Clearly we would need a graph with a bunch of data points representing the person's attraction to humans everywhere along the gender scale. For example, at a resolution of 0.1:
gender score: attractiveness
0.0: ----------------
0.1: ----------------
0.2: -------------
0.3: ---------
0.4: ---
0.5: --
0.6: ----------
0.7: ----
0.8: -
0.9: ----
1.0: --------------
And while we're at it, why don't we add scales for attractiveness due to body type, perceived youthfulness, hair color, etc. (Let's hope they can be considered independently. Dear god, the complexity if that weren't the case--I suspect it isn't...) Methinks this is a problem that could suck up as much, or as little, effort as you're willing to put into it.Some people--probably people who spend a lot of time dating, and who are attractive enough to be able to choose for whatever traits they want--would actually find useful the ability to specify things like that. Others might not care, or might not even know what difference most of these traits make to them (I would probably fall into this last category). Mmm, it might be interesting to see what the hardcore daters would discover about their own preferences (and how they might change over the course of dating). Does anyone know of any interesting studies or results in this area?
Making gender one-dimensional is of course richer than using a boolean flag, but I think the problem is even more complicated than that.
EDIT: as gjm11 states, I'm wrong and your scale is indeed two dimensional, as in one might feel a (wo)man and be attracted to a (wo)man.
[1] I normally don't use these funny gender-neutral pronouns, but here it seems called for.
EDIT According to the comment by walrus down the thread (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2741580), we should upgrade this system to use three numbers :).
You know, I thought that at firs too. I was going to say that it doesn't make sense to say a bisexual has B=0.5 and that we should have B_male and B_female. However, as I tried to think of a situation where you'd want to split that into two dimensions, I couldn't come up with one. As long as we read B as a relative preference it makes sense to say bisexuals have B = 0.5.
So, for example:
Hetero male: A=0.8, B=0.2
Gay male: A 0.7 b 0.9, or a 0.8 b 0.7
It's a convenient way to explain gender to nerds, and remember that there are error bars on each number that vary over a lifetime.