn't help, then why pay any price, no matter how small?

Or, just after what you quoted:

> He says the wearable technology seemed the least invasive way to catch symptoms early and give students tools to know if they might have early signs of, or potential exposure to, Covid-19.

How many false positives will it give? If there are 100 false positives to one true positive, then the signal will be drowned out in the noise.

Re:The Surveilled Student by visarga on Friday June 11, 2021 @03:41AM (#27470403)
> How many false positives will it give? If there are 100 false positives to one true positive, then the signal will be drowned out in the noise.

On the other hand the consequences of a false positive are much smaller than those of a false negative. Inconvenience vs serious health problems or death.

Re:The Surveilled Student by eesmith on Friday June 11, 2021 @04:28AM (#27470675)
Absolutely this requires a cost-benefits analysis!

So, what is the false positive rate? I pulled the 100-to-1 out of my ass. Maybe it's 10K-to-1 or only 5-to-1. Maybe the false negative rate is 19-to-1, which would also make it rather useless. Dunno. Does the school know? Is that information public? Sure would be nice to have, yes?

What does "inconvenience" mean? I think you're talking about inconvenience for the students. If so, I want you to consider what "inconvenience" means for the school administration.

They have many policies they could enforce. They could have mandatory campus-wide testing every three days, and if someone tests positive then the campus is closed until tests are negative for three weeks, and during that time all on-campus residents are in quarantine, and classes switch to 100% remote teaching.

Inconvenient, yes? But if the question is simply "Inconvenience vs serious health problems or death" then surely this inconvenience they could put up with, yes? It'll surely be more effective than this BioButton!

Instead, it sounds like the administration wants something which is more convenient and cheaper to their budget. If so, shouldn't they demonstrate that this convenience isn't some sort of high-tech smoke&mirrors to avoid paying for something that is actually effective?

Re:The Surveilled Student by elliekelly on Friday June 11, 2021 @08:49AM (#27472567)
I think it depends. I have lupus so I’ve got a low grade fever pretty frequently even though for the most part I’m perfectly fine. I’m certainly not contagious. In the early days of the pandemic I was turned away once — in front of everyone! The judgment I felt from the others in line was awful. Like I’d done something wrong for being unable to control sometime completely beyond my control. The anxiety from that one experience was enough to keep me home unless I had absolutely no choice but to go somewhere. It was certainly more than just an “inconvenience” to me and my family and no one around me was ever at risk of death because I had been diligent in masking and social distancing from the beginning.
Re:The Surveilled Student by hobs on Friday June 11, 2021 @09:05AM (#27472776)
And while your experience was poor the practice of turning away those with a fever is a sane best practice.

It happened one time in am embarrassing manner, and that sucks, but when you put your grief next to the millions of people that died we can probably just continue to do this thing and deal with the embarrassing outcomes as they crop up.

Re:The Surveilled Student by ameister14 on Friday June 11, 2021 @11:17AM (#27474514)
>It happened one time in am embarrassing manner, and that sucks, but when you put your grief next to the millions of people that died we can probably just continue to do this thing and deal with the embarrassing outcomes as they crop up.

That's only valid if the millions of people that died would not have died had people been turned away with fevers. From my understanding that is not the case.

Re:The Surveilled Student by elliekelly on Friday June 11, 2021 @10:09AM (#27473555)
Yes, for you the embarrassing outcome is a one-off. But for me (and others) it was a distinct possibility every single time I left the house. Do you see the difference?
Re:The Surveilled Student by hobs on Friday June 11, 2021 @10:55AM (#27474236)
There's no difference except in my miscommunication - I used the term once because you described it as a single event, I did not mean to imply that it could not happen again or wasnt happening often and inopportunely, but instead to comment on the contrast between a measured event that sucks and millions of measured events that suck way more.
Re:The Surveilled Student by TeeMassive on Friday June 11, 2021 @01:40AM (#27469712)
And young adults are among the least affected. There are no justifications for this kind of medical surveillance.
Re:The Surveilled Student by woofie11 on Friday June 11, 2021 @08:28AM (#27472366)
There are perfectly good justifications: More Americans died than combat deaths in WWII at this point. Young Americans can be permanently disabled, and can share diseases with old professors.

There are also perfectly good justifications for not wanting a police state.

Until both sides understand that the other side has a point, we're not going to land anywhere reasonable.

If we had 100% compliance with the easy things:

* Social distancing of 6 feet

* Universal usage of 80% or more effective masks

* Vaccines

* Everything that can be done outdoors is

We probably wouldn't need the hard things.

Reasonable measures by everyone are far more effective than part of the population throwing all precautions to the wind, and part insisting on a draconian police state.

I'm concerned about economic shutdowns, closing schools, failing businesses, police state measures, and similar. Avoiding those means we all need to acknowledge the very real risk of COVID19, and while we might not agree with medical surveillance, that the people pushing for it have different values but aren't crazy.

