It didn't make me feel uncomfortable. It felt like it was trying to make me "think" but it ended up philosophically hollow. Not sure what punchline I'd have wanted, but I prefer to be surprised.
I guess overall I have no complaints except that it could have been shorter. It seemed like it was building to a conclusion that never coalesced, which is okay for short fiction, but this one was sorta a slog.
From your choice of words and the fact that you wrote, I would gather that the story didn't leave you indifferent. So it achieved something.
What do you understand as "gimmick" and how could a "punchline" for that story look like for you?