News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Who defaults first: Greece or the US? by nhaehnle on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @05:06AM (#2729145)
This whole discussion is very depressing, because it highlights how uninformed the people are about what government debt represents. At least that is what a poll with 70% against raising the debt ceiling tells me.

Government debt equals private assets, and so being against government debt is being against (at least one form of) private assets.

If you are against the accumulation of private assets for whatever reason (for example, because you're a communist - see what I did there?), there are still better ways of preventing that than making the government commit economic suicide.

Honestly, the US should just get rid of the debt ceiling altogether, and recognize that the size of the budget deficit needs to be benchmarked not against pseudo-religious standards, but against how much productive capacity is available in the real economy - because that is what you need to look at to prevent inflation (which is the only possible negative economic outcome from a budget deficit that is too large).

Edit: I would appreciate some feedback on why people vote me down. I try to reply to questions and criticism as to the contents of what I write in a calm and clear fashion. I hope people don't just vote me down because they disagree with something that I write, or find it politically uncomfortable.

Re:Who defaults first: Greece or the US? by nodata on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @05:26AM (#2729181)
Why does government debt equal private assets?

and another question: why does a huge thing like a country need debt at all, shouldn't it (on average) be debt free?

Re:Who defaults first: Greece or the US? by dexen on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @05:57AM (#2729246)
> Why does government debt equal private assets?

Not that I fully agree with his assertion, but: Gov't debt usually takes form of `bonds'. Such bonds are issued for fixed terms and traded on free market. Both private and institutional investors (including other countries) invest in bonds, thus some of gov't debt will normally be in hands of private investors.

Government bonds are considered highly secure and reliable means of investment, if somewhat low-yield. That allows the issuing country to rely on bonds for matching income to expenditures any time it needs to, at rather low cost. Should a country declare bankruptcy, or just near it, this instrument is much harder to use for the govt.

Consider having a look at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_ascent_of_money which covers the topic pretty well.

Re:Who defaults first: Greece or the US? by nhaehnle on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @06:35AM (#2729325)
> why does a huge thing like a country need debt at all, shouldn't it (on average) be debt free?

Axiomatically, if you sum up over all worldwide assets and liabilities, they sum to zero. That is a fact that simply follows from accounting. So the world as a whole is (net) debt free (until we start trading with extraterrestrials, then things might change).

The US probably is roughly net debt free on average, summing over all domestic private and government assets and liabilities. I don't have time to run the numbers right now. Certainly, even if the US is not debt free on average, its net debt towards foreigners is much less than the government debt, and also less than the sum of government debt held by foreigners.

If people just stopped looking only on one side of the coin, they would realize that and chill out over the government debt.

Re:Who defaults first: Greece or the US? by stayjin on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @08:03AM (#2729487)
It is not that simple. Have you ever wandered why counties do not have to issue balance sheets at the end of every fiscal year( or at least before every election) ?

Do you understand how easy it would be to judge how a government performed by comparing two of these? And ask all the right questions, exactly as MS investors do with the "developers, developers, developers" CEO?

Re:Who defaults first: Greece or the US? by justincormack on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @09:02AM (#2729633)
Thats just because they dont want to share the information transparently. New Zealand started issuing a real balance sheet quite some time back, and it is very interesting. It is hard to do as you need to estimate long term liabilities etc.

Here is a summary position and you can find the rest on the site http://www.treasury.govt.nz/government/longterm/fiscalpositi...

All governments should do this....

Re:Who defaults first: Greece or the US? by nodata on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @10:43AM (#2730000)
This is excellent. What prompted them to do this?
Re:Who defaults first: Greece or the US? by justincormack on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @11:03AM (#2730066)
I forget the original reasons, it was some time back. There is a statement here: http://www.treasury.govt.nz/budget/2010/is/04.htm

I seem to remember it was partly prompted by a new government wanting to prove they were fiscally responsible, but also I think there has always been quite an awareness as there is a huge earthquake reconstruction fund (now entirely in external assets) in case of disaster, which would prompt some thinking about assets and liabilities.

Re:Who defaults first: Greece or the US? by stayjin on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @11:30AM (#2730194)
This is excellent indeed.

Actually, it might come as a surprise but Greece seems to have a lot of public assets which would give it a much better clear position than many other countries in Europe if they were to be compared.

However of course, it is no secret nowadays that even with a great clear position, if cash flow is not positive you may easily go under.

