Kids aren’t too picky about what they play in. They’ll make do with anything.
And planting native vegetation isn't black and white. You can still have a lawn with plenty of native vegetation.
Keeping native plants looking like the ones pictured in the article is nigh impossible with children. Keeping a perfectly manicured lawn is also impossible. Which looks best? I don't know? Neither is great in all honesty.
I think at some point if we have lots of kids running around a neighborhood we should be willing to accept the fact that some lawns, whether grass or plants, will just look janky.
This plants would get dormant and dissapear into the ground from October to March so will support children trotting around as good as any law for half of the year at least.
If your goal is just to prevent bare dirt for erosion purposes then grass is pretty easy to maintain, even with moderate traffic like running children. Just cut it back every week or two and the lawn will more or less take care of itself.
There are a couple things on the other side of this:
- I'm not planning on making purely ornemental plants. What I'm planning are edible plants, and as such, there is great functionality.
- I'm not planting this for the whole yard, but rather, will have different things in different places
- Making it an edible landscape, perhaps even having a perennial food forest, teaches my children the things I want them to learn: that they are part of an ecosystem, that abundance is from the land and not from the grocery store.
- There are alternative cover plants that work better for the landscape, such as white dutch clover. White Dutch Clover are hardier towards drought, can fix its own nitrogen, and pollinators love them. You can get varieties that grow no more than 8" so you don't really have to mow them. Sure, you might piss off your neighbors who see it as weeds they have to kill with glysophate. Other perennials such as thyme or oregeno can make for better cover on paths between garden beds
- I have started on reshaping the topology by adding basins and bearms so that rainfall can be captured and stored. It reduces the space my kids can run, but I will also be bringing in the kind of things I think people seek out from hiking in nature or strolling through a garden.
- I can't play baseball, but we would be able to play things like lazer tag, which is more fun when you have cover.
- There's a great park about 10 min walk away from our house. We'd probablty go there for soccer (I don't like baseball).
Maybe we should tempt them to go out offering real landscapes to explore instead. Most children love hide, lurk and watch animals and would find it extremely pleasant. It has also has more to offer to both, boys and girls.
This is the kind of garden that we are talking about and is 100% top of his game.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GWQsOoePD08
Is suitable or not for you?. Well, that depends on your location, presence/absence of dangerous animals, different personalities and ages of the children, etc.
Here in Phoenix, xeriscaping is very popular. It usually involves gravel laid on top of a weed barrier. The barrier does not work very well ... and you really can't play on the gravel. It's like the worst of all the options.
Even just putting in grass helps cool down the area around the house. If there is a way to put some kind of cover that is drought-resistant, does not require fertilizer, and can absorb the rains during monsoon, that's better than gravel-on-weed-barrier.
As adult, I still love doing many of these things, and find your observation that “you can’t do anything with native plants” bizarre, you get to enjoy the native life that they bring with them.
I'm all for curiosity about life and exploration, but for a lot of games a flat field is simply better, and those games have tons of value. How well you work/interact with other people has a huge impact on life, and active play directly develops those capabilities.
You don’t develop valuable social skills asking adults about things you want to learn more about? Learning how and when to ask questions is extremely valuable. And that’s not to say you can’t play plenty of social games in a woods –– many that don’t work on grass, tag is way more fun, any sort of fantasy/imagination type game is much more vivid, hide and seek is actually a fun game.
This is... reductive. I didn't play any organized sports as a kid, but I don't have trouble working with others. On the other hand I've met plenty of people that played sports all through primary school and they're utter assholes as adults. This narrative is also often used to justify why schools often cut funding for science/arts before cutting sports. To my ear it sounds like someone justifying why their preferred childhood activities were better than someone else's preferred childhood activities.
All the time.
Basically find out what lawn weeds are native where you are (that aren't spiny of course) and plant those in your lawn.
If you want running around and sporty activities, lawns are great (no accident pitches, and sportsfields are grass). If you want low maintenance, go with native vegetation or boring gravel.
Never the less, you have to know the effects of native vegetation. It attracts things you may not want, so you may want to design your flora for the fauna you are willing to accommodate.
https://www.scotts.com/en-us/library/lawn-care-basics/benefi...
https://content.yardmap.org/learn/native-grasses-for-your-na...
But its true that a lot of the ecological benefit would be forgone by a traditional lawn even with native grasses. But it does have the advantage of limiting the spread of non-native species that can (but no always) have harmful affects on local ecologies.
Alternately, to reduce on mowing, you could get a goat! It's like a Lawn Roomba.
In contrast, a yard full of native plants sounds nice ... but you can't really do anything in it. It becomes ornamental rather than functional. I can't play a game a baseball if my entire yard is ferns and flowers rather than grass.
That said, in garden beds and places where plants and trees do make sense, installing native species is a no-brainer. We're in the process of getting rid of a bunch of non-native shrubs and plants and replacing them with native.
And in that case, we're making a transition from ornamental to functional. Previously, the trees and shrubs looked nice, but the birds and bugs didn't particularly care for them. Now, the birds are eating the berries, the butterflies and bees are loving the flowering plants, and we spend less time on maintenance.