Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w...
by fencepost on Monday June 07, 2021 @02:49PM
(#27426500)
Firing on and sinking a flagged vessel and possibly killing crew (also, how do you then prove that you DIDN'T kill anyone?) is exactly the kind of thing that gets governments openly involved. Seizing a private vessel and fining the owners? That's a civil matter and while there may be backroom discussions everything stays civil.
"The military of Country X is firing on and sinking our country's vessels" is much more likely to lead to retaliation. China may not have the navy or willingness to project power across the Pacific, but I guarantee they have the capability if focused to utterly destroy the computing infrastructure of the country - and while enthusiastic private parties may not get involved in civil penalties, "Argentina just declared war on us!" is a hell of a rallying cry.
Edit: also keep in mind that even governments are not monolithic entities with a single mind. Those costs are coming out of someone's budget.
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w...
by heartbeats on Monday June 07, 2021 @09:07PM
(#27429466)
Will China bother to defend their fishing boats, though? Are they that entrenched in the governmental structure, or are they basically just petty thugs?
Re:Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s w...
by CameronNemo on Sunday June 06, 2021 @10:09PM
(#27418253)
Sinking the boat would also provide proof that the vessel was invading.
Game-theoretically, it seems preferable to sink them without any warning.
Consider: the fines would only be paid if they are less than the cost of acquiring a new ship. So if they have to pay fines of 90% of the value, you're still saving them 10% compared to getting a new ship. And if the fines are >100%, they would just ignore it and leave Argentina with the ship.
Unless Argentina can turn it into a revenue stream, sinking them unconditionally seems preferable. The Chinese fishing boats don't have anything to give them in a negotiation. All they have to give them is leaving the area, and that is accomplished by sinking the boats too.