News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft’s Android Shakedown by crizCraig on Thursday July 07, 2011 @01:32PM (#2739407)
Should Google do the same thing to Microsoft? Google has shareholders. If they did, I would lose respect for Google that I have already lost for Miscrosoft. Somehow, I don't think Google will, and not just because Windows Mobile is closed source.

I think public opinion/brand reputation is an important thing to consider in these types of situations. For example, this poll shows only 32% of people agree with the strategy: http://www.wepolls.com/r/584161/Should-Microsoft-continue-to...

I wonder what effect that has on the other 68% next time they have a choice between Microsoft and someone else.

Re:Microsoft’s Android Shakedown by rapind on Thursday July 07, 2011 @05:43PM (#2740443)
One of the reasons Google may not have given into the pressure is due to their stock voting structure. Larry and Sergey have final say.

Call me naive, but I actually think they try to stay away from playing in the filth even if everyone else is doing it.

Re:Microsoft’s Android Shakedown by mwsherman on Thursday July 07, 2011 @01:55PM (#2739524)
Well, that's an argument of self-interest. Does the PR cost outweigh the profit?

I think a lot of firms come to the conclusion that the profit is bigger. Most of the world (consumers) doesn't give two shakes about patents.

Re:Microsoft’s Android Shakedown by fragsworth on Thursday July 07, 2011 @03:26PM (#2739950)
Except the customers who are even aware of these lawsuits probably account for such a small percentage of customers as to be negligible.
Re:Microsoft’s Android Shakedown by barista on Thursday July 07, 2011 @02:55PM (#2739798)
What about Apple? They have used saimilar tactic. How about Oracle? IBM? Cisco? Lost respect for those too? Pretty much every company follows similar tactic to protect its interest. The fact Google does not use it is not because they "do no evil" but that they don't have any patents to ask money for.
Re:Microsoft’s Android Shakedown by zmmmmm on Thursday July 07, 2011 @08:07PM (#2740782)
> The fact Google does not use it is not because they "do no evil" but that they don't have any patents to ask money for.

At this point though, with thousands of phd level engineers and probably tens of thousands of the smartest people on the planet working for them, you have to conclude that the reason they have no patents is not that they are unable to produce patents, but rather a conscious choice that they don't want to.

The Nortel auction was fascinating. After leading the bidding Google just left the table and let its competitors buy up all the patents - patents that may very well injure Google in the future. I find it really weird that they opted out of at least buying some "protection" - in the end I can only put it down to a matter of principle - which is something I do respect them for.

Re:Microsoft’s Android Shakedown by CamperBob on Friday July 08, 2011 @01:02AM (#2741345)
It was probably a reasonable risk/return calculation on their part. What are the odds that they will be on the losing end of more than $3.14 billion in patent suits? How much interest can $3.14 billion earn between now and the time these hypothetical damages will have to be paid?

The calculation might have gone differently if it hadn't been for the fairly recent SCOTUS decision that made it more difficult for a plaintiff to obtain a permanent injunction against distribution of an allegedly-infringing product ( http://www.patentlyo.com/patent/2006/05/supreme_court_v.html ). If it hadn't been for that decision, the Nortel patents might have been worth $3 billion and then some.

Re:Microsoft’s Android Shakedown by abecedarius on Thursday July 07, 2011 @06:52PM (#2740605)
This is in fact one of the reasons for my higher opinion of Google over Apple.
Re:Microsoft’s Android Shakedown by yuhong on Thursday July 07, 2011 @11:29PM (#2741187)
They do have patents, they just don't use them the same way.