Re:Who defaults first: Greece or the US? by Andrew_Quentin on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @08:09AM (#2729505)
Of course this government debt needs to be paid with interest. The ones who pay it are the taxpayers. So government debt is a way of taking from the poor, middle classes, the vast majority, and giving to the rich, or a tiny minority.
Re:Who defaults first: Greece or the US? by nhaehnle on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @11:45AM (#2730278)
You are right that interest payment is typically a redistribution of wealth towards the rich.

The interesting thing is that a monetarily sovereign government actually sets its own interest rate, via monetary policy: the interest paid on US treasuries is ultimately a function of the interest rate set by the central bank, i.e. it is a political choice.

This is initially unintuitive, but it follows from developing an understanding of the system from first principles, as is done by Modern Monetary Theory. You can read about it under the heading "What role does the bond market play in all of this?" in this article I already linked to elsewhere: http://pragcap.com/resources/understanding-modern-monetary-s... and also in Randall Wray's book "Understanding Modern Money".

Quite a number of economists in the MMT line of thought actually argue in favour of letting the interest rate drop to zero, and using fiscal policy instead of monetary policy for inflation targeting.

In other words, government debt does not need to be a way of taking from the poor. It is that way as a result of political choice - though I do not think that it was a conscious choice, since people have not really internalised how our monetary system works these days.

Re:Who defaults first: Greece or the US? by justincormack on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @06:50AM (#2729358)
The fact that net debt is zero does not make people or countries creditworthy and able to pay.
Re:Who defaults first: Greece or the US? by tobylane on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @06:00AM (#2729253)
Government debt is apparently a good thing, it encourages internal private (businesses of that country) growth. I can't find more about it, it is something worth understanding properly.
Re:Who defaults first: Greece or the US? by nhaehnle on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @06:40AM (#2729337)
I should probably add some information on where my analysis is coming from. I am writing from a perspective of Functional Finance and Modern Monetary Theory. You can find a clear intro to the latter here: http://pragcap.com/resources/understanding-modern-monetary-s...

One of its most prolific proponent is economics professor Bill Mitchell who blogs here: http://bilbo.economicoutlook.net/blog/

See his Debriefing 101 category for more introductory posts: http://bilbo.economicoutlook.net/blog/?cat=11

Re:Who defaults first: Greece or the US? by borism on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @07:44AM (#2729458)
Thank you! MMT was very eye opening for me.
Re:Who defaults first: Greece or the US? by Steko on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @07:05AM (#2729393)
Well I gave you an upvote for reaching the correct takeaways (public uninformed and we need to raise debt limit) but I can see a couple reasons you might be downvoted:

(1) Presenting a heterodox theory as fact or mainstream.

(2) Muddled argument. The whole "being against government debt is being against private assets" line is incredibly weak. The less forceful but less controversial version of this argument is simply that the debt is a (possible) long term problem but we have a real short term crisis that is more important. As Brad DeLong says if you have some corroded gas pipes that might explode in 10 years you'll want to fix that eventually but that doesn't mean you don't turn on the heat during a blizzard.

Re:Who defaults first: Greece or the US? by mongol on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @05:28AM (#2729186)
Why is it so good with private assets that most likely are outside the country? How does it help taxpayers?
Re:Who defaults first: Greece or the US? by nhaehnle on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @06:30AM (#2729316)
First of all, "most likely" is false. Actual numbers can easily be found, here's a secondary source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Estimated_ownership_of_tre...

So less than one third is held by foreigners. This is more than for most other countries, but keep in mind that much of world trade is still run in US$ - this is what people (hopefully) mean when they say that it is a quasi-reserve currency, which naturally drives up demand for US$-denominated financial assets.

Second, the fact that so much of those assets are held by foreigners has greatly benefited US citizens up to this point in time, because the foreigners holding those assets obtained them by selling their products to the US. So the US was able to receive a lot of real, physical goods that cost actual physical resources and work to produce, in exchange for the US simply running a computer system on which accounts are managed. If you ask me, that is a very good deal.

Now, once China gets their act together and becomes able to change their economy into one that is not so export-heavy, they will sell of their assets over time. This will force the US to become a nation with net exports again.

But from the perspective of US citizens, the worst case is that the US enjoys more physical resources (than it would be able to without trade) now at the cost of enjoying less (than they would be able to without trade) in the future. And in fact, they cannot even be forced to take that full hit in the future, because they could always choose to inflate the debt away.

Now you may say that you would rather suffer a decrease in resources that you can enjoy now than suffering that decrease in the future. That is a reasonable political stance.

However, the reality is that especially China is hell-bent on sending real goods to the US in exchange for paper. Trying to cut the budget deficit or to reduce debt directly is not going to change that. In fact, it will hurt US citizens long before it will hurt China.