Re:The Surveilled Student by visarga on Friday June 11, 2021 @03:39AM (#27470395)
Is the privacy of many more important than the life of few?
Re:The Surveilled Student by textgel on Friday June 11, 2021 @04:07AM (#27470535)
Yes. Obviously. There's plenty of privacy destroying actions a society could take that would "save lives" but we don't do these exactly because of the encroachment on civil liberties they would entail.
Re:The Surveilled Student by strken on Friday June 11, 2021 @04:52AM (#27470831)
That's a false dichotomy between option A), have your students sit exams in person and kill people, and option B), grossly invade your students' privacy with obnoxious spyware. Option C), just trust your students to take exams at home and slightly dilute the signal of your test scores, has always been on the table and is a totally viable alternative.
Re:The Surveilled Student by GeneralMayhem on Friday June 11, 2021 @03:53AM (#27470469)
Is giving up your privacy bringing them back to life? The problem isn't the relative weighting, it's the implication that they're in any way linked.
Re:The Surveilled Student by meowster on Friday June 11, 2021 @08:56AM (#27472642)
Is it easier to kill people who have no privacy? History shows us the answer to that question is "yes".
Re:The Surveilled Student by totetsu on Friday June 11, 2021 @09:11AM (#27472824)
Are there any simple generally understandable comebacks to cheap rhetorical tricks like this?
Re:The Surveilled Student by dabbledash on Friday June 11, 2021 @09:14AM (#27472867)
I think the only move is to answer it honestly. It isn’t even a trick really; it gets to the heart of the matter.
Re:The Surveilled Student by MikeUt on Friday June 11, 2021 @07:37AM (#27471916)
If you answer "no", the same logic can be used to strip you of all your rights. How much domestic violence and murder could be prevented if every home was required to have cameras and microphones installed?
Re:The Surveilled Student by stefan_ on Friday June 11, 2021 @05:07AM (#27470915)
There is no fucking connection between the two. We can have privacy and no deaths.
Re:The Surveilled Student by dabbledash on Friday June 11, 2021 @09:13AM (#27472850)
Yes.

I said it about the Patriot Act and I say it about this.

Re:The Surveilled Student by aero142 on Friday June 11, 2021 @10:42AM (#27474030)
These ideas aren't so bad when they are voluntary, but that is never enough. There is inherently a power behind this where a small group needs to force a large group to do what they say.
Re:The Surveilled Student by adolph on Friday June 11, 2021 @10:17AM (#27473670)
> Is the privacy of many more important than the life of few?

That's a judgement call to which people will have different reactions.

One way to look at it is to ask if there are other mechanisms to accomplish the same/similar goal, then ask which of these mechanisms is most aligned with our values.

A recent Lex Fridman interview of Po-Shen Loh [0] covered a privacy protecting NPI approach. An interesting aspect of the approach is that it works with people's self-interest of taking steps to stay healthy instead of attempting to work against people's self-interest in not being quarantined.

0. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6z1JwZbX4dQ

1. https://www.novid.org/

2. https://www.poshenloh.com/

Re:The Surveilled Student by greatgib on Friday June 11, 2021 @05:06AM (#27470912)
Just consider the number of persons that died in the history fighting to earn and preserve your privacy!
Re:The Surveilled Student by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Friday June 11, 2021 @10:01AM (#27473427)
Unlike other posters, I think this is a valid question. I mean, it's heart rate and temperature, not your porn habits or diary or whatever. If the availability of that data could potentially save many lives, why is it so bad to gather it?

I mean, if we're in favor of universal health care where, by some rhetoric, we're forcing people at gunpoint to give their money to save others, why is this so bad?

Re:The Surveilled Student by textgel on Friday June 11, 2021 @10:14AM (#27473626)
Because those who want "just heart rate and temperature" will want more in future. We aren't setting that precedent and opening up the possibility for more.
Re:The Surveilled Student by dabbledash on Friday June 11, 2021 @10:53AM (#27474214)
This is like saying “it’s just metadata, what could it reveal.”

As for heart rate and temperature, having this info over time can show:

When were you sleeping, active, potentially emotional?

When did a woman ovulate? Is she pregnant now? Did she have a miscarriage? Or maybe an abortion?

Re:The Surveilled Student by fuzzer37 on Friday June 11, 2021 @11:05AM (#27474367)
Unequivocally, yes.
Re:The Surveilled Student by wolverine876 on Friday June 11, 2021 @01:11PM (#27475938)
We must make these judgments and trade-offs all the time in society. We surrender freedoms regularly: You aren't free to drive on the wrong side of the road; you have to surrender personal info for a credit card, passport, plane/train/bus ticket; if you have another deadly, highly contagious disease, you can be quarantined.

I don't love the tone, but the number of deaths is an indicator of cost when considering the trade-off.