News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sorry everybody, I failed with you by mumblemumble on Monday June 07, 2021 @10:03AM (#27422728)
I've actively resisted open sourcing some things I've written at work - including stuff that I'm sure others would like - precisely because of fears that it would be a career-limiting move. For my employer, these libraries are only valuable to the extent that they help us build things for which we can charge money. An open source library would not be one of those things, but it would take time (and therefore company money) to maintain such a thing. So putting myself in a position to be maintaining open source software on company time has the potential to greatly reduce my value to the company.
Re:Sorry everybody, I failed with you by snth on Monday June 07, 2021 @10:23AM (#27422945)
I think getting your name and work out in the world with open source work is a career _advancing_ move.
Re:Sorry everybody, I failed with you by mumblemumble on Monday June 07, 2021 @10:56AM (#27423328)
I've honestly never been at a job interview where people gave a crap about my open source contributions. They're typically much more interested in hearing war stories from the closed source projects I've worked on.

The thing about open source projects is, they tend to be slightly generic things like "file format," "widget library," or "machine learning algorithm" that most companies see as the kind of thing they can typically get for free from open source. (They're not wrong there - the fact that we're talking about my open source contributions here makes it almost tautological.) They also tend to involve the sorts of generic programming skills that, by virtue of being stuff that we all know at least somewhat well, aren't all that valuable. Supply and demand works with job skills, too.

By contrast, my commercial work tends to involve a lot of specialized knowledge that's quite uncommon, and also tends to produce the kinds of software that people are quite happy to pay a lot of money for.

Re:Sorry everybody, I failed with you by autarch on Monday June 07, 2021 @11:05AM (#27423421)
> I've honestly never been at a job interview where people gave a crap about my open source contributions. They're typically much more interested in hearing war stories from the closed source projects I've worked on.

Counterpoint - I have. Many times.

I created some Perl libraries (most notable <a href="https://metacpan.org/dist/DateTime">DateTime</a> and <a href="https://metacpan.org/dist/Log-Dispatch">Log-Dispatch</a>) that were used by a huge percentage of companies using Perl for applications (as opposed to simple scripts or sysadmin). This often came up in interviews, and I'm sure it helped me get more and better offers.

Nowadays, as fewer companies are using Perl for applications, it's probably less helpful, but it doesn't hurt.

Re:Sorry everybody, I failed with you by deckard1 on Monday June 07, 2021 @01:08PM (#27425084)
To be fair, that's like the guy that wrote moment-js or jQuery. I've worked at a number of Perl-based companies and every single one used DateTime (I'm a huge fan, btw). Something like that is going to be noticeable on a resume. Assuming they have some experience with Perl.

There was a company I know of that was advertising in their job postings that the guy that wrote Perl's DBI once worked for them or was their CTO or whatever. That was about 6 years ago, so not that far off.

Re:Sorry everybody, I failed with you by mumblemumble on Monday June 07, 2021 @11:10AM (#27423498)
Ha. I had actually thought about mentioning that this situation seemed to be very different 20 years ago, but decided I had already done enough blathering.

But, anyway, yeah - I think that this was different 20 years ago, back when open source hadn't quite completely disrupted the software industry and companies didn't yet understand the economics of open source.

Re:Sorry everybody, I failed with you by johnnyanmac on Monday June 07, 2021 @07:36PM (#27428767)
I mean, I worked with someone who creates a very high profile OSS project, and I'm sure it's a big reason he got hired to where he is.

I'll never say OSS is an optimal career path unless you are doing something extremely specialized (which to be fair, he is). But it sure can open doors for you even today if that's something you're passionate in. For me, I got around without any OSS, so it's more like a post-career plan now to help out some beloved repos.

(as long as you're not stupid, like showing your botting repository to an online game studio).

Re:Sorry everybody, I failed with you by autarch on Monday June 07, 2021 @11:15AM (#27423557)
This still helped me as recently as 2017, so it's not like this stopped being true 20 years ago.
Re:Sorry everybody, I failed with you by loup-vaillant on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @10:51AM (#27435943)
> I've honestly never been at a job interview where people gave a crap about my open source contributions.

They gave a crap about mine, I believe for two reasons: first, I put it in the middle of my CV, at the same level as my regular job. This basically forces everyone to talk about it. Second, Monocypher is a crypto library, and cryptography tends impress people.

Re:Sorry everybody, I failed with you by pizza234 on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @04:31AM (#27431911)
I can't speak for other companies, but as a person involved in hiring, open source is very valuable to me.

It's not valuable in terms of potential to market/usefulness/popularity, rather, because I can see very clearly how a person designs/writes code, and how they solve problems, when they have plenty of time; I can also see other non-technical aspects, like how they structure their git history (which, to me, has lot of signals).

People (rightfully) dislikes to show their capacity under pressure; open source is the way to show it without pressure :)