News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Repeated Deaths of OOP (2015) by acdha on Sunday June 06, 2021 @01:29PM (#27414683)
> We could have a more interesting, robust debate, but poorly defined terms + bad faith means we get the same no true Scotsman rhetoric over and over, and it’s hopelessly dull.

If you want a healthy and robust debate, dismissing defenders of the most popular paradigm as always acting in bad faith is not how you get there.

This would also be a good way for you to learn more about the field. For example, is “just bad code” actually more prevalent due to OOP or because it’s the default paradigm for the most popular languages (Java, C#, Python, even JavaScript although that’s messy) and especially those used by the legions of lower-skilled developers cranking out business logic? Does FP reliably produce better results or is that more a function of the areas where the style is the most popular and, especially, a selection bias for developers with training & motivation to work on more than basic Jira-mill projects? (Lisp had a similar challenge for comparison: a large chunk of the developers you could hire were graduates of elite CS programs who would have performed above average with anything and it’s really hard to run a control study where, say, half of them spent a year building the same system in VB)

Note that I don’t think there’s a simple Boolean answer to any of those questions. I think FP is a useful technique but, like any tool, it is not perfect and a good developer should have enough experience to be flexible based on the problems and resources.

Re:The Repeated Deaths of OOP (2015) by throwaway894345 on Sunday June 06, 2021 @03:45PM (#27415715)
> If you want a healthy and robust debate, dismissing defenders of the most popular paradigm as always acting in bad faith is not how you get there.

(1) I'm not dismissing, I'm criticizing. (2) I'm very clearly not arguing that all OOP proponents are always acting in bad faith.

> This would also be a good way for you to learn more about the field. For example, is “just bad code” actually more prevalent due to OOP or because it’s the default paradigm for the most popular languages (Java, C#, Python, even JavaScript although that’s messy) and especially those used by the legions of lower-skilled developers cranking out business logic?

This is begging the question. The whole point is there's a semantic argument: is OOP defined by the features and design patterns (including the "bad code" design patterns) that are unique to OOP, or is OOP defined differently and this is the same kind of "bad code" that exists in other ecosystems?

But in whatever case, the debate rarely advances this far because we get mired in semantics, which is my broader point.

> I think FP is a useful technique but, like any tool, it is not perfect and a good developer should have enough experience to be flexible based on the problems and resources.

To be clear, I'm not an FP purist. I actually don't like very many FP languages, and indeed there are some values of "OOP" for which I could be called an OOP enthusiast (to the extent that one would be willing to call idiomatic Go or Rust, "OOP").

Re:The Repeated Deaths of OOP (2015) by acdha on Sunday June 06, 2021 @04:08PM (#27415880)
> I'm very clearly not arguing that all OOP proponents are always acting in bad faith.

You made sweeping unqualified assertions which are hard to reconcile with that claim:

“OOP proponents reliably turn the debate toward semantics rather than engaging with the substantial criticism”

“We could have a more interesting, robust debate, but poorly defined terms + bad faith means we get the same no true Scotsman rhetoric over and over, and it’s hopelessly dull.”

If that’s what you believe going in, it’s unsurprising you’re not finding better quality outcomes.

Re:The Repeated Deaths of OOP (2015) by throwaway894345 on Sunday June 06, 2021 @04:58PM (#27416258)
> If that’s what you believe going in, it’s unsurprising you’re not finding better quality outcomes.

It’s not what I believed going in, it’s a summary of my cumulative experiences.