News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Danish whistleblower details NSA collaboration, cable and... by truth_ on Monday May 31, 2021 @02:57AM (#27341054)
I really dislike how USA bullies people trying to buy Russian S400 anti-aircraft and anti-missile systems.

S400s are effective against their best aircrafts. And they don't want other countries to have it.

So they threaten sanction and people have to play along.

Re:Danish whistleblower details NSA collaboration, cable and... by alkonaut on Monday May 31, 2021 @03:07AM (#27341130)
It's a complex issue. It's not just money involved, buying a long term "system" means you are reliant on relations for spares and support. This puts into question the willingness of (e.g.) Turkey as a NATO country to upset Russia. NATO is a defense pact, which in reality means a military industrial pact too. There is no way to entirely separate the manufacturing and acquisition of military gear, from the treaty where it's supposed to be used.
Re:Danish whistleblower details NSA collaboration, cable and... by buran77 on Monday May 31, 2021 @04:32AM (#27341663)
The US does its best to prevent allies from having any kind of military technology outside of US control, particularly if it's effective. Allegiances aren't set in stone and the US won't take the chance to see that tech used against them.

[0] https://tech.slashdot.org/story/03/12/01/1226207/galileo-sys...

[1] https://www.theguardian.com/uk/2003/dec/08/world.internation...

Re:Danish whistleblower details NSA collaboration, cable and... by KMag on Monday May 31, 2021 @03:13AM (#27341161)
Wasn't there also at one point a proposal for a F-35 maintenance facility in Turkey? Having that kind of access to F-35 information and being potentially beholden to a manufacturer of the main threat to the F-35 sounds like a huge intelligence leak just waiting to happen.
Re:Danish whistleblower details NSA collaboration, cable and... by _tik_ on Monday May 31, 2021 @03:57AM (#27341430)
US bullied Indonesia to buy US weapons too. And Indonesia is not a NATO member. Most of those weapons from US is overpriced and overkill for Indonesia need.

https://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2020/03/13/trump-threat-...

Re:Danish whistleblower details NSA collaboration, cable and... by 1cvmask on Monday May 31, 2021 @03:49AM (#27341376)
Having an AAAD (A2/AD) defense system poses a threat to bombing planes, missiles etc.. Defensive systems raise the cost of an invasion or bombing runs. You can threaten countries easily or in an easier manner when we deny them systems like the S400. Would we have bombed Vietnam, Laos and everywhere else so indiscriminately if the had proper defensive systems in place.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Area_denial_weapon

Re:Danish whistleblower details NSA collaboration, cable and... by adriancr on Monday May 31, 2021 @03:10AM (#27341148)
I don't see how it's a good idea to buy air defense from a potential enemy you have... the country NATO was created to defend against...

It will surely protect you against them and not be used to sabotage/spy on you.

Re:Danish whistleblower details NSA collaboration, cable and... by hutzlibu on Monday May 31, 2021 @03:46AM (#27341356)
The nato was created against the sowjetunion.

There is no more sowjetunion. And it is a bit frustrating, that we are in a new cold war right now, because people were too lazy(on both sides) to adjust after the wall came down. So yes, russia is an enemy again, hurey and sure it makes not much sense letting them gather direct data to boosten their air defence missiles. But this works in both ways, no? If you have the S400 - you can study extensivly its weaknessess.

Apart from that, china seems a bigger threat.

Re:Danish whistleblower details NSA collaboration, cable and... by adriancr on Monday May 31, 2021 @04:18AM (#27341551)
Studying S400 weaknesses can be done without buying it and deploying it. (And likely has been done in plane design)

> Apart from that, china seems a bigger threat.

Russia is a direct threat of invasion for most European countries and yet they're not taken seriously (except neighbors which some have been invaded). The fact that S400 is even debated is proof of that...

US for better or worse can take both Russia and China militarily on itself... but it feels a bit pointless if the countries it protects are shooting themselves in the foot.

Re:Danish whistleblower details NSA collaboration, cable and... by hutzlibu on Monday May 31, 2021 @04:52AM (#27341818)
"Studying S400 weaknesses can be done without buying it and deploying it. "

How? Spycraft? Sounds a lot harder than having the gear at hand.

"US for better or worse can take both Russia and China militarily on itself.."

I hope we never find out, but I am sceptical. The US budget is surely way higher, but china and russia can produce, develope and sustain their military gear a lot lot cheaper. And have more manpower.

"Russia is a direct threat of invasion for most European countries"

And well, I live in germany and I don't feel threatened by russia. I know for Lithuania it is a bit different - but they are in the EU and NATO and the ukraine is not. So the lithuanian people I know don't really feel threatened by russia either and rather are annoyed by the new iron curtain, as well.

Re:Danish whistleblower details NSA collaboration, cable and... by pizza234 on Monday May 31, 2021 @05:09AM (#27341953)
> And well, I live in germany and I don't feel threatened by russia.

While "most European countries" is excessive, there are some countries that are very much under threat; Poland is the prime example.

