News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. moves to double Canadian lumber tariffs by RoadieRoller on Thursday May 27, 2021 @03:59PM (#27307506)
(I am not a US citizen, but visited many times) Why not build houses using concrete/cement? Poor Asian countries have been building houses for decades using concrete and less maintenance. No, it is not about weather. Concrete can be easily used in Southern US states where winter is less than a month or no snow at all. At least the structure can be concrete and the walls be wood or drywall. I think it is the wood mafia trying to make a living out of enforcing city codes to use only lumber for houses.
Re:U.S. moves to double Canadian lumber tariffs by mywittyname on Thursday May 27, 2021 @04:13PM (#27307739)
Costs.

The type of lumber used to frame American houses is (well, used to be) quite cheap. Concrete is like $10 per cubic foot. While, a timber framed wall is mostly air. An 18x8 foot wall made of timber would take about 16 boards to make and take an experienced team less than 20 minutes to put up. That's $100 or so in material costs at current (extremely high) prices, plus maybe $100 in labor (this is pretty hard to estimate, actually).

That same wall would be like $700 if made from concrete. And labor costs would be probably equally as expensive because those forms take a long time to assemble. They need to be shipped in, assembled, left to cure, disassembled, then hauled away. While lumber just needs to be dropped off the back of a truck into a pile in the yard.

Re:U.S. moves to double Canadian lumber tariffs by wearywanderer on Thursday May 27, 2021 @04:41PM (#27308179)
Poured concrete will often use a lot of lumber anyway, since the concrete needs forms to be poured into. However, using precast concrete or CMUs avoids this.
Re:U.S. moves to double Canadian lumber tariffs by saltcured on Thursday May 27, 2021 @09:56PM (#27310926)
Another type of concrete construction in parts of Asia uses prefabricated, reinforced concrete members. Piers, beams, and panels with internal steel made in a controlled factory setting and having high strength. It's a bit like half-timber construction but replacing the thick timber with concrete. They also use similar concrete for telephone or neighborhood power poles.

They are brought on site and erected by cranes and pile drivers to build the frame of a house somewhat like with large timber. The panels are set across beams to fill in floor areas, and walls are closed with non-load bearing elements, whether brick, blocks, stucco, drywall, etc. I am not sure how well this method works for seismically active areas though, where you would need to tie those in-fill wall areas into the structure.

Re:U.S. moves to double Canadian lumber tariffs by bobthepanda on Thursday May 27, 2021 @04:33PM (#27308053)
Also, a lot of home construction in the US is single family and this type of construction is by and large mostly wood.

Concrete is used as a base for apartment (like four or five over two) but wood still makes up the majority, and there aren’t a whole lot of residential projects in the country built as massive concrete tower blocks outside of some specific regions.

Re:U.S. moves to double Canadian lumber tariffs by danans on Thursday May 27, 2021 @04:09PM (#27307679)
> Why not build houses using concrete/cement?

Partially because until recently, wood was the most plentiful and cost-effective building material in parts of the US. It is far more seismically resilient than brick or concrete.

It is also much easier to modify if you want to add a window or other opening - cutting an opening in a concrete or cinder block wall is much harder.

Wood, when responsibly harvested, also sequesters C02.

That all said, it's possible we'll see an uptick in the popularity of alternative structural materials to wood - but traditional concrete has an absolutely massive carbon footprint, and low-carbon and low cost concrete alternatives aren't readily available on the market at this time.

Re:U.S. moves to double Canadian lumber tariffs by bobthepanda on Thursday May 27, 2021 @04:28PM (#27307981)
There have been recent developments in wood skyscrapers for the benefits you mentioned, so I would bet wood only gets more popular.
Re:U.S. moves to double Canadian lumber tariffs by ericmay on Thursday May 27, 2021 @04:51PM (#27308368)
We don’t even need to build those at all… let alone with wood.
Re:U.S. moves to double Canadian lumber tariffs by bobthepanda on Thursday May 27, 2021 @05:57PM (#27309082)
We don’t need to do much of anything, but tall buildings are fine, given that they minimize the land impact of a given amount of square footage, and denser communities have lower land footprint and lower per capita carbon emissions.

(European cities are plenty dense at moderate heights, but they also offer much smaller living quarters than American ones; a Parisian studio is in the range of 9-35 m^2 whereas an average Manhattan studio is 51 m^2, and most Americans would consider it small.)

Re:U.S. moves to double Canadian lumber tariffs by ericmay on Thursday May 27, 2021 @07:46PM (#27310027)
Skyscrapers specifically (tall buildings depends on definition of height), but they’re very energy intensive. You can only operate, construct, and maintain them with cheap oil.

The problem isn’t density (most European towns are perfect here actually) but too much density. Manhattan is the opposite spectrum of suburbia, and neither are very desirable. France actually does this well in Paris, as you mentioned. The American thing to do would be tear down every arrondissement and replace with skyscrapers. Paris sort of made that mistake with part of the city before they stopped.