The only way to stop the flow of financial assets towards foreigners is via a combination of trade barriers and helping China to turn their economy into a domestic-consumption-based economy.

Re:Who defaults first: Greece or the US? by bad_user on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @05:46AM (#2729219)
So, this may be a stupid question but - What happens when a country defaults? What are the consequences of that?
Re:Who defaults first: Greece or the US? by nhaehnle on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @06:56AM (#2729374)
Since other commenters focus on the negative effects of the default, let me explain the potential positive effects for the citizens of the country of a default combined with an exit of the Euro in the case of Greece. (There are no potential positive effects of a default for the US.)

The major problem that is facing Greek citizens these days is that because the Greek government's hands are tied in monetary things, the country cannot achieve its full potential.

Since Greece was a net importer for a long time, money has been leaving the main part of the Greek economy [1]. Now Greeks no longer have as much money to afford imports - which would be only fair in some sense - but worse than that, they no longer have money to pay each other. This is what causes the very high unemployment in Greece.

Now you would say, if you have person A who would like to sell to person B, and person B who would like to sell to person A, and neither of them have any money, they could still do their transaction, and so not having any money to pay each other is not a problem. That is true in this very simple scenario.

The real modern economy is much more complex than that, and situations where two people genuinely just trade with each other almost never occur. So Greece has become stuck, people are unemployed, which means that the country is not reaching its productive potential.

By re-introducing its own currency, the Greek government could restart the spending cycle.

It is without doubt that a new Greek currency (NGC) would immediately drop in value compared to other currencies. There is nothing that can be done about that, and it is the reason why a reintroduction of NGC needs to go along with a default (or a technical default where the debts are revalued once in NGC, so that the exchange rate no longer matters).

It is also true that the short-term pain for Greeks would not go away immediately. Imports would be very expensive in NGC and difficult to afford, but this is not that much different from the current situation where imports are difficult to afford because the money is missing.

Most importantly, the Greek government would be able to introduce an economic expansion program to put people to work, so that the real capacity of Greece itself would be used fully to the benefits of Greek citizens.

Edit: I should add that this scenario has already played out in the case of developing countries and particularly many times in South America, e.g. in Argentina.

[1] Of course, there are also very rich Greeks. However, they save their money and don't invest in Greece at this time (because the economy is bad), so their money does not enter into the picture.

Re:Who defaults first: Greece or the US? by turbojerry on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @01:56PM (#2730817)
Yes something similar has happened in Argentina as you mention, however perhaps you are not aware of the negative side, I would recommend you read FerFals blog-

http://ferfal.blogspot.com/

You'll note the current entry, 4th July 2011 is "10 Things you must know about Home Invasions" proceeded by "Survival Kits" and a little further down "Armoured Vehicles", or perhaps if you're interested in how business is conducted after such a collapse you might read this article about doing business in Argentina-

http://www.inc.com/magazine/201106/doing-business-in-argenti...

Re:Who defaults first: Greece or the US? by nhaehnle on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @02:37AM (#2732808)
Oh, I am not saying that Argentina is in a perfectly happy situation. The huge problem in economics is that you cannot really do comparative studies, but how do you think Argentina would have developed if they hadn't let their currency float freely (and as a consequence defaulted on their government debt)?

There is at least a clear correlation between defaulting and subsequent growth of the economy, and there is a very plausible theoretical reason (roughly outlined in my earlier post) that this connection is causal: defaulting and free-floating currency is what allowed Argentina to return to a path of growth.

This does not mean that things will be perfect immediately or even 10 years later. It just means that - assuming responsible economic stewardship - the country can go back to fully realizing and growing its potential.

Re:Who defaults first: Greece or the US? by gnosis on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @02:50PM (#2731045)
But are these consequences of a default, or of other things going on in their society?
Re:Who defaults first: Greece or the US? by retube on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @06:40AM (#2729336)
A lot of people lose a lot of money. Many institutions hold first-world sovereign debt as supposedly almost risk-free investments with guaranteed (fixed-income) returns. These institutions include banks, pension funds and other investment funds and vehicles into which both corporates and individuals will have invested their money.

Plus you also have those that have insurance against a sovereign default, largely through credit default swaps (CDS). However unlike many forms of insurance, you don't need to actually own the bond to take out a CDS on it. In this way many people will trade the risk of a Greek default without actually going anywhere near the physical asset. Being a derivative product, the size of the CDS market on Greek debt is likely to be many, many, many times greater than the size of the underlying basket of bonds.

