News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Methods for Array Initialization in Rust (2018) by tialaramex on Monday May 24, 2021 @11:44AM (#27265697)
Yes. This is untidy but effective.

Here's what's left (this was greatly reduced by const generics already, as another poster has explained):

https://doc.rust-lang.org/src/core/array/mod.rs.html#383

That macro implements Default, but only for arrays of size 1 to 32. It doesn't make any sense to talk about a Default array of size 0, the array is empty, there's no "default" content at all.

You can see the same verbosity for places where in some other languages you'd be able to just say all these things just work with any number of elements in a tuple, and Rust has chosen "up to 12" instead because it cannot express that.

https://doc.rust-lang.org/src/core/tuple.rs.html#100

The top half of that file is explaining to Rust's macro language how to do various things for an N-tuple, and then the bottom half call that macro for the 1 through 12 sizes.

If you really need a 16-tuple (unlikely, but...) you could copy paste the code to make one with the same features. This isn't compiler support, so you could just do it yourself.

Re:Methods for Array Initialization in Rust (2018) by estebank on Monday May 24, 2021 @12:36PM (#27266440)
> If you really need a 16-tuple (unlikely, but...) you could copy paste the code to make one with the same features. This isn't compiler support, so you could just do it yourself.

There's one wrinkle in that strategy in that you might run afoul of the orphan rule[1][2] where you can't write:

    impl ForeignTrait for ForeignType {}
because if we did it would be brittle and changes to an external crate could make your unchanged crate stop compiling. So you're restricted to either implementing your own trait or any trait on a type you declared. To "get around this" you can use the new-type pattern[2]:

    struct MyArray<T>([T; 33]);
    impl ForeignTrait for ForeignType {}
[1]: https://github.com/Ixrec/rust-orphan-rules

[2]: https://play.rust-lang.org/?version=stable&mode=debug&editio...

Re:Methods for Array Initialization in Rust (2018) by tialaramex on Monday May 24, 2021 @04:10PM (#27269116)
My error. Good point about the orphan rule. Because I was writing about Tuples what I was talking about is actually impossible in your own code I think, because tuples are inherently foreign. Even though the code in std looks tame, you are forbidden from doing this elsewhere. Even for a hypothetical local type MyType you are forbidden from attempting:

impl ForeignTrait for (MyType,u8)

The compiler will conclude that ForeignTrait is foreign, of course which is what we expected, but (MyType,u8) is also foreign even though MyType is local and so the orphan rule forbids this definition. Shame.

It doesn't make any sense to sidestep with new type because if you didn't want a tuple you could already define whatever type you wanted and this isn't an issue anyway, whereas if you do really want a tuple then a new type isn't a substitute.