Re:The right tag for the job: why you should use semantic HTML
by coldtea on Sunday June 06, 2021 @04:36PM
(#27416087)
I don't see any reason to use semantic HTML. It's cargo cult.
At some point web designers (at the time in the early 00s web development was not as involved as it has been post Ajax) learned the term "semantic" and went wild with it (made you sound smart, and you could charge a little more than the unsophisticated shop down the road), without understanding the science behind data.
Instead we should have separation of concerns, with structured raw information (you know, like what we have in our relational and document databases), served with different represenations: for accessibility, for data access, for web, for syndication, for print, for reading devices, and so on.
Of course the web being the web, it needed to make this too in the most inefficient and multi-layered way (and leave it up to the web designers/devs to have "proper" semantic tags).
At some point web designers (at the time in the early 00s web development was not as involved as it has been post Ajax) learned the term "semantic" and went wild with it (made you sound smart, and you could charge a little more than the unsophisticated shop down the road), without understanding the science behind data.
Instead we should have separation of concerns, with structured raw information (you know, like what we have in our relational and document databases), served with different represenations: for accessibility, for data access, for web, for syndication, for print, for reading devices, and so on.
Of course the web being the web, it needed to make this too in the most inefficient and multi-layered way (and leave it up to the web designers/devs to have "proper" semantic tags).