So if Greece defaults - or even "technically" defaults, which could include the proposed rollover into longer-dated bonds - this could have huge implications for people who are short this insurance. They're all going to have to pay out.

Apart from the direct financial impact, with Greece you have the additional embarrassment and complication due to being part of the Euro. Greece may be forced to leave the single currency, which is going to be a costly and messy exercise, and severely damage the reputation and credibility of the currency.

Re:Who defaults first: Greece or the US? by tobylane on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @05:57AM (#2729245)
Their loans get more expensive, and everyone who loaned to them has to write off the loans, or extend them a lot. Greece's loans are currently 1 year, if I understood correctly the plan for their default is to turn them into 30 year loans, like South America did ~25 years ago.

Also, like Greece is now, the country has to have massive public service cuts, and tax hikes. Have the republicans been asked about the possibility of this?

Re:Who defaults first: Greece or the US? by StavrosK on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @06:13AM (#2729285)
I read an article the other day about how about 54% of an average salary goes to the government in one form or another. Unfortunately, it's in Greek, but, from what I saw, it was very accurate.
Re:Who defaults first: Greece or the US? by tobylane on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @06:22AM (#2729301)
That's true of most countries, and it's much lower than it used to be, mid Cold War UK and US top tax rates were 85 and 90 just for income tax. Now top tax rate is 50, but then you have National Insurance (NHS) and so on. If you buy something pre-tax you can save over 60%.
Re:Who defaults first: Greece or the US? by StavrosK on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @06:25AM (#2729311)
That's for top tax rate, though (over 100k, in Greece). I'm talking about the more average salaries, about 45k gross, which comes out to about 1700 EUR/mo net (after just income tax and insurance payments). Taxes on cigarettes, gas, etc are still absurdly high (something like 80% of the price of cigarettes is tax, if I remember correctly).
Re:Who defaults first: Greece or the US? by skarayan on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @05:57AM (#2729247)
It depends on many things including the size of the debt and to whom. In the least, it will damage the reputation of the country, make it harder to borrow in the future, and hurt its relationships with other countries.

What happens when a company defaults on its debt? Its rating goes down, reputation is hurt, etc. Same deal, except it's more global with a country.

Re:Who defaults first: Greece or the US? by jvdh on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @05:56AM (#2729242)
Basically, it renogatiates the terms of outstanding debts to a new interest rate, and longer terms.

See also: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sovereign_default

Re:Who defaults first: Greece or the US? by bad_user on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @05:58AM (#2729248)
So that doesn't sound so bad.

Why are people freaking out on the US, Greece and Spain?

Sorry, I'm totally unfamiliar with these things.

Re:Who defaults first: Greece or the US? by chalst on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @08:22AM (#2729537)
Bonds are not like equities. Bonds pay out a fixed amount of interest, and so there is no chance of hitting the lottery; with equities, the company stock can skyrocket.

Hence bonds are a risk-averse investment, and so bond holders are very jumpy about default.

The Greek bonds, IIRC, before the CDS rates (credit default swap: basically a bet on the chance of a bond going into default) started creeping up, were issued at around 3% coupon. This value is consistent only with a very low perceived risk of serious default by the buyers of bonds. At the moment, CDS markets are showing a near probability of Greece going into default: the bond rates are artificially low only because of massive government and IMF intervention in the markets.

Note also that even after the drastic austerity measures, Greece is still running a budget deficit, so if it defaults, it cannot finance its expenses even in the short term.

Greece is small fry, but it is seen as a test case for bigger countries: probably Spain, possibly Italy. Actually, the situation is worse in Portugal than Greece, since Portugal is also insolvent and has shown nothing like the political resolve that Greece has. But Portugal is tiny.

Many of the banks in wealthier European countries are heavily exposed to PIGS (Portugal-Spain-Ireland-Greece) debt, so expect serious PIGS defaults to be followed by rich country bank crises. German banks, in particular, are badly exposed to Spanish government debt. The "stress tests" of European banks carried out in 2010 explicitly did not test for sovereign default, presumably to avoid frightening bond holders.

Re:Who defaults first: Greece or the US? by thaumaturgy on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @06:42AM (#2729343)
Because a default -- even a "technical" default in the form of an extension or renegotiation -- indicates a serious problem in a country's finances, which can affect its credit rating and, in turn, its ability to continue borrowing as well as the value of its currency.

The U.S. has defaulted before, in 1933, but this would still be considered a very significant event in global economics, and economists really don't need another reason to get nervous right now.

