News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Overkill objects for everyday life by neilpanchal on Sunday May 30, 2021 @06:15PM (#27337411)
I kinda disagree. These aren’t very good examples. Also the dough mixer is for restaurants, not military use. :-) Although I want one now.

Here is a kitchen scale I bought. Made in Switzerland, no less. It’s bloody beautiful: https://neil.computer/notes/mettler-toledo-ml3002e-teardown/

Does that mean all consumer grade stuff is bad? No. Leatherman tools and 3M consumer grade stuff is usually great. Nalgene bottles. Does that mean all pro quality stuff is great? No. I’ve bought restaurant quality containers, made in California, no less, but are not BPA-free.

My philosophy is quite tangential to the points you’re making:

- Search for stuff in auxiliary / parallel industries.

- Used surplus stuff is usually below consumer grade prices even if it was slightly worse, you're still equal. 9/10 times it is actually the opposite - 10x the quality, performance and durability of consumer grade crap on Amazon.

- Some cheap crap is actually good. Victorinox $30 knife is excellent value and used by professional chefs. The same cannot be said for an outdoors knife, you want it to be overbuilt. Cheap $30 outdoor knives would not stand a chance. Always buy generic drugs, they're exactly the same.

There are atleast 100 more examples I can write about that were a net positive buys. Just last week I bought U-Line tape dispenser. Same price as consumer grade ones, so why not?

- Orthogonal search usually yields frugal jackpots. No one would ever find any use for the life raft bag in the marine parts store.

Average consumers want stuff that is objectively worse for them. Touchscreens were an excellent idea for a phone, now they want it everywhere in their cars. Overall, with the throw-away culture consumers are addicted to, it’s hard to not blame them. Have you ever dealt with customer service? You might be surprised. We are soooo addicted to wasteful culture. You’re just promoting this and doubling down on it.

Let’s see in last 20 years: Quality went downhill, durability is an after thought, repairability is non existent and consumers want bigger box - literally larger than the item because they choose it based on how good the box looks. If it were any other reason, it’s a waste of packaging and businesses know this. Businesses are not looking to waste money on extra packaging unless it led to better sales. This is a direct evidence of the utter shitshow consumer culture embodies.

Anyways, I fancy things that are engineered with deliberation and specification. Tested and qualified against requirements. Usually military, aviation, marine or medical grade goods are designed and engineered in such a way.

Re:Overkill objects for everyday life by IgorPartola on Sunday May 30, 2021 @07:13PM (#27337898)
There are definitely nice finds out there. That doesn’t mean that the military equivalent of a consumer good is better. Duct tape is duct tape. A Humvee is a shit grocery hauler. Military boots aren’t going to be as nice or comfortable as a pair of Italian hand made boots.

I remember looking at ToughBooks because their shells are amazing. But what does that do for me if inside it has a 10 year old computer?

Re:Overkill objects for everyday life by yourapostasy on Sunday May 30, 2021 @08:25PM (#27338482)
> Duct tape is duct tape.

Meant in jest: I find your lack of faith [1]...disturbing [2].

That said, I have found marked differences even in "consumer" duct/duck tape offerings at big box stores. Adhesive properties, abrasion resistance, UV resistance, backing laminate strength, vibration tolerance, and so on, have converged my choices these days to Gorilla and 3M brands, and only give other manufacturers that show up in the big box store shelves one chance with one sample roll.

[1] https://tapeuniversity.com/industry/industrial-mro/what-is-t...

[2] https://onemileatatime.com/duct-tape-airplane/

Re:Overkill objects for everyday life by neilpanchal on Sunday May 30, 2021 @07:18PM (#27337948)
Agreed, there is a bit of selectivity and careful consideration. These are misuses and illfits. Wearing military boots to a wedding is an impedence mismatch so to speak, not really a fault of military boots.

You gotta compare apples to apples.

Re:Overkill objects for everyday life by PaulDavisThe1st on Sunday May 30, 2021 @09:11PM (#27338816)
Under what conditions are military boots ever actually better than the best non-military alternatives?
Re:Overkill objects for everyday life by CRConrad on Monday May 31, 2021 @03:14AM (#27341172)
Air drops into enemy territory.
Re:Overkill objects for everyday life by manigandham on Monday May 31, 2021 @01:47AM (#27340604)
Love this article and agree completely. I always go for the functional, reliable and sturdy industrial versions if possible. I also like the design and engineering that go into these products instead of the typical polished plastic consumer junk.

Lots of comments are talking about the extremes but most reasonable people can figure it out. Obviously don't use an industrial appliance that operates at 90db, requires high voltage electrical, and needs 2 hours of daily maintenance to make your coffee; but that liferaft bag is brilliant. Also nice industrial design on the site!

