News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cheese photo leads to Liverpool drug dealer's downfall by pc86 on Monday May 24, 2021 @08:08AM (#27263392)
I agree with you on the legal doctrine piece, but most in the US (myself included) would say that the US Constitution doesn't grant anybody any rights. It codified inalienable rights that exist for all people merely by virtue of their existence. Every person has the right to speak their mind, to defend themselves, to not incriminate themselves, etc. etc. with all the caveats and potential nullifications that accompany those rights. The fact that some countries may violate those inherent rights is irrelevant, and the fact that some of those countries may be common law is equally irrelevant.

It's possible to believe both that Liverpool and the surrounding area is better off without this man free, but that the UK as a whole is worse off for their frequent violation of rights with regard to those in the US Bill of Rights.

Re:Cheese photo leads to Liverpool drug dealer's downfall by pjc50 on Monday May 24, 2021 @08:13AM (#27263437)
The position that the US constitution applies to the UK is a pretty crazy piece of legal maximalism in the first place, but there is plenty of US caselaw that it doesn't apply equally to non-US nationals even within the US.

https://scholarship.law.georgetown.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?a...

https://guides.ll.georgetown.edu/c.php?g=592919&p=4170926 (which reminds me of the US failure to ratify certain international conventions under which it provides weaker rights)

Re:Cheese photo leads to Liverpool drug dealer's downfall by pc86 on Monday May 24, 2021 @08:16AM (#27263457)
I'm not meaning to imply that the USC applies to anyone other than US citizens from a legal standpoint. Not only am I not a lawyer, but I'm meaning to draw a distinction between legal rights and human rights in this context.

I'm saying that the rights codified in the USC are inalienable rights. The US government isn't granting the freedom of speech, and it can't take it away. The right exists because you're a human being.

The fact that a country doesn't recognize it as a right doesn't change its status.

Re:Cheese photo leads to Liverpool drug dealer's downfall by akarma on Monday May 24, 2021 @11:14AM (#27265293)
As an American happy to live in a country with all our protected freedoms, there are some parts of the Constitution that other reasonable countries don't agree with, and that's fine. There are other cultures with other value systems and they're no less valid.

(1) Freedom of Assembly, part of our 1st Amendment, is one example.

A French court recently decided a protest in Paris could not take place. The court rationale was that a previous protest a few years ago in the same area on the same issue led to violence and destruction of property.

The French Constitution allows freedom of speech, but not freedom of assembly, and Americans are often confused by that. The freedom to write and say what you want does not equate to the freedom to protest in the streets. Not allowing freedom of assembly would have saved many lives in the protests that have swept the US, though potentially at the cost of slower social progress.

(2) Right to bear arms, our 2nd amendment, is another example.

The vast majority of first-world countries don't agree that the right to bear arms is an inalienable human right in today's society.

As Americans, we may prefer the added protection against government tyranny and our personal ability to protect ourselves and our belongings. Unarguably, however, it comes at the cost of mass shootings, and additionally, though many factors are responsible for our uniquely high homicide rate, easy availability of firearms certainly does not help to curb it.

--- All this to say, many of our protected rights have clear, substantial disadvantages. It's not our place to tell every other country in the world how to operate.

Re:Cheese photo leads to Liverpool drug dealer's downfall by freeflight on Monday May 24, 2021 @12:55PM (#27266731)
> Not allowing freedom of assembly would have saved many lives in the protests that have swept the US, though potentially at the cost of slower social progress.

The US supreme court has established that the government can't regulate the content of speech, but the government is in its right to regulate the time, place and manner of speech. [0]

So it is very much a thing in the US and has been enforced plenty of times, for example during Occupy and even during BLM when protests were just declared as "riots" to then crack down on them with the full force of a militarized police arresting thousands of people [1].

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_speech_zone

[1] https://apnews.com/article/american-protests-us-news-arrests...

Re:Cheese photo leads to Liverpool drug dealer's downfall by akarma on Monday May 24, 2021 @05:20PM (#27269865)
> even during BLM when protests were just declared as "riots" to then crack down on them with the full force of a militarized police arresting thousands of people

Many Americans actually died in these events in addition to dangerous fires (with people still inside buildings!) and random acts of violence, so the riot characterization has at least in some cases been fair. It makes sense thousands of people would be arrested when hundreds of crimes have occurred.

The difference in the US is that these events could not be stopped from occurring, and people were not immediately arrested and water cannoned and so forth by police. It was only after the event grew and escalated and changed in nature.

That is where France differs — a protest can, from the beginning, be declared unable to occur, and police respond to it accordingly.

