Re:Tim Cook’s Fortnite trial testimony was unexpectedly reve...
by mywittyname on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @01:16PM
(#27279541)
> These are all things "general-purpose" computers are capable of. You've just drawn the line where it happens to be convenient for this argument.
That's basically the entire purpose of court decisions: to draw a line in the sand regarding what behavior is allowed. This is free speech; that is not. This is an illegal search; that is not. This is cruel & unusual punishment; that is not. This is tortuous negligence; that is not. So yes, I am drawing a line exactly where I think it should be.
The alternative is that there is no legal distinction between computing devices. So software in a car, laundry machine, POS terminal, phone, laptop, smart light, etc all share the same rules. So if a Windows laptop must be able to install arbitrary software, then Toyota needs allow for the same in their cars. And if Apple can lock down installation of software on their devices, then Dell is allowed to do the same (and if that's the case, can Intel do the same and only run certain code?).
A legal classification here is, IMHO, the preferred outcome of this case. Whatever the decision made here is, it will have very far reaching implications on technology. Though, if the case were to say that all computing systems are the same, I'd prefer Apple to lose and all computer systems be forced open, than allowed to be closed. Since having cheap video game consoles is not really worth the cost to society of allowing for locked down computer systems.
> If banking apps and Photoshop are what makes a computer "general-purpose", then we'll see banking apps and Photoshop banned from platforms.
Also, my argument is whether or not these types of apps "make sense," as in, a customer base exists for such apps on said platform that there is the market pressure to create one. Not whether not such apps are "allowed." It's certainly allowable to make such apps for the Xbox, there's just not a market to do so; it doesn't jibe with customers perceived uses of said devices. Customers want to check their bank account on their iPhones; they have no desire to do so on their Xbox.
That's basically the entire purpose of court decisions: to draw a line in the sand regarding what behavior is allowed. This is free speech; that is not. This is an illegal search; that is not. This is cruel & unusual punishment; that is not. This is tortuous negligence; that is not. So yes, I am drawing a line exactly where I think it should be.
The alternative is that there is no legal distinction between computing devices. So software in a car, laundry machine, POS terminal, phone, laptop, smart light, etc all share the same rules. So if a Windows laptop must be able to install arbitrary software, then Toyota needs allow for the same in their cars. And if Apple can lock down installation of software on their devices, then Dell is allowed to do the same (and if that's the case, can Intel do the same and only run certain code?).
A legal classification here is, IMHO, the preferred outcome of this case. Whatever the decision made here is, it will have very far reaching implications on technology. Though, if the case were to say that all computing systems are the same, I'd prefer Apple to lose and all computer systems be forced open, than allowed to be closed. Since having cheap video game consoles is not really worth the cost to society of allowing for locked down computer systems.
> If banking apps and Photoshop are what makes a computer "general-purpose", then we'll see banking apps and Photoshop banned from platforms.
Also, my argument is whether or not these types of apps "make sense," as in, a customer base exists for such apps on said platform that there is the market pressure to create one. Not whether not such apps are "allowed." It's certainly allowable to make such apps for the Xbox, there's just not a market to do so; it doesn't jibe with customers perceived uses of said devices. Customers want to check their bank account on their iPhones; they have no desire to do so on their Xbox.