News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:“AI promised to revolutionize radiology but so far its fa... by kspacewalk2 on Monday June 07, 2021 @11:13AM (#27423530)
Radiologists most definitely are trying. Our institute's entire medical imaging research arm is driven by several very motivated practicing radiologists. You just misunderstand what it is that they do, fundamentally. Diddling with some pics and publishing papers is just not in the same league as making medical diagnoses. A lot is riding on their understanding every little artifact of the algorithm/approach that gives them a modified image to interpret. They will never accept black-box automagic, and they will always evaluate the benefits of novel algorithms together with the drawbacks of having to get used to their quirks and opaque artifacts, possibly with outcomes impacted and/or lives lost in the process. Where the risk/benefit analysis is clear, they do adopt plenty of common-sense automation tools for a very simple reason - they get paid per scan read, so their time is (lots of) money, to them.
Re:“AI promised to revolutionize radiology but so far its fa... by caddemon on Monday June 07, 2021 @11:52AM (#27424010)
I don't think the blame falls on practicing radiologists, but the OP is absolutely correct that medical data is way too inaccessible. It is often impossible to get your own raw data, and even worse it is sometimes impossible to share that data with another doctor. Two large hospitals in major US cities apparently can't share EEG data because they use different software to read it. Guess who wins when all your prior data gets essentially thrown out? It's not the insurance companies, and it's certainly not you - it's the new hospital.

How realistic it is to have ML involved in reading radiology results in theory I don't know, but the larger point is that in practice it is sure as hell not going to happen until patients have real access to do what they please with their own data. Not only am I pissed I can't have my own EEG data, but I also would gladly contribute it to a database for development of new tools, or any other research study that asked. But there is essentially no way to even do that, at least at either institution I've asked. Just think of all the data that is being utterly wasted right now!

Re:“AI promised to revolutionize radiology but so far its fa... by visarga on Monday June 07, 2021 @01:13PM (#27425140)
>I also would gladly contribute it to a database for development of new tools, or any other research study that asked

This should be a standard question in the medical file like those related to organ donation.

Re:“AI promised to revolutionize radiology but so far its fa... by RobertDeNiro on Monday June 07, 2021 @12:41PM (#27424672)
The number of patients that are interested in viewing or accessing their own data has to be negligible. Last time I got an Xray they actually gave me a DVD of the imaging itself. I remember looking at it, I thought it was neat, but ultimately there was little use in there for me. I dont know what % of patients have bothered to look at it.
Re:“AI promised to revolutionize radiology but so far its fa... by xkjkls on Monday June 07, 2021 @12:45PM (#27424723)
Viewing their own raw data may be negligible, but sharing between medical professionals is a relatively common and necessary practice. Currently it is extremely difficult to get one doctor to share medical information with another, and it shouldn't be.
Re:“AI promised to revolutionize radiology but so far its fa... by nradov on Monday June 07, 2021 @01:27PM (#27425332)
Provider organizations are understandably reluctant to accept removable media from unknown sources due to the risk of malware. Many of the computers that doctors use don't have DVD drives or they're disabled for security.
Re:“AI promised to revolutionize radiology but so far its fa... by xkjkls on Thursday June 10, 2021 @11:23AM (#27461781)
Cloud is still a thing.
Re:“AI promised to revolutionize radiology but so far its fa... by deeviant on Monday June 07, 2021 @01:37PM (#27425473)
It's not about the patient reviewing their own data as much as it is about the patient having easy access to their data and can easily share that data with other consumers of it (i.e. some AI based interpretation service)
Re:“AI promised to revolutionize radiology but so far its fa... by phobosanomaly on Monday June 07, 2021 @02:08PM (#27425934)
'Easy access' is scary for hospitals because it means increased possibility of HIPAA violations.
Re:“AI promised to revolutionize radiology but so far its fa... by vel0city on Monday June 07, 2021 @10:13PM (#27429884)
The P in HIPAA stands for portability. It should be a HIPAA violation for them to not give me the original data sets for my healthcare when I request them in person.
Re:“AI promised to revolutionize radiology but so far its fa... by vmception on Monday June 07, 2021 @05:44PM (#27427459)
The data will get better

Healthkit ftw

Re:“AI promised to revolutionize radiology but so far its fa... by an_opabinia on Monday June 07, 2021 @11:59AM (#27424096)
> patients have real access to do what they please with their own data... contribute it to a database...

Misconception #2 is that there's some "data moat" or whatever.

Re:“AI promised to revolutionize radiology but so far its fa... by caddemon on Monday June 07, 2021 @12:01PM (#27424129)
I am aware there isn't, what I'm saying is there should be - particularly for dense datatypes like EEG that we probably aren't fully leveraging at the moment.
Re:“AI promised to revolutionize radiology but so far its fa... by potatoman22 on Monday June 07, 2021 @11:32PM (#27430368)
That's false. Both Epic and Cerner, the largest EMR companies, have databases of millions and millions of patients. They're used for research, and stuff.
Re:“AI promised to revolutionize radiology but so far its fa... by caddemon on Tuesday June 15, 2021 @07:20PM (#27522891)
Yeah but all the EMR data I've seen have just been doctor notes, some prescription info, standard clinical scales, etc. Not that this can't be interesting, but there's not really a major database for richer data types like imaging or EEG (AFAIK)