News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:John Carmack on JPEG by acdha on Friday June 04, 2021 @07:31PM (#27400328)
OpenJPEG has improved the situation a bit but I use JPEG 2000 as a cautionary example. The community had some good selling points but assume that meant inevitability and slacked off on browser compatibility, open source, and even interoperability. For the first decade or so you had to pay something like $1,500 to get a copy of the spec, too.

I work in the library/archiving space where people spent years trying to make this happen due to the compression wins, support for a good range of color depths and spaces, and the progressive decoding is perfect for browsing galleries of high-res images before zooming way into the one you wanted.

The frictional cost largely canceled that out: people don’t trust unreliable formats and the JP2 files which only opened in one of {Kakadu, Aware, Adobe} and couldn’t be used with any open source tools live long in the memory. Performance in Jasper was wretched … and while the vendors thought that’d boost sales, it seemed far more effective to me at getting people to use other formats instead.

These days, if anyone is talking about new image formats the first question is what they’re doing for open source (especially things like ImageMagick which half the world uses) and specifically browsers. A WASM polyfill for <picture> or <img srcset> is really critical because it means people don’t have to transcode everything for a handful of users.

Re:John Carmack on JPEG by matheusmoreira on Saturday June 05, 2021 @10:33AM (#27405376)
Proprietary stuff just isn't worth it. They erect so many barriers around the format and the specification that it's essentially impossible to get anything done.
Re:John Carmack on JPEG by radarsat1 on Saturday June 05, 2021 @12:25PM (#27406361)
This reminds me of Sony's minidisc technology. Such a cool product for its time but they purposely made it impossible to use and incompatible with everything.
Re:John Carmack on JPEG by matheusmoreira on Saturday June 05, 2021 @02:16PM (#27407350)
Sony UMDs too!
Re:John Carmack on JPEG by acdha on Saturday June 05, 2021 @11:29AM (#27405842)
That’s my general conclusion and it’s substantially more so for the library/archive case where long-term stability is so important. It’d be one thing if, say, a game found a format to be so much better when they control the encode and decode sides completely but once that’s not true it really needs a first-class open source implementation to even be considered.