News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Colorado becomes first state to ban legacy college admiss... by deadmutex on Thursday May 27, 2021 @04:15PM (#27307771)
I think the argument is that someone whose parents are richer can afford to boost their kids' scores through tutoring, prep classes etc. So, if there are two identical kids, one whose parents have more resources will come out ahead.

I think one needs to be careful of survivorship bias here -- "the system worked for me, so it is fine".

The issue with banning SAT/ACTs, etc. is that is the system they're using in its place with actually better?

However, many well off parents will feel like they worked hard to move up, and provide their kids with best educational opportunities... but now the rules are changing. It is definitely a hard problem to try to equalize for wealth and at the same time not overly penalizing somewhat wealthy parents that also care about kids' education.

Re:Colorado becomes first state to ban legacy college admiss... by RHSeeger on Thursday May 27, 2021 @04:22PM (#27307883)
> So, if there are two identical kids, one whose parents have more resources will come out ahead.

This is true of pretty much every single thing they can use to measure students, though. Test scores, classwork scores, sports, extracurricular activities, social interactions; all of these things are easier for children in wealthier families.

Re:Colorado becomes first state to ban legacy college admiss... by lr4444lr on Thursday May 27, 2021 @04:46PM (#27308266)
And SATs are the ONE thing that has to be performed openly when it counts without any kind of coaching, proofreading, parental persuasion, or social connection.
Re:Colorado becomes first state to ban legacy college admiss... by deadmutex on Thursday May 27, 2021 @04:38PM (#27308133)
Indeed, it is not an easy problem