This is not at all to say that these events were all wrong or created with ill intent, but that there is a clear advantage and disadvantage to the right to freedom of assembly in the US.

Re:Cheese photo leads to Liverpool drug dealer's downfall by freeflight on Monday May 24, 2021 @08:38PM (#27271425)
> That is where France differs — a protest can, from the beginning, be declared unable to occur, and police respond to it accordingly.

I think you are misunderstanding what all of this actually means: The US government doesn't just have to tolerate protests anywhere anytime.

It is in its right to deem certain times, places and forms of expression as not valid, the only thing it can't regulate is the content of the expression.

So you are free to protests for whatever you want, but you are not free to do it whenever and wherever you want, the authorities have the last word on that, regardless of any violence or crimes happening.

Re:Cheese photo leads to Liverpool drug dealer's downfall by akarma on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @11:32AM (#27278171)
I understand what you're referring to, but was aiming to explain the difference between the US and France in a more approachable way. The US could block a protest from occurring, but the legal basis would be much tougher than that in France (it's more protected in the US).

In the US, a court won't simply forbid a protest ahead of time because the issue was protested several years ago in the same neighborhood and it led to a riot.

Re:Cheese photo leads to Liverpool drug dealer's downfall by pjc50 on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @01:34AM (#27273028)
> Many Americans actually died in these events

Did they? How many? And of those how many were killed by the police or far-right sympathisers like Kyle Rittenhouse?

Re:Cheese photo leads to Liverpool drug dealer's downfall by akarma on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @11:23AM (#27278038)
25 Americans last I read. Almost all if not all were killed by fellow civilians, not police.
Re:Cheese photo leads to Liverpool drug dealer's downfall by kergonath on Monday May 24, 2021 @06:01PM (#27270197)
> The French Constitution allows freedom of speech, but not freedom of assembly, and Americans are often confused by that.

It is a subtle issue, but under French law assembling and protesting is covered under free speech, which is a human right.

However, another principle is that all rights are limited when they are in conflict with other people’s fundamental rights, one of them being to live in peace. So in case of protests they have to register beforehand to ensure that there would be some police to prevent violence. That’s the theory anyway. They are not quite as murderous as American policemen, but French ones can also be violent and heavy handed.

For the same reason some protests can be forbidden. Usually, it is very difficult as the local government needs to demonstrate a significant risk of unacceptable violence. It is easier these days (in the last 2 decades or so) since there are “exceptional” measures in force to limit terrorism. And of course now there are public health restrictions because of COVID.

Re:Cheese photo leads to Liverpool drug dealer's downfall by webmobdev on Monday May 24, 2021 @06:06PM (#27270246)

    Right to bear arms, our 2nd amendment, is another example.
From what I've read about this arcane piece of legislation, some historians have suggested it stemmed from the fear of slave owners who believed that freed black man may choose to exact revenge on them and they feared that others in their country, who favoured abolition of slavery and criticised them for owning slaves, may not stand with them to offer protection against such revenge attacks. Thus, many spoke in favour of the right to bear arms, stoking fears of a future conflict between the white man and the black man.
Re:Cheese photo leads to Liverpool drug dealer's downfall by pc86 on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @07:36AM (#27275583)
This has no basis in reality.
Re:Cheese photo leads to Liverpool drug dealer's downfall by webmobdev on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @03:53PM (#27281744)
I am not an American, so I may indeed be mistaken. But the reasoning sounded logical to me - The whole civil war in the US happened because the confederates differed with other Americans on the question of white supremacy and the abolishment of slavery in the USA. For these secessionists, the enslaved blacks and the Americans who supported freeing them were the enemies.
Re:Cheese photo leads to Liverpool drug dealer's downfall by watwut on Monday May 24, 2021 @01:17PM (#27267064)
USA also allows and disallows protests at various places and times. And they have just legislated new additional laws about that.

But I give you that personal guns being framed as anti goverment tyranny is profoundly us thing. I find out odd also because those guns tend to be stockpiled by pretty authoritarian groups and very rarely by civil rights groups.

Re:Cheese photo leads to Liverpool drug dealer's downfall by michaelt on Monday May 24, 2021 @10:50AM (#27265009)
I think a lot of people in the US would say that rights like freedom of speech ought to be available to everyone, everywhere in the world.

But if you ask them whether 4th-8th amendment rights should extend to detainees at Guantanamo Bay; or whether separation of church and state should be demanded of our Israeli friends; or whether the Queen should be deposed as a tyrant; you would find a lot less support.

