News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft’s Android Shakedown by TomOfTTB on Thursday July 07, 2011 @11:49AM (#2738929)
One of the things Microsoft has done well is to pick the right pricing plan and the right industry. By making it a per unit fee on Smartphones you make it easy for manufacturers to pass the cost on to the consumer who then subsidizes it through a contract with their provider.

The $5 per unit HTC pays Microsoft is only $.20 a month when passed directly on to the consumer and spread out over 2 years.

Re:Microsoft’s Android Shakedown by SwellJoe on Thursday July 07, 2011 @12:30PM (#2739122)
This, of course, has the side effect (or possibly even intended effect) of making Windows Phone seem more cost-effective. "Free" software isn't free, if it includes a Microsoft tax, anyway.

I just hope the large Android ecosystem starts pushing for patent reform, and soon. This is just fundamentally broken market behavior...Microsoft is getting protection money. They don't even have to provide products people want, and they still make money on every smart phone sold.

Re:Microsoft’s Android Shakedown by btilly on Thursday July 07, 2011 @02:08PM (#2739586)
Microsoft loves arrangements where you have to pay them whether or not you're using their product. In fact this was the subject of the first anti-trust case against them which was settled out of court. (Not many people remember this one.) See http://www.associatedcontent.com/article/467487/the_antitrus... for confirmation.
Re:Microsoft’s Android Shakedown by joelhaus on Thursday July 07, 2011 @11:03PM (#2741162)
Doesn't this practice violate the 1994 consent decree with the FTC? The linked article states that MS could only charge computer manufacturers if MS software was installed. I guess the decree must have expired, because it seems that the Android OS situation directly applies.

BTW, fascinating article, thx! At the time, all of the MS anti-trust stuff seemed so distant, but given the current tech landscape, it seems to have taken on much greater importance.

Re:Microsoft’s Android Shakedown by btilly on Friday July 08, 2011 @12:26AM (#2741294)
The decree was that they couldn't charge by the machine, regardless of whether MS software was installed. I believe that Microsoft's response was to charge by the CPU instead, which technically wasn't covered in the decree, but had almost the same effect.

In this case they aren't charging by the CPU, they are charging by the operating system that ships with Microsoft's "intellectual property". If they got away with the per-CPU crapola 15 years ago, nobody will blink an eye at the current arrangement.

Re:Microsoft’s Android Shakedown by SwellJoe on Friday July 08, 2011 @12:17AM (#2741277)
It certainly does seem to tell us something about the deep-seated character (or lack thereof) within the company.
Re:Microsoft’s Android Shakedown by zmmmmm on Thursday July 07, 2011 @08:12PM (#2740796)
> "Free" software isn't free, if it includes a Microsoft tax, anyway.

You have to wonder how galling it is for Microsoft that even after they impose this "tax" manufacturers still prefer to make Android devices and still sell vastly more of them than WP7. Effectively it values WP7 at less than free which must be rather insulting.

Edit: I think the fact MS is even trying this speaks volumes about how Microsoft misunderstands the market. Stuck in a 1990s mindset their assumption is that their problem competing with Android is that it is free while their OS costs money. They simply do not understand the difference between free and open source and assume the only difference between the two is a financial one. They fail to see the strategic value of Android being "open" to these manufacturers and don't get that it is far greater than anything they can ever impose on them via patent trolling.

Re:Microsoft’s Android Shakedown by marcf on Thursday July 07, 2011 @11:53AM (#2738955)
It undeniably hurts HTC's profits though. Sucks for those that have to pay this Microsoft tax. And it also does hurt Google in the sense that this cost is being passed to Google's customers rather than Google taking this burden.
Re:Microsoft’s Android Shakedown by protomyth on Thursday July 07, 2011 @11:59AM (#2738995)
I would imagine the S3 purchase has the nice side effect of offsetting some of the costs per phone and gaining HTC their own licensing property. I also see the S3 purchase as helping them in the whole customized ARM game. Cell phones are massive chunks of patents and HTC knows the space well.
Re:Microsoft’s Android Shakedown by nextparadigms on Thursday July 07, 2011 @02:18PM (#2739624)
HTC is paying $5 per phone, but they also get protection against Apple. I don't think HTC would've signed the deal with Microsoft, if it wasn't for the Apple lawsuit.
Re:Microsoft’s Android Shakedown by marcf on Thursday July 07, 2011 @02:58PM (#2739817)
I figure though HTC's profit per phone is likely on the order of $20 or less? (I'm guessing here but I should be in the ballpark.) Thus $5 per phone is hugely significant.
Re:Microsoft’s Android Shakedown by darklajid on Thursday July 07, 2011 @03:45PM (#2740006)
Re:Microsoft’s Android Shakedown by woobar on Thursday July 07, 2011 @05:22PM (#2740389)
Bill of Materials is just a fraction of their expenses.

We can estimate per phone profit from the quarterly report [1].

- Q1 after-tax profit was NT$14.83bn

- Handset shipment for 1Q was 9.7mn units

~ NT$1500 per phone (~US$55/per phone)

[1] http://www.corpasia.net/taiwan/2498/irwebsite/index.php?mod=...

Re:Microsoft’s Android Shakedown by nextparadigms on Thursday July 07, 2011 @02:15PM (#2739609)
I don't understand that logic. It's $5 taken from the cost of the device, and because of those $5 baked into the cost, it probably makes the devices $10-$15 extra at the retail store.

Also they are planning on charging Samsung $15 license fee, so that would be a lot for a $150 phone.