Re:I was the fastest girl in Connecticut. But transgender at...
by ASalazarMX on Monday May 24, 2021 @04:54PM
(#27269577)
I seriously don't understand why are you defending that trans-women don't have a physical advantage against women?
The article is about post-puberty trans women dominating the first places. High-performance athletes train hard, but also have an innate biological advantage that gives them that slight edge to reach the podium. Post-puberty trans women had their innate biological advantage growing male, and hormone replacement can lessen, but not fully revert that.
Things that seem “common sense” often are far more complicated then they seem on the surface.
Should trans people partake in youth sports? Maybe sorta, with restrictions it depends. Should adult trans women be allowed to partake in sports, probably yes after sufficient time on hormones as the limited data we have says it isn’t a significant advantage, or may be a disadvantage. That said we should study and learn.
This conversation is toxic because people who don’t understand the subject matter come in and say things they don’t understand and continually insult and degrade a vulnerable minority.