Re:Cheese photo leads to Liverpool drug dealer's downfall by boomboomsubban on Monday May 24, 2021 @01:04PM (#27266880)
These two points of view aren't contradictory, the Constitution is very clear that it does not grant anybody rights but it is less clear about whose rights they can infringe on.
Re:Cheese photo leads to Liverpool drug dealer's downfall by pjc50 on Monday May 24, 2021 @08:25AM (#27263530)
Yes, that's the usual human rights rationale but it's practically a theological one - that the rights have always existed and exist even if you can't see or action them.

Interestingly ECHR doesn't bother to define what a right is or where they come from, leaving the implicit position being simple legal realism that the rights exist because this document says they do and the parties agreed to it. https://www.echr.coe.int/Documents/Archives_1950_Convention_...

Re:Cheese photo leads to Liverpool drug dealer's downfall by mnw21cam on Monday May 24, 2021 @09:00AM (#27263812)
The other point of course is that even if you recognise a pre-government system of human rights, it is reasonable to apply exceptions. For example, the right to free speech is reasonably curtailed when the person speaking is ordering a lackey to commit murder. Most countries recognise some level of intrinsic human rights, but they all handle these exceptions slightly differently.

It's not that the UK is dastardly in violating this person's right to privacy because it doesn't think the rights are worth upholding. It's just that the UK has formulated a particular set of reasonable circumstances where it is alright to violate the right to privacy, and has reasoning behind each of them. The US has a different set of formulated reasonable circumstances where it is alright to violate the right to privacy that much of Europe is pretty horrified about. Both sides being horrified at the borderline areas of the other is not surprising.

Re:Cheese photo leads to Liverpool drug dealer's downfall by kergonath on Monday May 24, 2021 @06:11PM (#27270300)
> Interestingly ECHR doesn't bother to define what a right is or where they come from, leaving the implicit position being simple legal realism that the rights exist because this document says they do and the parties agreed to it.

That’s a strange take. It is basically a rewriting of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights of 1948. It even says so right there in the preamble. And it’s a law, part of an international treaty, not a history book. So where the origins of these rights are is beside the point and a legal description is not really surprising.

Re:Cheese photo leads to Liverpool drug dealer's downfall by Spooky23 on Monday May 24, 2021 @08:47AM (#27263693)
That's all good for the origin story but obviously lacks impact in reality.

The "bug" in the system is that when you talk about inalienable rights inherent by the grace of god or the creator is that god doesn't write shit down. The canonical texts have been edited by various entities for thousand of years in some cases. So you're dependent on the interpretation of others. Usually people's understanding of God's will (assuming agreement on the deity) is influenced by their mortgage.

I'm sure the high and mighty philosophy was confusing to any of the 1M enslaved people who were literate. But then again, the fiscal success of the plantation was dependent on those humans being classified by law as more intelligent cattle.

Re:Cheese photo leads to Liverpool drug dealer's downfall by refurb on Monday May 24, 2021 @10:03AM (#27264468)
You’re interpreting it way too literally. The Declaration of Independence isn’t saying “god said X”, it’s declaring that everyone had these rights, not based on the govt giving it to them, but that they always had them and the US govt is simply recognizing that. There is no religious document one needs to refer back to.

I think it’s actually a genius way of describing rights. It’s the same way one might say that slavery ended not because the govt decided to give slaves rights (the government doesn’t have that power), but rather that they always had them and the govt simply stopped denying their rights.

Re:Cheese photo leads to Liverpool drug dealer's downfall by Spooky23 on Monday May 24, 2021 @10:19AM (#27264646)
> I think it’s actually a genius way of describing rights.

In context, it absolutely is.

Remember that many of the key constitutional framers were believers in deism, and believed in god in the context of a creator, but not as an omnipresent supernatural being.

Outside of that context, things get difficult. Looking beyond the slavery example, the Commonwealth of Massachusetts was governed in the early years of the republic as compared to New York or Pennsylvania. It demonstrates the differences in how context as defined by religion matters.

Re:Cheese photo leads to Liverpool drug dealer's downfall by EdTsft on Monday May 24, 2021 @08:34PM (#27271401)
It's interesting how the US has such a different cultural view of rights than other English speaking commonwealth countries that you'd expect to be culturally similar. I can't speak for other countries but as a Canadian I view the idea of "inalienable" or "god-given" rights as preposterous. A right is a promise a government makes to a people. I have a much more expansive right to free speech than someone in North Korea does, that's just an objective reality since the North Korean government does not make the promise of free speech to their people. I have no right to be granted employment if I cannot find it myself, but that right has existed for others in various places and times. You can say that people should have certain rights, but to me it's wrong as a statement of fact to say that they already have them.

This view of rights also makes it easy to say that we should have the right to healthcare, or food and water, or housing. You don't have to debate about whether those are "inalienable human rights" to decide that it would be better for our government to make those promises to our citizens.

