News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Explainer: What is a global minimum tax and what will it ... by whiddershins on Saturday June 05, 2021 @10:23AM (#27405293)
I’ve never understood how taxing corporations isn’t just double taxation.

The corporations end up distributing the money to stakeholders who then owe taxes on it.

What would happen if corporate tax rates were 0% because ... they aren’t really people after all?

Re:Explainer: What is a global minimum tax and what will it ... by ajb on Saturday June 05, 2021 @10:38AM (#27405416)
Double taxation is a funny concept because the economy is cyclic anyway. If any given dollar could only be taxed once, eventually you'd run out of untaxed dollars to tax.
Re:Explainer: What is a global minimum tax and what will it ... by samstave on Saturday June 05, 2021 @11:29AM (#27405845)
So... wouldnt that mean that there should be a government MAXIMUM amount of taxes that can be collected?

Why are their taxes on every single transaction?

Re:Explainer: What is a global minimum tax and what will it ... by krastanov on Saturday June 05, 2021 @11:35AM (#27405897)
Because taxes are necessary and we just make up a rule that works in practice. This is not "foundations of logic", it is just "where can I shoehorn a tax so I can fund the public services and the military". It does not need to make sense when put in weird hypothetical made up edge cases.
Re:Explainer: What is a global minimum tax and what will it ... by jerry1979 on Saturday June 05, 2021 @10:48AM (#27405505)
Taxes on corporate net income should not count as "double taxation" because the corporation is legally distinct in nearly every way from its shareholders. That's the whole point of corporations. The corporation gets taxed once on net income because that corporation exists as a construct within govt structures. The shareholders get taxed because of the relationship they have with the corporation. It's literally fee for service.
Re:Explainer: What is a global minimum tax and what will it ... by weird-eye-issue on Saturday June 05, 2021 @11:17AM (#27405750)
This argument falls apart for flow through entities. They are essentially treated the same as the shareholders by the IRS but they are treated as distinct by other parts of the government, banks, courts, etc.

So what service are you actually paying for besides just... Getting taxed by the IRS?

Re:Explainer: What is a global minimum tax and what will it ... by jerry1979 on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @12:04AM (#27430541)
I do not have any professional expertise that would allow me to make recommendations or financial/legal advice. Do you know if these flow through entities provide any limits on liabilities for the people who benefit from owning the pass through entity? If so, I would consider that as a benefit.
Re:Explainer: What is a global minimum tax and what will it ... by weird-eye-issue on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @12:28AM (#27430639)
That's my point. They are not taxed separately but they do provide liability protection. In your other comment you made it sound like they are taxed separately and that was the cost to pay for being treated like a separate entity.
Re:Explainer: What is a global minimum tax and what will it ... by jerry1979 on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @10:13AM (#27435458)
It looks like I misunderstood your comment. The point I want to drive home is that when the government "backs" one entity, paying for that backing via taxes on net income should not count as double taxation because I consider that tax a fee to pay for that one entity. Whether the government offers some other kind of entity with different tax advantages is, to me, beside the point because as someone who is not a corporate tax expert, I have to assume that there must be some kind of advantage to running a C corp vs an llc.
Re:Explainer: What is a global minimum tax and what will it ... by acover on Saturday June 05, 2021 @10:29AM (#27405341)
Income tax and sales tax are double taxation.

Double taxation happens a lot. I don't think it's a good rule for determining if a tax is fair.

Re:Explainer: What is a global minimum tax and what will it ... by woodruffw on Saturday June 05, 2021 @10:31AM (#27405364)
Apart from the material question of whether or not it’s double taxation: why does it matter? Plenty of things are doubly taxed: I pay taxes once on my income, and then I pay it again when I exchange my income for goods or redeem any financial instrument that my income went into.
Re:Explainer: What is a global minimum tax and what will it ... by samstave on Saturday June 05, 2021 @11:32AM (#27405867)
Personally, I would say it matters because that scenario is BS.

Further, don't forget that while the IRS knows exactly how much you have made - they still require you to figure it out at the end of the year and then in all likelihood pay more taxes than what was taxed.

In scandanavian countries - their taxes are high - but at least the system is simple; they send you a summary of what you made, what you were taxed and you basically just sign it (according to some friends from there - I do not have first hand knowledge of how its actually done in Sweden/Norway/Finland)

Re:Explainer: What is a global minimum tax and what will it ... by woodruffw on Saturday June 05, 2021 @01:00PM (#27406677)
> Personally, I would say it matters because that scenario is BS.

Which scenario?

To be clear, I agree that the IRS’s guessing game system is ridiculous. I’d much prefer the Scandinavian system. But I’m not clear on what that has to do with double taxation, seeing how those countries do it as well (via VAT or any discretionary tax.) No country can accurately tax you ahead of time on discretionary spending, and I don’t believe any does.

Re:Explainer: What is a global minimum tax and what will it ... by skohan on Saturday June 05, 2021 @10:29AM (#27405342)
There's double taxation all the time. For instance, if I run a store, and I pay sales tax on what I sell, and then I pay income tax on net revenue, the income from the same transaction is taxed twice.
Re:Explainer: What is a global minimum tax and what will it ... by nemo44x on Saturday June 05, 2021 @10:58AM (#27405594)
And your employees are paid from that taxed income and that is taxed. When the employee buys something with that money that is taxed as is their dwelling via property tax. And the cycle continues.

I do wonder how long it takes for a dollar to be 100% taxed as it is exchanged. Transactional taxes certainly give government incentive to stoke consumption as the faster the dollar is exchanging hands the more tax revenue they are collecting.

Re:Explainer: What is a global minimum tax and what will it ... by indymike on Saturday June 05, 2021 @11:40AM (#27405940)
Nope. Employees are an expense. Expenses are subtracted from income before taxes are calculated.
Re:Explainer: What is a global minimum tax and what will it ... by nemo44x on Saturday June 05, 2021 @07:06PM (#27409166)
Yeah sort of. But whatever they are paid restarts the tax machine.

I’m not railing against taxes here. Just curious how long it takes the government to completely reconsider each dollar put into circulation.

Re:Explainer: What is a global minimum tax and what will it ... by mjw1007 on Saturday June 05, 2021 @10:57AM (#27405589)
As I understand it, many countries set the rate of tax on dividends, and on gains from selling shares, to be below the rate of income tax by roughly the rate of corporation tax.

In particular, things tend to be set up so that for small companies it doesn't make much difference whether the owner takes money out by paying themselves a salary or a dividend.

Re:Explainer: What is a global minimum tax and what will it ... by anamexis on Saturday June 05, 2021 @10:27AM (#27405318)
Who is saying it isn't double taxation?
Re:Explainer: What is a global minimum tax and what will it ... by ucha on Saturday June 05, 2021 @10:59AM (#27405605)
It's one of the reasons why dividend tax is much lower that income tax.
Re:Explainer: What is a global minimum tax and what will it ... by DudeInBasement on Saturday June 05, 2021 @10:49AM (#27405513)
It is, but it's there to protect the liability of the owners
Re:Explainer: What is a global minimum tax and what will it ... by ModernMech on Saturday June 05, 2021 @11:15AM (#27405734)
Taxes are incurred when money flows. It's taxed once when it flows to the corporation, and it's taxed again when it flows to the individual.