News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tell HN: SMS-based two-factor authentication is not secure by rawgabbit on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @12:13PM (#27449620)
As others have said, it is not that SMS 2FA is insecure; it is that thieves have figured out how to defeat it using SIM jacking and a bit of facebooking and googling. It is now trivial to figure out your home town, your favorite pet, etc. Also as others have said, the current alternatives have their problems. What if you lose all your Yubi keys? What if your phone was accidentally wiped and you never got around to backing it up? You cannot prove you are you and so customer support cannot help you. Google, Microsoft, and Apple are not known for helping consumers get themselves out of this catch-22.

It is a mistake to ask consumers to protect, backup, and secure their digital lives themselves. Consumers don't have the time or skills to keep up with the hackers. If Apple, Google, ATT, Verizon etc. cannot provide digital security, this is an opportunity for someone else to step in. My personal suggestion is this is a ripe opportunity for someone like the US Post Office or Department of Motor Vehicles. Consumers would go to the US Post Office or DMV and purchase a Yubi key from them. The additional value they add, is they can verify the identity of the consumers who is purchasing the Yubi key and replace the key if it is lost/stolen. Similar to how they process driver licenses or passports. This service is optional and would actually cost money. I would gladly pay a monthly fee for this peace of mind.

Re:Tell HN: SMS-based two-factor authentication is not secure by jrochkind1 on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @03:15PM (#27451892)
> As others have said, it is not that SMS 2FA is insecure; it is that thieves have figured out how to defeat it using SIM jacking and a bit of facebooking and googling

Uh... what does (in)secure mean to you?

Re:Tell HN: SMS-based two-factor authentication is not secure by bkdbkd on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @05:12PM (#27453284)
exactly. "its not that the lock is insecure, its just that sometimes thieves figure out how to make keys."
Re:Tell HN: SMS-based two-factor authentication is not secure by rawgabbit on Thursday June 10, 2021 @04:12PM (#27465186)
What I mean is that if thieves can defeat the lock on my door, it doesn’t mean my door lock is worthless. I still lock my door but I don’t rely on it exclusively for protection.
Re:Tell HN: SMS-based two-factor authentication is not secure by baybal2 on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @01:25PM (#27450609)
> As others have said, it is not that SMS 2FA is insecure; it is that thieves have figured out how to defeat it using SIM jacking and a bit of facebooking and googling

It is 100% insecure, and been exploited for nearly a decade.

1. Anybody with access to raw SS7 network can basically click a finger, and have you traffic rerouted

2. GSM interception gear is widely available

The person who invented "SMS verification" was a round idiot

Re:Tell HN: SMS-based two-factor authentication is not secure by spicybright on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @01:03PM (#27450342)
Absolutely this, but the service should act like a driver's license if you want people to actually use it.

Pay some $ for the key, renew it every 2 years for a fee, pay for a replacement if needed.

No one wants another monthly fee, taxes should keep the infra up like any other license.

Re:Tell HN: SMS-based two-factor authentication is not secure by danieljacksonno on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @01:13PM (#27450479)
We have something vaguely similar with "BankID" in Norway. It's a bank issued digital ID that submits a 2FA to your phone (not through SMS, but through some other system that takes over the whole screen - not sure what it is).

It's usable for almost all government agencies or official stuff online here, but I haven't seen anyone use it for third party auth as it costs roughly 10 cents per login for the service using it.

Re:Tell HN: SMS-based two-factor authentication is not secure by srhngpr on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @01:50PM (#27450911)
This has been rolled out and in use in British Columbia, Canada as well. We have a digital ID app for iOS and Android, which you verify your ID with first, then for government sites (e.g., health records), you login through this app instead - there are no emails, usernames, or passwords involved.
Re:Tell HN: SMS-based two-factor authentication is not secure by CapsAdmin on Thursday June 10, 2021 @02:30AM (#27457505)
From a usability standpoint it's not very good though. The experience differs from phone to phone and it kinda feels like a hack from a programmers point of view.

In Norway, Sparebank1 is pushing an app to get one-time codes now. I wonder if we'll see more of these in the future?

I use the Microsoft authenticator to get access to my Microsoft work account.

I bet if everyone starts making their own apps for one-time codes EU will demand a single app to do all of this.

Re:Tell HN: SMS-based two-factor authentication is not secure by Extigy on Thursday June 10, 2021 @08:22AM (#27459806)
>not through SMS, but through some other system that takes over the whole screen - not sure what it is

This sounds like it might be a so-called “flash” SMS. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SMS#Flash_SMS

Re:Tell HN: SMS-based two-factor authentication is not secure by unethical_ban on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @04:04PM (#27452443)
I only use 2FA if the service provides me with backup codes that I can put in my password safe, which has a unique, long password that is stored and backed up in several places.

If there is not a self-service recovery option for me losing my phone, I won't use it.

---

FWIW I keep a copy on my desktop and on my phone (Keepass) and sync them every few weeks. I try not to add new passwords to my phone copy in order to keep things simple, but Keepass can do diffs and merges.

"But if your safe is owned, then all your accounts are owned!" Yes, that's the balance I take. If someone is able to get my safe and use my bio auth on the phone OR otherwise crack it, I'm screwed.

Re:Tell HN: SMS-based two-factor authentication is not secure by matheusmoreira on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @06:10PM (#27453942)
> Consumers would go to the US Post Office or DMV and purchase a Yubi key from them.

> The additional value they add, is they can verify the identity of the consumers who is purchasing the Yubi key and replace the key if it is lost/stolen.

This is exactly how digital signatures work in my country. A government institution vouches for digital certificate companies which verify and certify people's identities. It can be used to file taxes and lawsuits, for example. To most people this is just yet another layer of bureaucracy.