I'm not sure what to say. I guess if people are upset about dogs in the Bay Area (or somewhere else) then that's up to owners in that area to fix? I have no idea about dogs or dog owners in the USA, and presumably neither does user "diggan" who has also been commenting and getting downvoted to oblivion, but who nevertheless I have a feeling is a responsible dog owner. The thing we took issue with was the idea that dogs should at all times in be on the leash. IMO that's quite irresponsible (many need exercise) and counterproductive (a dog who is rarely exercised will probably be hyperactive when taken out). To me it just sounds like a few people have had some experiences with bad dog owners, but instead of thinking "Wow that guy was an asshole" you're presuming "all dog owners are assholes" which is ... weird.