Re:Danish whistleblower details NSA collaboration, cable and... by hutzlibu on Monday May 31, 2021 @05:13AM (#27341982)
So you really think russia would invade a NATO country triggering a direct NATO response, with all the nukes still around?

Do you know something I don't that makes this scenario likely?

Re:Danish whistleblower details NSA collaboration, cable and... by adriancr on Monday May 31, 2021 @05:52AM (#27342284)
> So you really think russia would invade a NATO country triggering a direct NATO response, with all the nukes still around?

Trump threatened to pull US out of NATO which would make it meaningless

Regardless of intentions, If that were ever to happen, it would put even Germany under threat from Russia's green men.

France/UK's nukes are a deterrent but its doubtful they would be used

US with troops in those countries make it pretty clear a conventional war with green men would be repelled with heavy losses on Russian side.

Re:Danish whistleblower details NSA collaboration, cable and... by hutzlibu on Monday May 31, 2021 @06:33AM (#27342525)
There are still lots of nukes in the NATO without the US.

And germany does not have russian speaking and feeling areas, who would (at least partly) welcome green man, which was the case in east ukraine and crimea.

And as far as I know, Trump is gone.

Re:Danish whistleblower details NSA collaboration, cable and... by pizza234 on Monday May 31, 2021 @09:03AM (#27343640)
I meant without the NATO present.
Re:Danish whistleblower details NSA collaboration, cable and... by tclover on Monday May 31, 2021 @04:32AM (#27341666)
>Russia is a direct threat of invasion for most European countries lmao
Re:Danish whistleblower details NSA collaboration, cable and... by bitcharmer on Monday May 31, 2021 @05:18AM (#27342016)
Yes, I'm pretty sure Ukrainians find it funny as well.
Re:Danish whistleblower details NSA collaboration, cable and... by tclover on Monday May 31, 2021 @05:20AM (#27342039)
Crimea is very complicated issue with no clear answer.
Re:Danish whistleblower details NSA collaboration, cable and... by bitcharmer on Monday May 31, 2021 @08:18AM (#27343288)
This can be said about any geopolitical area if you look far enough into the history. Saying "it's complicated" is a very poor excuse for the annexation. Similarly "complicated" are Taiwan, Tibet, Kashmir and tens of other regions in the world. There will never be peace if we're OK with actions like this.
Re:Danish whistleblower details NSA collaboration, cable and... by hutzlibu on Monday May 31, 2021 @08:54AM (#27343570)
Sure, but on the other hand, it is maybe not helpful to oversimplify.

Because then your actions will not lead to more peace and just complicate things further.

Territorial integrity is often at odds with self-determination. In the case of Georgia and Ukraine the west argued with sacred territorial integrity - and in the case of Kosovo with self-determination. And russia argued reverse.

I have not been in all those areas, so I don't want to judge, but I do know that there was lots and lots of propaganda going on and allmost nobody really asked the actual people living there, what they actually want - which is what I prefer to apply in most conflicts. But this not so easy either, because ... does the vote of a person living there since only 2 years count the same as one whose family has been there since centuries? Where to draw the line?

Otherwise it gets ridiculed when for example occupying russian soldiers in chechenya gets the same vote as the people who actually lived there.

Re:Danish whistleblower details NSA collaboration, cable and... by CRConrad on Thursday June 03, 2021 @03:58AM (#27378382)
Crimea is an utterly simple issue with a crystal clear answer.
Re:Danish whistleblower details NSA collaboration, cable and... by truth_ on Monday May 31, 2021 @03:36AM (#27341301)
India is not a part of NATO. India was one of the leaders of the Non-Alignment Movement, but did certainly bend a little towards the USSR.

USSR and post-USSR Russia has solidly backed India in many issues. When the US imposed bans on export of vaccine raw materials even after a month of assurances of special waivers for India, Russia agreed to supply and produce Sputnik V in a heartbeat.

Historically, here's one example- when US Ally Pakistan was committing a genocide and ethnic cleansing on its own people [0] (now the country of Bangladesh), and India was funding and training the rebels, the US sent Task Force 74 to deter India. And Russia sent cruisers, destroyer, and a nuclear armed submarine to balance the situation.

India won the war of 1971. And the independent country of Bangladesh was born.

See- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Task_Force_74

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1971_Bangladesh_genocide

Re:Danish whistleblower details NSA collaboration, cable and... by 1cvmask on Monday May 31, 2021 @03:57AM (#27341428)
We also openly supported white colonisers in India like the Portuguese in Goa and the French in Pondicherry (just like Vietnam etc). We even voted against Indians at the UN in favor of white colonial rule of Goa (and even forced client states through coups/arms twisting to vote along).

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Annexation_of_Goa#UN_attempts_...

Re:Danish whistleblower details NSA collaboration, cable and... by adriancr on Monday May 31, 2021 @04:21AM (#27341577)
India is not part of NATO... I only meant the comment for NATO countries.

For India it does makes a lot of sense.