News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:83% of Americans Are Belt Tightening Due to Inflation Pre... by wolverine876 on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @02:38PM (#27294395)
The headline confuses me: If that large proportion were 'tightening their belts', economic activity would decline and there would be no inflation. An inflation headline would be, '83% of Americans are buying new cars/computers/homes/washer-dryers' or '83% of Americans have borrowed more than last year'. Inflation is an excess of economic activity - too much money for the available truly valuable investments. It's people buying cryptographic strings, hoping they will go up in value, and the values nominally going up because so many are buying it.

I doubt 83% of Americans know what inflation is, much less know about the current debates around it or understand its effects. I question whether 83% could be reacting to reports of inflation.

Inflation has been turned into a bad word, but the post-Great Recession era of near-nil inflation is the anomaly. Generally, through most of my life of reading economists, a low level of inflation (e.g, 2-3%) is considered the healthiest state.

I think part of it is politicization: Whenever someone talks about government spending or stimulus, particularly around the Great Recession in 2008 and the Coronavirus pandemic, people who advocate for small government use inflation risk as an argument against it. My feeling is that has created two conditions: 1) the stopped clock is eventually right, and 2) they've built up inflation as so much of a demon that people are afraid of it.

The direct effects of inflation are to help people with lots of fixed debt and inflationary income, because your debt of 100,000 is still 100,000 while your income inflates from e.g., 50,000 to 52,000. And it similarly hurts people with lots of fixed income or assets. The indirect effects are complicated, but again, a low level of inflation - higher than recent experience - has long been considered optimal.

Re:83% of Americans Are Belt Tightening Due to Inflation Pre... by dragonwriter on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @02:45PM (#27294473)
> The headline confuses me: If that large proportion were 'tightening their belts', economic activity would decline and there would be no inflation.

83% at the bottom could tighten their belts, and the 17% at the top who control far more wealth could loosen theirs and economic activitt would increase.

> and there would be no inflation.

Even if we assume the first incorrect statement were true, this would still be wrong: there wouldn’t be demand-pull inflation, but there still could be supply-push inflation.

> Inflation is an excess of economic activity - too much money for the available truly valuable investments.

No, inflation is an increase in consumer price levels, and has nothing directly to do with investments, though there are indirect effects in both direction.

Re:83% of Americans Are Belt Tightening Due to Inflation Pre... by wolverine876 on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @02:58PM (#27294626)
You talk about ways that the headline could be reconciled with inflation, but even if true, the headline certainly doesn't describe an inflationary situation.

> inflation is an increase in consumer price levels

That's a common and well-known symptom (because everyone can see it), but that doesn't define inflation. From Britannica:

Inflation, in economics, collective increases in the supply of money, in money incomes, or in prices.

I used the term 'investments' loosely, rather than spelling out all the possible things on which we can spend money. But actual investments, by the narrow definition, count: asset bubbles, or example, are a form of and sign of inflation (in that one market). Again, inflation is an excess of economic activity for the economic realities of the situation.

> there wouldn’t be demand-pull inflation, but there still could be supply-push inflation

If you mean 'cost-push' inflation, that is caused by increased production costs, which lower production and thus reduce supply and thus, unless demand also decreases, prices increase. If demand also decreases sufficiently, as the headline might suggest, then there's no inflation. Increased production costs aren't the concern behind the inflationary effects of various stimulus measures, which should reduce costs of production (including via cheap debt).

Re:83% of Americans Are Belt Tightening Due to Inflation Pre... by dragonwriter on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @03:04PM (#27294697)
> You talk about ways that the headline could be reconciled with inflation, but even if true, the headline certainly doesn't describe an inflationary situation.

The headline describes a response to inflation, not a cause. You are criticizing it because the response it describes does not explain the cause. Which is a silly criticism; responses aren’t supposed to explain causes.

Re:83% of Americans Are Belt Tightening Due to Inflation Pre... by wolverine876 on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @03:07PM (#27294731)
The response and cause are inputs in the same system. An economy of belt-tightening is not inflationary.

> silly

Enough said.

Re:83% of Americans Are Belt Tightening Due to Inflation Pre... by dragonwriter on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @03:36PM (#27295065)
> The response and cause are inputs in the same system.

But not to the same state. The description is of inflation at T(<n) producing belt-tightening at T(=n). You are complaining that the belt-tightening doesn’t explain the inflation. Of course it doesn’t.

Now, sure, there’s a valid question of “what is causing the inflation”; is it offsetting belt loosening in another group? Is it supply issues?

But

Re:83% of Americans Are Belt Tightening Due to Inflation Pre... by wolverine876 on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @06:15PM (#27296779)
We are in early days with little inflation. In the sequence of time T(1 .. N), what you describe applies only to T(1). For all time T(>1), the belt-tightening is an input. If 83% of Americans are doing it, inflation isn't an issue for T(>1), in which case it's a moot issue.
Re:83% of Americans Are Belt Tightening Due to Inflation Pre... by dragonwriter on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @07:47PM (#27297602)
> If 83% of Americans are doing it, inflation isn't an issue

Since I already explained why this is wrong in my first post (and you acknowledged it in your response, but shifted your criticism of thr headline to that the belt-tightening doesn’t explain inflation even though it is consistent with inflation from other causes), I think we've come full circle here.

Re:83% of Americans Are Belt Tightening Due to Inflation Pre... by wolverine876 on Thursday May 27, 2021 @12:24AM (#27299376)
> I already explained why this is wrong

Oh sorry, I didn't realize you forbade me from expressing a different opinion.