Re:Overkill objects for everyday life by Animats on Monday May 31, 2021 @03:17AM (#27341191)
Average consumers want stuff that is objectively worse for them. Touchscreens were an excellent idea for a phone, now they want it everywhere in their cars.

The commercial version of the electric Ford F-150 has a reasonably sized touchscreen in the center of the dashboard. The consumer version has a huge 18 inch touchscreen which sticks up above the top of the dashboard, and looks silly. This replaces the large number of single-purpose knobs and buttons in the commercial version.

Re:Overkill objects for everyday life by bashinator on Sunday May 30, 2021 @09:57PM (#27339153)
> Nalgene bottles

...were originally lab equipment. The company pivoted to consumer goods after their products had already become popular as such.

Re:Overkill objects for everyday life by cmendel on Sunday May 30, 2021 @11:04PM (#27339596)
>>Always buy generic drugs, they're exactly the same.

I'm sorry to say. This is false.

This will be a bit technical but often, generic drugs are a racemic mix (both L and D conformations in some mixture) where as a branded drug may be a specific conformation or specific racemic mix (e.g. 75% L, 25% D.)

The issue comes from the fact that L-conformations may have different (better, worse, otherwise) effects than the D-conformations.

TL;DR Not all generics are the same as their branded counterparts and they might effect you differently. Caveat emptor.

Re:Overkill objects for everyday life by ornornor on Monday May 31, 2021 @01:53AM (#27340645)
I have no idea what that comment meant to say. Am I being thick or it the same for anyone not manufacturing drugs for a living/as a hobby?
Re:Overkill objects for everyday life by cmendel on Monday May 31, 2021 @02:51AM (#27341022)
I'll do my best to explain. So in chemistry, there is a thing called 'chirality' essentially this has to do with how a molecule is shaped. It's assessed by how a beam of polarized light that is passed through a molecule rotates.

There are a few different types:

Achiral, no change Levorotary (L), Rotates anticlockwise Dextrorotary(D), Rotates clockwise

The reason that it matters and what I was talking about above is that the sites in your body that a drug interacts with aren't universal. So if you have a (L) version of a drug that might have different effects and interactions than a (D) version.

A 1:1 mix of both (L) and (D) is called a racemic mix.

When you are talking about Brand name drugs, you're typically discussing a particular mix (e.g. Adderall XR is a 3:1 (D):(L) mix) or a particular conformation. That is not necessarily true with generics which may have a different ratio of (D):(L).

To give an example of how different the effects can be: Penicillamine (L) is used in the treatment of primary chronic arthritis. Penicillamine (D) not only has no therapeutic effect, it is highly toxic.

Here's a link to some Wikipedia pages on it if you're interested: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chirality#Chemistry https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Racemic_mixture

Do note that this is a bit of an oversimplification, but it's 3AM here so I hope you can forgive me.

Re:Overkill objects for everyday life by ornornor on Monday May 31, 2021 @05:44AM (#27342226)
Thank you, that was informative.

If generic drugs have a different L:D ratio and L molecules have a different effect than D molecules, then surely the generic has a different effect and result than the brand name which would make or the other work better. Wouldn’t that come up and be an issue leading to either reformulating the generic to better match the brand name, or pulling the generic altogether?

Re:Overkill objects for everyday life by nucleardog on Monday May 31, 2021 @03:40PM (#27347449)
> To give an example of how different the effects can be: Penicillamine (L) is used in the treatment of primary chronic arthritis. Penicillamine (D) not only has no therapeutic effect, it is highly toxic.

I think, as a layman, Thalidomide is probably a good striking example.

One chirality does what it says on the tin. The other causes babies to be born missing limbs and with other birth defects.

In theory, if we could produce Thalidomide with only the correct isomer, it would not only be effective but 100% safe for pregnant women.

Re:Overkill objects for everyday life by neilpanchal on Monday May 31, 2021 @12:04AM (#27339957)
Thanks TIL, I had no idea. I'll stop giving medical advice I guess.
Re:Overkill objects for everyday life by cmendel on Monday May 31, 2021 @02:53AM (#27341034)
Ha, no worries! I'd thought the same until I went off and got a degree in Chemistry.
Re:Overkill objects for everyday life by growse on Monday May 31, 2021 @03:51AM (#27341390)
Fwiw, I have a degree in chemistry and it never occurred to me that generics would potentially have a different chiral mixture to the original.

Given that we know (like you point out) that different enantiomers can have very different effects, it seems particularly dangerous for generics to be marketed as alternatives to the branded drug when, in some cases, they really are not.

Re:Overkill objects for everyday life by alliao on Sunday May 30, 2021 @11:53PM (#27339889)
thank you!