You're saying that because of the lack of transparency in the bidding process when it was shoved through "as a COVID emergency" we're not in a particular position to say that this vendor wasn't best for the job?
Maybe you are correct. Maybe we just need more faith in the vendor selection honesty of a government that recently contracted the services of a ferry company that didn't own any actual ferries.
No, I am not saying that at all. Please cite where I said that there was a lack of transparency. I only said that the parent poster would need information in order to make a case, and without that information no case could be made. I have no idea how transparent the process was and whether the relevant oversight controls were properly enforced, nor did I make any claims or assumptions about that, although it sounds like you have some assumptions of your own. If so, please back them up -- if you think there was impropriety in the bidding process, then again some evidence is called for.
This:
>without knowing specifics about the bidding process
Something we don't know because of the lack of transparency, which is (partly) why OpenDemocracy raised a lawsuit.
What would you be referring to if not that?
Has it ever had the opportunity to try?
Many projects to funnel government money into private companies have not delivered results. Has a large, in-house NHS IT project failed?
The GCloud contracts were released following FOI requests.
I disagree wholeheartedly
This is not an insult to the NHS. How on earth could they become good at something like that given that it is a healthcare system? They are also not good at maintaining cellular towers, water treatment, hospital construction, manufacturing their own uniforms, or their own medical equipment. So they pay other firms to provide these products to them rather than trying to adopt an autarky-based model.
Now you could argue that they should have hired another vendor, but without knowing specifics about the bidding process and which other vendors were competing, you are not really in a position to say that this particular vendor wasn't the best for the job.