Re:Valid Signal privacy issues shrugged off while patches qu...
by UncleMeat on Saturday June 05, 2021 @02:44PM
(#27407555)
Configurable security posture is the sort of thing that got RSA into trouble. For the huge majority of users, opinionated security is a much better approach, even ignoring the maintenance problems of having special features.
The temporary access threat model is a common criticism that people use, but it is largely incoherent. Once you are making human judgements like "enough time to transfer a signal account but not enough time to install a rootkit" things quickly break down into meaninglessness.
Re:Valid Signal privacy issues shrugged off while patches qu...
by mindslight on Saturday June 05, 2021 @03:24PM
(#27407828)
I don't really like trusted computing, but it is part of the mobile security model. There's a distinction between Signal deliberately facilitating extraction of the keys, and having to break a device's security to do so.
So from that point of view it would be legitimate to argue that I might want to get notified if one of my contacts transfers his account. I can then double check : “Did you just transfer your signal account to a new device or was that an attacker?”
That might only be interesting for high-risk users though and could impair the UX. Why not make it optional?