News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Overwork contributes to 745k premature deaths per year by tikhonj on Friday May 28, 2021 @08:55PM (#27322211)
At the same time, I don't think anybody would have issues with claims like "smoking kills X people a year", even though it's also a relationship that isn't 100% direct. The two claims do seem qualitatively different to me, but I'm not sure why. What's the concrete difference between "overwork kills X people a year" and "smoking kills X people a year" that makes one a sound claim and the other sound like nonsense?
Re:Overwork contributes to 745k premature deaths per year by parsimo2010 on Friday May 28, 2021 @09:27PM (#27322365)
I think the difference may be because we've been hearing about the harms of smoking for decades now. So when we hear "smoking kills X people" we understand they don't mean that smoking is the cause of death written on the death certificate, we understand that smoking has a demonstrable causal link to a variety of reduced lung health.

While most people understand that stress probably isn't good for you, we haven't had decades of ad campaigns and public health initiatives dedicated towards it. So the general public just needs time to catch up before we put stress in the same bucket as smoking, lead paint, and asbestos.

Re:Overwork contributes to 745k premature deaths per year by temp8964 on Friday May 28, 2021 @11:29PM (#27322807)
Actually "smoking kills X people a year" is also wrong. Yes, there is directly link between smoking and physical damage to the body. But two issues involved:

1. people usually do not instantly die after smoking. There is a long process from smoking to death.

2. people who smoke are different from people who do not smoke. There could be other contributing factors associated with people who smokes.

"smoking kills X people a year" was never a scientifically accurate claim. The accurate claim should be smoking increase * chance of ##, or on average people who smoke live ## years shorter.

However, there are cases where you can say smoking kills someone. For example, a woman who frequently smokes during the pregnancy gives birth to a baby born with severe life-threatening defects and the baby dies immediately after birth. In this case it could be OK to say the mother's smoking killed the baby, because:

1. There is a relatively short period of time involved.

2. There may be no other significant contributing factor to the birth defects, if we can rule out genetic factors.

Otherwise, in most cases, it is not scientifically accurate to claim smoking kills X people a year. In some cases, smoking actually could save people, who would otherwise use more detrimental means to release stress or anxiety.

Re:Overwork contributes to 745k premature deaths per year by trompetenaccoun on Saturday May 29, 2021 @12:17AM (#27322988)
What about "virus killed x amount of people last year", when the vast majority of these deaths were patients older than the median life expectancy with significant existing health problems prior to the infection?

I do agree people need to be more critical of science reporting. And often science needs to do a much better job at both sciencing and explaining the results to people who aren't experienced in interpreting them.

Re:Overwork contributes to 745k premature deaths per year by temp8964 on Saturday May 29, 2021 @12:55AM (#27323120)
I think my two tests are still valid on the claim:

1. is the length of the period of those people from getting infected to death relatively short?

2. are there any other significant factors contribute to those people's death in that period?

Even if deaths were patients older than the median life expectancy with significant existing health problems prior to the infection, they can still pass those two tests, so most of them were still killed by the virus.

Re:Overwork contributes to 745k premature deaths per year by trompetenaccoun on Saturday May 29, 2021 @01:33AM (#27323277)
Just to be clear my question was rhetorical. You have to do an autopsy to have a reasonable guess about the cause. A 90 year old has a 13% chance of dying for any reason within a year (in the US, see here: https://www.ssa.gov/oact/STATS/table4c6.html). If it's not the virus it may be their liver, or their heart, or, and this is interesting now, chronic respiratory diseases. This has been a leading cause of death for a long time (https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/leading-causes-of-death.htm).

>are there any other significant factors contribute to those people's death in that period?

Multiple things can contribute. Our body is an extremely complex organism. Putting a death down to 100% this or that when in reality it's a lot more complicated isn't just imprecise, it's often flat out wrong.

And just because events coincide doesn't mean there's causality. If 1000 people died on a day with severe thunderstorms around the country that doesn't mean the thunderstorms killed them all. When old people with a virus infection die it's reasonable to assume there could be a connection, but you can't just say everyone who tested positive in a given time died of the virus.

Re:Overwork contributes to 745k premature deaths per year by temp8964 on Saturday May 29, 2021 @05:39PM (#27328419)
For 90 year olds, the COVID caused death probably happens in a few weeks, instead of within a year, right?

I agree "events coincide doesn't mean there's causality", but I think the causation here is still pretty strong, even for 90 year olds.

Re:Overwork contributes to 745k premature deaths per year by smnrchrds on Saturday May 29, 2021 @02:04AM (#27323369)
> 1. is the length of the period of those people from getting infected to death relatively short?

What about HIV/AIDS? Does it kill anyone?

Re:Overwork contributes to 745k premature deaths per year by noahtallen on Friday May 28, 2021 @09:26PM (#27322358)
I think smoking is a much more concrete relationship though, because you’re inhaling something which directly and physically damages your body. The tie to death is also more obvious because there aren’t other factors which could make a difference. If you smoke a lot, you’ll get lung cancer —- eating a good diet or exercising won’t stop the bad effects. Whereas with overwork, maybe if you have excellent routines like getting good sleep, exercise a lot, meditate, hydrate, etc, you’ll be able to combat the stress level. So you’re probably not quite as doomed as you might be with smoking.

Like, with smoking, it is the actual thing you consume which kills you. But with overwork, it’s not that you’re working $x hours too many, but that you’re super stressed out. (Even achieving low stress levels with normal work hours can be hard!) I think phrasing it as stress makes the tie more obvious to me because high stress levels are more obviously damaging.

Re:Overwork contributes to 745k premature deaths per year by spicybright on Friday May 28, 2021 @11:21PM (#27322779)
I disagree. You can see clear effects from prolonged stress on the body. And in both cases, people still get lung cancer without smoking, and people can still die of heart attacks without being stressed.