News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Snowflake CEO Says Worker Merit Should Outweigh Diversity... by kazinator on Thursday June 03, 2021 @05:39PM (#27387695)
> Merit and diversity are not in opposition to each other.

Logic/math does not bear out this well-intended belief.

If you select N employees for the company based entirely on merit, you get some set U.

If you select N employees entirely based on diversity, you get a set V.

Whenever U /= V, the criteria are necessarily in conflict. The conflicting choices are represented in the symmetric difference of U and V: elements in U that are not in V and vice versa.

The merit criteria selects some people U\V (those in U who are not in V); the diversity criteria disagrees with that and insists they be replaced with people in the V\U difference.

You can mix the criteria: somehow hedging between diversity and merit. There is more than one way of doing that and those ways can be in conflict with each other as well as with pure merit or pure diversity.

Ideally you want merit only because only that is relevant to the organization. What may happen instead is that selection takes place based on a mixture of merit plus some undesirable bias. Diversity advocates rightfully point out that this is in conflict with pure merit.

What diversity should ideally mean is the elimination of such a bias, rather than introduction of compensating biases.

There are no comments on this comment yet.