There is, by the way, an interesting elephant in the room that I've yet to hear mentioned anywhere: once we've gotten to the point that people start discussing the possibility of simultaneous defaults of several major countries, nobody's really sure what will happen next, and, nobody's really sure how to get out of the hole, since we've never been in this deep before.

Re:Who defaults first: Greece or the US? by gnosis on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @02:58PM (#2731081)
"The U.S. has defaulted before, in 1933"

So it's defaulted.. and look where it is now.

If Greece looks to the US as a model it should default, and the sooner the better.

"Because a default ... can affect its credit rating and, in turn, its ability to continue borrowing..."

Borrowing is what got Greece in trouble in the first place. Perhaps putting and end to borrowing from other countries would put it on a sounder financial footing. At least it would never again get in to the situation where many future generations would be forced to repay the debts of their ancestors.

Re:Who defaults first: Greece or the US? by jvdh on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @07:18AM (#2729421)
In itself the renegotiation is not that bad, and often works out. What makes it worse is that the government openly admits that it has a very big problem in staying solvent. This makes it harder for them to get new loans in the future. Also other financial institutions will lose trust in that country, causing money to flow out and devaluation of the currency. This in turn makes it harder for that country to do business with others.

In the end, hard measures will have to be taken so that trust can be restored.

Re:Who defaults first: Greece or the US? by tobylane on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @06:02AM (#2729258)
US total debt is apparently nearly 55 trillion dollars [1] which is a massive amount to suddenly be written off by banks and governments all over the world. One of many many effects is that your cost of living will rise quickly.

http://www.usdebtclock.org/

Re:Who defaults first: Greece or the US? by nhaehnle on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @06:47AM (#2729356)
The US total debt is actually more like 14 trillion dollars.

People come up with this 55 trillion dollar numbers by adding in future social security-type outlays, which are always paid out of the current budget. These types of numbers are a form of FUD which is spread by ideologues.

Think about it this way. Suppose you rent an apartment for 1500$ per month, and expect to live in it for the next 10 years. If you follow the logic of the people who claim a 55 trillion debt, then you would claim that you now have a debt of 180,000$.

We all know that that claim is ridiculous, but unfortunately, the same flawed logic is slightly harder to detect and unravel when it comes to something as complex as the entire economy.

Re:Who defaults first: Greece or the US? by Someone on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @07:07AM (#2729395)
There is a difference in commitment. You can easily get out of that apartment, but not out of those future social security-type outlays. That is why accountants call 'future payable' stuff a debt.

That "out of their current budget" is irrelevant. Most people who buy a house on mortgage pay of their debt out of their current budget, too. A mortgage still is a debt, though (ideally (more than) balanced by the worth of the property you bought for the mortgage)

Re:Who defaults first: Greece or the US? by borism on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @07:48AM (#2729467)
This is called restructuring, not a default.
Re:Who defaults first: Greece or the US? by chalst on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @08:07AM (#2729501)
Restructuring avoids default only if the creditors agree to it before default.

Default is any failure to pay the full amount of the coupon on a bond on time, where the coupon on a bond is the specification of which sums of money are payable when.

Re:Who defaults first: Greece or the US? by pwaring on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @07:55AM (#2729476)
A restructuring can be classed as a default by the rating agencies, and for the purposes of paying out on credit default swaps.
Re:Who defaults first: Greece or the US? by Andrew_Quentin on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @08:03AM (#2729489)
I am not sure if this is correct, but I think one consequence would be that the lenders will take over the assets of the country such as public industry, forestry, etc, as it happened in Russia and sell them at any price to whoever wants to buy them.
Re:Who defaults first: Greece or the US? by andrewaylett on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @04:22AM (#2729078)
I find it hard to believe that some kind of agreement won't be reached, whether it'll be a sensible one or not, but it's certainly fair to say that there's a chance of disaster, and that a US default would be an awful lot worse than a Greek one.
Re:Who defaults first: Greece or the US? by thaumaturgy on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @06:43AM (#2729349)
An agreement absolutely will be reached, but that doesn't make the situation much better. It's quite likely that Congress will have to accept yet another increase of the debt ceiling, while we'll see even more cuts from social services at home.
Re:Who defaults first: Greece or the US? by stayjin on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @07:46AM (#2729462)
An honest, yet a little bit provocative, question: The "mainstream" explanation regarding Greek dept is because Greeks are bon viveurs who spent all the money they could put their hands on on drinking and gambling without financial control. Does anybody know any explanation regarding the US debt?
Re:Who defaults first: Greece or the US? by blumentopf on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @07:44AM (#2729459)
Hilarious typo in a headline in the middle of that article:

"Pubic opinion"