Re:Rethinking the computer ‘desktop’ as a concept
by KronisLV on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @01:46PM
(#27358442)
Oh, I'm not necessarily advocating for it but the reasons behind it seem interesting, whatever they might be.
Is it a matter of differences in cultures, that people don't seem to mind ads as much online, or perhaps there'd be backlash from OS app distribution channels, were devs to attempt to monetize software in the Windows Store for example (I don't really use UWP apps so no idea), or perhaps it's something else entirely...
That said, I feel like the option not even being there is limiting in of itself. Suppose I'm a developer who wants to create software that's free to download and use, but ad supported. Now I cannot possibly do that. As for those who would prefer no ads, there would always be the possibility of a paid version with no ads, the possibility of altering the hosts file to block ads, or possibly downloading the source code of the app, removing the ad integration code and compiling the app themselves.
Though there are also interesting technical aspects as well, such as us not being able to sandbox most native apps (short of AppImage and Flatpak as well as Snaps, but even then there are other challenges), which may contribute to spyware in desktop apps. Plus I bet there's a large difference between showing an ad in an app and being able to mess around with the OS default browser settings and so on...
Is it a matter of differences in cultures, that people don't seem to mind ads as much online, or perhaps there'd be backlash from OS app distribution channels, were devs to attempt to monetize software in the Windows Store for example (I don't really use UWP apps so no idea), or perhaps it's something else entirely...
That said, I feel like the option not even being there is limiting in of itself. Suppose I'm a developer who wants to create software that's free to download and use, but ad supported. Now I cannot possibly do that. As for those who would prefer no ads, there would always be the possibility of a paid version with no ads, the possibility of altering the hosts file to block ads, or possibly downloading the source code of the app, removing the ad integration code and compiling the app themselves.
Though there are also interesting technical aspects as well, such as us not being able to sandbox most native apps (short of AppImage and Flatpak as well as Snaps, but even then there are other challenges), which may contribute to spyware in desktop apps. Plus I bet there's a large difference between showing an ad in an app and being able to mess around with the OS default browser settings and so on...