I have to imagine that it's not that skyscrapers are great for emissions, but that the suburbs are just abysmal and so everything looks good in comparison.

Walkable neighborhoods and bike-friendly development in mixed-use medium density areas is probably the best. The main issue with suburbs is that you have to drive everywhere, not necessarily the density.

Re:U.S. moves to double Canadian lumber tariffs by bobthepanda on Thursday May 27, 2021 @08:50PM (#27310514)
Operating them is not that expensive. A building's heating and cooling needs are proportional to surface area, not volume, and in a given apartment building the vast majority of walls are shared with other units instead of outside. So a taller building is more and more efficient with regards to climate control, unless it doesn't contain a whole lot of volume. The Burj Khalifa is obviously not ideal but at least judging by, say, Hong Kong the optimal sweet spot for a building is 30-40 stories, where you're not running into massive extremes of either cost or carbon emission.

The reason the suburbs perform so poorly is, among other things, transport very quickly becomes the largest contributor to emissions. Hong Kong is so dense that not only is the "fifteen minute city" more than a reality for non-work trips, but most people are within a 15 minute walk or bus ride of massive shopping malls with department stores.

That being said, the end picture looks fuzzy after some more searching, mostly because it's hard to isolate variables about cities (their wealth, their climate, etc.) and also because the definition of what a "city" is varies globally. Other than "very car oriented suburbs with large lots and home sizes are big carbon emitters per capita."

Re:U.S. moves to double Canadian lumber tariffs by dzhiurgis on Friday May 28, 2021 @03:32AM (#27312667)
Ask people where would they rather live Hong Kong or Auckland (being second worst sprawl after LA)...
Re:U.S. moves to double Canadian lumber tariffs by bobthepanda on Friday May 28, 2021 @01:38PM (#27318300)
Ask people if they would prefer to work or win the lotto.

It's impractical for everyone to win the lotto.

Re:U.S. moves to double Canadian lumber tariffs by ericmay on Friday May 28, 2021 @11:38AM (#27316685)
The building's heating and cooling are just one part of the equation - you also have massive amounts of construction materials, lack of tree coverage, maintenance, transportation of materials to and from the building, etc. You did call these things out a bit in your post toward the end. I'd also argue the lack of local agriculture and the need to ship massive amounts of materials to skyscraper cities is an unaccounted for c02 emissions problem as well.

> Hong Kong is so dense that not only is the "fifteen minute city" more than a reality for non-work trips, but most people are within a 15 minute walk or bus ride of massive shopping malls with department stores.

I bet Munich or Amsterdam are 15 minute cities too and you don't need the skyscrapers (or at least as many).

You also rightly called out that the car-oriented suburbs are big time carbon emitters. How will this change with electric cars? Will suburbs become more competitive with cities on a per-capita emissions basis? Idk. If they get close to parity that would be an alarming development for proponents of cities. I think the suburbs have a lot of potential if we could relax zoning laws and more people did things like have suburban gardens.

The ideal state IMO are mixed-use, walkable and bike-able neighborhoods. They should incorporate the local environment well. If you live near the Mediterranean you paint your house white to keep it cool ad develop architectural characteristics. If you live in Ohio you have lots of tree cover, etc. Suburbs are undesirable for obvious reasons, but I think cities will be/are undesirable for other less understood reasons. Right now people in America look to them and say hey look they have great c02 emissions but it depends on what you compare them to. Do small towns and villages in Normandy have worse per-capita c02 emissions?

We also have to consider there is an acceptable level of c02 emissions either way, we don't need to race to the bottom. Overall I'd say if we focus on living sustainably, and reduce the need for nation-state level manufacturing and support, we'd be better off.

Re:U.S. moves to double Canadian lumber tariffs by bobthepanda on Friday May 28, 2021 @01:08PM (#27317938)
I have the opposite opinion; skyscrapers minimize the amount of land used for housing, so they are fantastic at reducing land impact.

Disconnected lawns or apartment courtyards and single street trees are far too small to provide a meaningful, thriving ecosystem, particularly for roaming animals. Hong Kong's extreme density, meanwhile, allows 40% of the territory's land to be uninterrupted natural habitat.

The lack of local agriculture is a far greater issue than just what skyscrapers enable. At least in the US (I'm sure in Europe as well) the seasonality of food is no longer a huge deal for availability because we're willing to ship produce halfway around the world, and that's a problem for both cities and suburbs.

I'm not super confident that the timeline for our electricity getting green is going to proceed at the pace required. And there are also lots of other things electric cars don't fix, like extensive amounts of roadway runoff from roads and parking lots, impact to physical habitats, higher energy use, etc. There still isn't a great heating or cooling solution that is both low energy and works in temperature extremes, and your US suburban homeowner would balk at buying a property without AC.

Re:U.S. moves to double Canadian lumber tariffs by ericmay on Friday May 28, 2021 @02:25PM (#27318835)
> I have the opposite opinion; skyscrapers minimize the amount of land used for housing, so they are fantastic at reducing land impact.

