They’ve all gone well for us, so I recommend them from that point of view, but on the other hand, I don’t recommend them because I’d hate to have any hand in a situation that went wrong for someone else.
Our last we actually delivered on our own because the midwifes didn’t get to us in time.
Birth - a natural process - has been commercially medicalised, especially in Brasil (C-section rate >60%) and the US (>30%). If giving birth at home was normalised, we'd see a huge growth in natural birth and an increased availability for medical staff to support in emergencies if required. But the rates of emergencies would actually decline too.
Otherwise I think it’s an awesome idea and encourage people to consider it.
Birthing centers are also a great alternative. I do not especially like the idea of hospitals as default places of birth, but acknowledge the potential value when needed.
My wife had unexpected complications that would have been disastrous, possibly fatal if we had been at home rather than a hospital for delivery. I can’t imagine trying to rush her from home to the hospital mid-delivery.
I’m forever grateful for the medical care we received at the hospital during delivery. It’s simply not possible to deliver the same care at home.
You can get much better service for way less money if you avoid the red tape and do a home birth.