That sounds brilliant on first reading. I think it would take a lot of work and research to make it work, but man what a killer if it does work.
I don't think people change sizes that often, but that's solved by "Does Item XYZ still fit well, or should we send you another set of sizers?"
Note: this has been a surprisingly interesting thread. I really don't care about clothes, as long as I don't look like a derelict. But it's been fun to read and comment.
Also, I get away with grabbing stuff off the rack in part because of the types of clothes I buy. I strongly favor knits, jersey, and stuff with a smidgeon of spandex. I have a serious medical condition and I suffer edema. I can bloat up so bad overnight that people will congratulate me on my pregnancy (probably in part because they all think I am in my thirties and I am so NOT). So I can't wear anything too fitted because it may not fit from one day to the next.
As I get healthier and these issues resolve, I am finding that I no longer qualify for "women's" sizes and am beginning to have some of the pain points I had in my youth: Tall, thin women have a tough time finding clothes that fit properly. (Men get "big and tall" shops. Women get "petite" (short) and "women's" (fat).) When I was younger, I sometimes fantasized about learning to make my own clothes. That never happened. These days, I fantasize about starting a factory to make the kind of things that work well for me and, oh, turn a tidy profit at the same time. Time will tell if such thoughts lead anywhere. In the mean time, I am contemplating how to address such topics on various websites I own.
Thanks so much for your generous contributions to the thread.
I don't think it's an expensive solution either. Think of it as a customer acquisition cost. Almost anyone would accept free clothes.
Edit: Let's not forget Zappos is killing it. Maybe fit is not that big an issue and can be worked out over a couple of purchases.