News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Rise of "Worse is Better" by nknight on Monday July 04, 2011 @04:42PM (#2727811)
If you substitute "practicality" wherever you see "worse is better", you'll have a much clearer idea of what the "philosophy" really is, and realize it in no way conflicts with critical systems.

All software design and development is done to a set of requirements. The more disastrous a failure would be, the stricter the requirements will be, and the more rigorous the processes will be.

Like almost all other developers, my software does not run nuclear reactors, therefore I am not going to expend the resources to achieve the safety necessary for a nuclear reactor. It would be both unnecessary and economically infeasible.

Do I care if a client makes a call to my IPTV webservice and gets back corrupt data? Well, yeah, but I'm not going to step through the entire software stack to mathematically prove it's impossible, nor am I going to encase the servers in a lightyear of lead to protect them from cosmic rays. I'm going to follow general best practices, let some testers play with it for a few days (while thousands of other lines of code in the client and server get exercised at the exact same time) and ship it.

Why? Because the small risk of a user not being able to watch their favorite movie in some weird corner-case has less economic significance than me spending days making 100% sure everything is perfect in my new API call.

At the same time, I recognize components of my systems that can have serious economic consequences, and accordingly invest more time in getting them closer to "right" (or avoiding them entirely -- e.g. not so long ago I ripped out all the C-style string/buffer handling from what was ostensibly a C++ library (not mine, originally) and replaced it with std::string and std::vector, which I knew were right, because people smarter than me had made sure they were, because everyone knew they had to be, and time was invested accordingly).

This is a continuum, not a pigeonhole.

There are no comments on this comment yet.