News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:YouTube approves ad by Belarusian gov with journalist fro... by shadowgovt on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @06:09PM (#27283360)
It was an interesting experience.

I went in assuming someone's in charge, but honestly, most of the mistakes Google makes are in the category "nobody's in charge." They operate at a scale where everyone tries to use them to do everything. That's everything good and everything bad. They've been both a force for normalizing LGBTQ identity and a force against it, a mass communication tool and a mass oppression tool, a platform to help people and a platform to stalk people. They actively manage, observe, maintain, and regulate only a subset of the space of uses their tools allow.

This is explanation, not excuse. I'm not there anymore because I think it should be their responsibility to take responsibility reflective of their size and impact. I lost faith that the leadership agreed.

In this specific example, my assumption from personal priors is they let this ad in because there's nobody in charge of negative-filtering ads like this until complaints come, and in the absence of policy the default policy is "allow." They have categories to catch ads for illegal substances, various forms of illegal activity, and so on, but "A state-level actor will use our ad platform to paint a false message of the status of a political prisoner" is a new one for them.

Re:YouTube approves ad by Belarusian gov with journalist fro... by philsnow on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @06:36PM (#27283623)
> I'm not there anymore because I think it should be their responsibility to take responsibility reflective of their size and impact. I lost faith that the leadership agreed.

I fully agree with you, and I don't think that there's any going back: the founders don't care about this, a CEO generally only takes a principled stand on things like this when it's their baby, but Google is not Sundar's baby.

Re:YouTube approves ad by Belarusian gov with journalist fro... by mleonhard on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @06:21PM (#27283489)
If it looks like nobody in Google is in charge, it's only because the execs refuse to take action and the board refuses to properly incentivize the execs.
Re:YouTube approves ad by Belarusian gov with journalist fro... by shadowgovt on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @06:39PM (#27283653)
And perhaps importantly: the board can't incentivize the execs. Not alone.

Alphabet is still majority-owned by the founders as of 2019. In practice, the board is advisory; 100% of stockholders who's names aren't "Larry Page" and "Sergey Brin" could vote the same on an issue, and the issue will carry in whatever direction Larry and Sergey say it should if both agree.

Re:YouTube approves ad by Belarusian gov with journalist fro... by ocdtrekkie on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @06:39PM (#27283668)
"The board" is Larry and Sergey, from a realistic voting power standpoint. All of this is ultimately their fault.