News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Judge Denies Apple Request To Stop Amazon From Using "App... by anigbrowl on Friday July 08, 2011 @02:07PM (#2743450)
I share most of your feelings about trademarking policy, and find the linguistic land grab aspect of it disturbing. However, my feeling (very slightly) sorry for Apple is because of their ill-fortune with the trademark system that we have now, as opposed to the idealized trademark system of my dreams that would have clear and unambiguous standards on what could or could not be trademarked.

It seems to me that they really thought they were following the necessary steps to build a distinct brand. I can understand why this would seem very important to them, because titles can be strangely personal things, notwithstanding the existence of the naming/branding businesses and so on. I used to work in the film business, and surprisingly enough, you can't (in general) get copyright or trademark protection for movie titles. This is a problem for any writer or producer without the backing of a studio, so in the trade you'll often see references to 'untitled Paul Producer project' - Paul Producer probably has a great title, but doesn't have the resources to stop someone else with more money from from pinching it and launching a marketing campaign year ahead of release. You'd be surprised how often this happens.

If you're interested, here's a good article on that issue, though not without a few minor errors: http://troygould.com/layouts/50/graphics/handel_la_lawyer.pd...

There are no comments on this comment yet.