News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Medium sees employee exits after CEO publishes ‘culture m... by spoonjim on Friday June 04, 2021 @11:59AM (#27394942)
You haven’t heard the term “silence is violence”? It’s not ironic. Anytime you see on a list of “demands” (which is a term that people feel very comfortable using) that includes “forcefully condemn X,” they are basically rejecting your choice to remain silent on the issue.

You may have never seen this in the workplace but it is increasingly common in some of the most coveted (or formerly so) employers like Google, Basecamp, Medium, etc.

Re:Medium sees employee exits after CEO publishes ‘culture m... by viraptor on Saturday June 05, 2021 @12:03AM (#27402053)
As usual, there's context to everything and these discussions often skip over it. In some extreme cases, silence is violence is correct, for many people that threshold will be in different places. In other context people may be abusing "silence is violence" as "you should support my pet issue I care about". There will be cases where people will have strong opinions about, like providing services to ICE - literally helping a violent organisation to be more efficient.

Ideas are not the same thing to people - some ignore it, some don't, some abuse it, some change it for different purposes.

Re:Medium sees employee exits after CEO publishes ‘culture m... by Aunche on Saturday June 05, 2021 @03:22AM (#27402967)
>There will be cases where people will have strong opinions about, like providing services to ICE - literally helping a violent organisation to be more efficient.

This is just "support my pet cause" with some added rationalization. The line of what constitutes as "being complicit" always conveniently ends where the majority of activists lie. You're bad if .1% of your company's revenue comes from a contract with a government organization, part of which enforces illegal immigration. However, if you sign this petition, your sins will be forgiven.

Re:Medium sees employee exits after CEO publishes ‘culture m... by viraptor on Saturday June 05, 2021 @03:44AM (#27403085)
I think you're generalising a bit and end up building an imaginary persona you believe in. Maybe some people think like that. But for example, in my case: I agree with it and I'm not an activist. "You're bad..." is wrong way to look at it. I'm against helping them rather than against taking their money. There are no sins to forgive but if there were, signing a petition is not a way to achieve it.

You presented your idea of the supporter of the quoted opinion and it turns out to be almost the opposite of the supporter you responded to.

Re:Medium sees employee exits after CEO publishes ‘culture m... by Aunche on Saturday June 05, 2021 @04:08AM (#27403193)
My characterization was intentionally facetious for my own amusement, but the core argument remains sound. If working for a company with an ICE contract counts as helping a violent organization, then you should also apply the "silence is violence" doctrine to activists who sign a petition but refuse to quit, yet nobody ever does.
Re:Medium sees employee exits after CEO publishes ‘culture m... by viraptor on Saturday June 05, 2021 @04:24AM (#27403258)
Some people believe they can push for change from inside. I'm not sure what do you mean by "nobody ever does" - we're commenting on an article about people quitting - and they will if they can't achieve the change they want. Others may not join in the first place due to political reasons. (I've refused 2 jobs at companies doing things I don't agree with)
Re:Medium sees employee exits after CEO publishes ‘culture m... by Aunche on Saturday June 05, 2021 @01:02PM (#27406694)
In this case, they are being paid to leave, so it's a commercial transaction rather than an act of holding themselves to a moral standard. Not taking a job or resigning from a job for political reasons would be such an act, but I don't see how that would be relevant to "silence is violence" if you aren't pressuring others to do the same.
Re:Medium sees employee exits after CEO publishes ‘culture m... by spoonjim on Saturday June 05, 2021 @12:23PM (#27406337)
You say “literally helping a violent organisation to be more efficient.” Someone else might say “Helping our nation protect its borders.” Neither person would be axiomatically correct because you’re arguing over opinions, not facts.
Re:Medium sees employee exits after CEO publishes ‘culture m... by patrick451 on Saturday June 05, 2021 @12:44AM (#27402262)
Grass does not speak. Therefore, in some circumstances, it is violent. What a ridiculous assertion.
Re:Medium sees employee exits after CEO publishes ‘culture m... by grey-area on Saturday June 05, 2021 @01:09AM (#27402394)
This is neither a new idea, nor particularly controversial, nor does it apply to grass.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sin_of_omission

Re:Medium sees employee exits after CEO publishes ‘culture m... by bawolff on Saturday June 05, 2021 @03:18AM (#27402955)
I've worked at some places that i think would consider themselves woke. I have never been asked to personally condemn anything. I'm doubtful that places like google are really like that, i suspect this is mostly a strawman that doesn't really exist.

Sure, if i went around saying that hitler was just misunderstood, i would probably get in trouble. And i'm totally ok with that.

Re:Medium sees employee exits after CEO publishes ‘culture m... by SV_BubbleTime on Sunday June 06, 2021 @12:24PM (#27414172)
> I have never been asked to personally condemn anything

Wear a Trump hat to work and see how long that lasts. Just tell people you voted for him, see if “you’ll be asked to condemn anything”.

“I’ve never had any problems with the people I work with“… probably just means you are aligned with them.

Re:Medium sees employee exits after CEO publishes ‘culture m... by schwartzworld on Friday June 04, 2021 @09:57PM (#27401236)
What is the X? Can you give a real life example?
Re:Medium sees employee exits after CEO publishes ‘culture m... by spoonjim on Friday June 04, 2021 @11:23PM (#27401821)
X is, these days, usually “white supremacy.”
Re:Medium sees employee exits after CEO publishes ‘culture m... by dboreham on Friday June 04, 2021 @10:37PM (#27401524)
Let's try: bombing civilians.
Re:Medium sees employee exits after CEO publishes ‘culture m... by mc32 on Friday June 04, 2021 @11:15PM (#27401782)
And offshoring manufacturing to dictatorships that also "reeducate" and forcibly manage the reproductive rights of religious minorities in the country and threaten neighboring countries with invasions and harvest organs when the like.

Oh, wait... that's right these activists don't care too much about THAT violence.

Re:Medium sees employee exits after CEO publishes ‘culture m... by adrianN on Saturday June 05, 2021 @01:00AM (#27402356)
I'm pretty sure the group of "these activists" is diverse (heh) enough to make such generalizations wrong.
Re:Medium sees employee exits after CEO publishes ‘culture m... by seattle_spring on Saturday June 05, 2021 @01:35AM (#27402513)
Remind me which political ideology in the US is the one trying to forcibly manage reproductive rights?
Re:Medium sees employee exits after CEO publishes ‘culture m... by mc32 on Saturday June 05, 2021 @08:15AM (#27404265)
The one which by proxy is totally nonplussed by what human rights violations go on in China as long as the cash register keeps dinging its bell but on the other hand gets utterly flustered at the lesser problems at home so it ends up looking hypocritical?