“If you had any income that is not reported here, report it on irs.gov/…. Failure to do so is punishable by …”
This would make things significantly easier for 90% of the population.
Since “they” also define what you can be prosecuted for, that’s a bit of an odd justification even before considering the fairly strong evidence from both tax prep lobbying and anti-tax candidate behavior (including occasionally saying the quiet part out loud directly about the pain in the process being necessary to keep tax burden front of mind for taxpayers) that the two reasons cited by the grandparent are, in fact, the dominant factors.
Which ones? I don't agree or disagree, but I think it's a good practice to call out politicians when we make claims they do something. That way it gives a more clear line of sight to your claim.
(I agree that #2 is a big problem, but I don't think it's actually the reason we file taxes.)
(85-90% of households in recent years)
Oh, and my taxes are supposed to increase even more once the Trump tax holiday for the middle class expires in 2025. Luckily for corporations it is permanent for them. That tax plan was the most blatant government handout to the 1% and for some reason 40% of Americans think it's the best tax plan ever.
In any case, the standard deduction does have the effect of significantly reducing the administrative burden of taxation, and it crosses off one of the arguments used in favor of pointlessly complex tax filing.
You now have to be able to deduct over $24k to not take the standard deduction.
2. There exist tax preparation companies which profit enormously from doing the paperwork for you and they'd miss out on that profit if the government just billed you.