Signs very geographically even in ASL. (See: https://www.reddit.com/r/asl/comments/dcvqo9/is_there_much_d...)
Wouldn't your argument hold for spoken languages as well? Why do we have french and spanish? Because it would be impossible to force most people to learn the other language.
English is the widely spoken for economical reasons and yet that's only 13% of the world population.
No sign language has that kind of pull. We would need TV shows / movies that pushed a particular sign. The internet helps but how do you prevent groups from drifting?
At some point accents become dialect that become languages. Written ASL doesn't seem to be growing.
Why do people communicate in different languages? Because they live in slightly disconnected social circles.
British Sign Language developed in a different direction, where fingerspelling the alphabet is very different from how it is done in ASL. So even though US and England share a spoken language, signed expression developed differently.
Same deal with signed languages around the world. They generally develop locally and incorporate influences from elsewhere, much as spoken languages do, with the local dominant spoken language having the most influence.
- "sign language" is universal
- signed languages directly correspond with the spoken language
Neither is true. the signed language in the United States and the signed language in the UK are not mutually intelligible.
That said, I am pretty comfortable in claiming that two fluent signers of very different signed languages will have a much easier time bridging a communication gap than the corresponding non-signers in the respective communities, especially since Deaf signers who grow up in a hearing world usually develop many skills around gesturing and bridging communication gaps.
Language and culture are very intertwined (stories, jokes, puns, ...) I am grateful there are many languages in the same way I am grateful for many cultures.
By the way, it may interest you to know that there actually is something called International Sign. But it’s probably not what you’re looking for, since it’s basically just an unstandardised pidgin.
I understand there's partly nationalism in this, and that if Esperanto taught us something is that international languages are HARD, but I can't help but think that a single standard sign language would help communication between users and easier involvement of speakers.
Again, I hope I don't sound offensive, I'm just curious.