I don't think land impact (assuming we're talking about the same thing) is much of an issue. Most places in Europe for example, these small towns and whatnot live quite ok with nature without having to concentrate all human activity into a city.

> The lack of local agriculture is a far greater issue than just what skyscrapers enable. At least in the US (I'm sure in Europe as well) the seasonality of food is no longer a huge deal for availability because we're willing to ship produce halfway around the world, and that's a problem for both cities and suburbs.

Yes but they make the problem worse. Nobody in NYC can farm, for example. I can grow a decent vegetable garden in my backyard in the suburbs (and I do). These cities also enable excess population density which require all of these things to be flown and shipped in because it's impossible to get locally. Suburbs even do a better job than this.

I'm not super confident that the timeline for our electricity getting green is going to proceed at the pace required. And there are also lots of other things electric cars don't fix, like extensive amounts of roadway runoff from roads and parking lots, impact to physical habitats, higher energy use, etc. There still isn't a great heating or cooling solution that is both low energy and works in temperature extremes,

The solution is to look back to what worked in the past for inspiration. Tree coverage, specific construction materials, etc.

> and your US suburban homeowner would balk at buying a property without AC.

Yea... and nobody is buying a condo in NYC without air conditioning or heat either.

Re:U.S. moves to double Canadian lumber tariffs by hwbehrens on Thursday May 27, 2021 @04:06PM (#27307626)
It varies between regions, but in general, building with wood is significantly faster and less expensive than using concrete. They are also easier to remodel, extend, and ultimately demolish, but these are secondary reasons.

Some areas, such as regions of Florida or Arizona for example, have substantial historical housing stock made from concrete. However, the majority of new construction is wood for the reasons stated above.

There are not (to my knowledge) any building codes that prohibit concrete construction for residential.

Re:U.S. moves to double Canadian lumber tariffs by gresrun on Thursday May 27, 2021 @04:39PM (#27308149)
At least in FL, slab-on-grade with concrete block for the first story + wood frame for additional stories is incredibly common because it is far less susceptible to termite & moisture rot damage than slab + wood frame or wooden pier + beam.
Re:U.S. moves to double Canadian lumber tariffs by spideymans on Thursday May 27, 2021 @04:06PM (#27307622)
Environmental concerns are one reason. Concrete is more environmentally intensive than lumber, and the construction industry already accounts for a significant portion (about 10%) of global GHG emissions. We should be moving away from using concrete when more sustainable alternatives exist.
Re:U.S. moves to double Canadian lumber tariffs by jandrewrogers on Thursday May 27, 2021 @04:20PM (#27307848)
Two reasons: cost and earthquakes.

The US has vast timber forests, so it is inexpensive, and timber (or steel) framing works well for earthquake resistant construction. A large part of the US is a seismic hazard zone and the building regulations reflect that. You can find older neighborhoods with unreinforced masonry throughout the US but those date from a time before they had modern building regulations and before the extent of earthquake risks were fully understood.

Re:U.S. moves to double Canadian lumber tariffs by clusterfish on Thursday May 27, 2021 @04:03PM (#27307569)
It's more expensive and has a terrible environmental impact. Forestry at least can be sustainable if done right
Re:U.S. moves to double Canadian lumber tariffs by sorenjan on Thursday May 27, 2021 @04:30PM (#27308012)
According to this article [0], cement is the source of 8% of the worlds carbon dioxide emissions. Switching from renewable materials like wood to carbon emitters like concrete is not what the world needs right now.

[0] https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-46455844

Re:U.S. moves to double Canadian lumber tariffs by MattGaiser on Thursday May 27, 2021 @04:02PM (#27307558)
Americans tend to want very large homes by global standards and lumber is (or at least was) cheaper.
Re:U.S. moves to double Canadian lumber tariffs by dotcommand on Thursday May 27, 2021 @10:50PM (#27311223)
> I think it is the wood mafia trying to make a living out of enforcing city codes to use only lumber for houses.

Not really. No more than the ice mafia made the inuit build igloos out of ice. People do with what they have. The eastern seaboard is chock full of trees. When the settlers arrived, they used what was readily available. It's far easier for settlers to make homes out of wood than stone/rocks/etc and concrete didn't exist back in the 1600s/1700s. And as the borders of the country expanded westward, the style of homes made its way west as well.

Re:U.S. moves to double Canadian lumber tariffs by kenned3 on Thursday May 27, 2021 @06:23PM (#27309326)
My ex-wife is Chinese from a city in China where everything is made out of cement.

The reason? The region also lacks trees. They have an abundance of the raw materials for cement, but not wood.. So that is what they used.

Cement is also a terrible material for many climates. Here (ontario) the freeze/thaw cycle causes it to crack unless you use a lot of costly methods to prevent this.

Re:U.S. moves to double Canadian lumber tariffs by bcrl on Friday May 28, 2021 @10:06PM (#27322512)
Portland cement has a significantly worse environmental footprint than wood. One removes carbon from the atmosphere while the other releases it.