News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Have you ever hurt yourself from your own code? by blablabla123 on Thursday May 27, 2021 @02:38PM (#27306502)
I mean more the "Why don't you ..." It's quite obvious that it's rethorical but it seems so nonsensical to put this into a question while camouflaging what is really going on.
Re:Have you ever hurt yourself from your own code? by aynsof on Thursday May 27, 2021 @07:12PM (#27309759)
What an interesting question!

As others have said, it's definitely a 'softening' of a request to make it more polite ('Go home' vs 'Would it be possible for you to go home?').

But I think there are some status games going on here, too. A subordinate would never use that phrasing with a superior.

While the phrase uses conditional language to 'soften' the request, it's also an imperative (an order) that's made to look like a request.

Try to imagine the boss saying this. How would they have said it - with an upward inflection at the end, as in a question like this one? Definitely not! The phrase would definitely end on a downward inflection, as in an order like 'Please go home'.

It's a curious turn of phrase that I'd suggest is particular to managers, parents, and other authority figures that need to maintain a veneer of respect for their subordinates. It also strikes me as uniquely American; I couldn't imagine a Brit or an Australian saying something like this (but happy to be corrected).

Re:Have you ever hurt yourself from your own code? by blablabla123 on Saturday May 29, 2021 @01:59PM (#27327011)
Thanks for the detailed answer! That makes it really understandable :)
Re:Have you ever hurt yourself from your own code? by HeyLaughingBoy on Thursday May 27, 2021 @05:20PM (#27308701)
Don't feel bad :-) My 11 year-old son (a native English speaker) said the same thing to me just yesterday.

"Hey, bud. Why don't you pick up those two plastic containers and follow me."

"OK, but dad, it really confuses me when you say that. Can't you just say 'please pick up those containers'? It sounds like you're giving me an option but you're really not."

Until he said that, I had never given it a thought. But he takes things very literally, so I can see how it's confusing even though he knows what I mean.

Re:Have you ever hurt yourself from your own code? by kibbleble on Friday May 28, 2021 @01:37AM (#27312080)
Did your son really say "can't you just say?" :P

I think English littered with these suggestive polite negation statements.

Re:Have you ever hurt yourself from your own code? by HeyLaughingBoy on Friday May 28, 2021 @10:34AM (#27315791)
LOL. I didn't even notice that :-)
Re:Have you ever hurt yourself from your own code? by schoen on Friday May 28, 2021 @01:11AM (#27311940)
It occurs to me that Spanish can also have this, which I only know because of this incident:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/%C2%BFPor_qu%C3%A9_no_te_calla...

(I don't know whether it has exactly the same set of connotations in Spanish as in English, but it doesn't seem like the king expected Chavez to do something other than comply.)

Re:Have you ever hurt yourself from your own code? by dentemple on Thursday May 27, 2021 @04:54PM (#27308405)
The "camouflage" here indicates an increase in the speaker's politeness level. Some languages use explicit terms or forms of address to do this; English, however, utilizes indirect phrasing to achieve this effect.
Re:Have you ever hurt yourself from your own code? by adrianmonk on Thursday May 27, 2021 @03:47PM (#27307359)
I'd say the purpose is more or less to show respect. By phrasing it as an idea or a suggestion, you give them the chance to (appear to) cooperate willingly.

Both people presumably do know what's really happening, and this is exactly why it's seen as unnecessary (and inconsiderate) to actually say it. There's no reason to call extra attention to something unpleasant.