News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon Ring’s neighborhood watch app is making police req... by crazygringo on Thursday June 03, 2021 @05:54PM (#27387880)
> 1) will be public and probably not too common - fishing expeditions by the police. 2) will not be public at all and will represent the bulk of data transfer

I don't think that's correct at all.

To the contrary -- how often does a regular resident get a subpoena? Practically never.

On the other hand, how often do cops check CCTV footage? All the time. If cops are trying to follow the path a suspect took to drive through a neighborhood and where they wound up, then this 1) option is amazing and will frequently be used.

I can't imagine why you're perjoratively calling it "fishing expeditions". That's ridiculous, there's zero evidence police are using this, or want to use it, to catch petty crimes they don't know about in the first place. It's to track suspects' routes and confirm alibis, that type of thing. Both common and legitimate.

> They certainly mustn't.

The obvious context here is Ring requests. Not things like subpoenas.

> Complete bullshit as well. Ring doesn't make the rules.

You're wrong. Ring does make all the rules of what Ring shares through this program.

You're acting like the existence of subpoenas makes this all a bunch of song and dance, but they're entirely different things for entirely different purposes. Your pessimism and cynicism isn't just unwarranted, it's simply factually incorrect.

There are no comments on this comment yet.