More of an aside, it is weird to me that you would include the right to not self-incriminate among the set of inalienable rights. That one seems like a much more arbitrary detail of your justice system than some more obvious right like access to food and clean water.

Re:Cheese photo leads to Liverpool drug dealer's downfall by simias on Monday May 24, 2021 @08:50AM (#27263716)
I'm not sure I understand your point. Are you arguing that you think that the UK police and/or justice system tacitly enforce the US Constitution because they think it's a good idea or merely that you think that the world would be a better place if all of humanity adhered to said constitution?

The former is preposterous, the latter is your opinion but it's frankly irrelevant in this discussion.

Re:Cheese photo leads to Liverpool drug dealer's downfall by webmobdev on Monday May 24, 2021 @05:55PM (#27270153)

    It codified inalienable rights that exist for all people merely by virtue of their existence ... The fact that some countries may violate those inherent rights is irrelevant
Ok, so what is your opinion on the trial and detention of various foreign "terrorists" in the USA who are / were in Guantanamo Bay Naval Base military prison? If we go by the very US laws you believe apply to every human being in the world, that implies the US government tortured, denied due process and illegally detained and treated many foreign citizens differently because they were not American citizens.
Re:Cheese photo leads to Liverpool drug dealer's downfall by wfleming on Monday May 24, 2021 @08:16AM (#27263458)
> but most in the US (myself included) would say that the US Constitution doesn't grant anybody any rights. It codified inalienable rights that exist for all people merely by virtue of their existence

As an American I find this a very surprising interpretation, and I doubt anybody in my close social circle would agree with it either.

Re:Cheese photo leads to Liverpool drug dealer's downfall by ekianjo on Monday May 24, 2021 @08:34AM (#27263595)
Its not an interpretation at all. Its is litterally written by Jefferson in the preamble to the constitution

> We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.—That to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed,—That whenever any Form of Government becomes destructive of these ends, it is the Right of the People to alter or to abolish it, and to institute new Government, laying its foundation on such principles and organizing its powers in such form, as to them shall seem most likely to effect their Safety and Happiness.

From your comment I wonder how many americans actually understand the history behind the constitution.

Re:Cheese photo leads to Liverpool drug dealer's downfall by brendoelfrendo on Monday May 24, 2021 @08:51AM (#27263727)
I'm really, really enjoying that two people (this comment and a sibling comment) both posted in support of this interpretation of the constitution, and then both of them posted the same snippet of the Declaration of Independence instead.
Re:Cheese photo leads to Liverpool drug dealer's downfall by indymike on Monday May 24, 2021 @10:58AM (#27265110)
The Declaration of Independence made the claim that certain rights were inalienable. The US Constitution was much less exciting and largely just laid out how the government would function.

"We the People of the United States, in order to form a more perfect union, establish justice, insure domestic tranquility, provide for the common defense, promote the general welfare, and secure the blessings of liberty to ourselves and our posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America."

The Bill of Rights wasn't even part of the original constitution. The constitution was ratified in 1788, and the Bill of Rights was ratified in the form of amendments 1 through 10 in 1791.

Re:Cheese photo leads to Liverpool drug dealer's downfall by will4274 on Monday May 24, 2021 @12:41PM (#27266528)
> The Bill of Rights wasn't even part of the original constitution

I see this claim frequently, but I still judge it as "mostly false." Multiple states refused to ratify the constitution without the bill of rights. Without the bill of rights, the original constitution would have collapsed in less than ten years. The original constitution by itself was a piece of paper. The constitution together with the bill of rights are the foundation of our government.

Re:Cheese photo leads to Liverpool drug dealer's downfall by indymike on Monday May 24, 2021 @07:28PM (#27270919)
Incorrect. The Bill of Rights was written after the US Constitution was ratified. The part about it collapsing is conjecture (quite a few scholars agree with thus position).
Re:Cheese photo leads to Liverpool drug dealer's downfall by boomboomsubban on Monday May 24, 2021 @12:59PM (#27266809)
This is the reason that the Bill of Rights say "Congress shall make no law infringing on..." The creators of the Constitution were very clear that rights were not granted by the state, they were inherent to all people.

There's still room for the Bill of Rights to only apply to Americans though, it is not clear whether they may make no law infringing on the rights of citizens or people.

Re:Cheese photo leads to Liverpool drug dealer's downfall by will4274 on Monday May 24, 2021 @11:59AM (#27265924)
It's disappointing to me that you and your social circle weren't educated in your own country's government and history. Can I ask which underfunded school district you attended?

In most American schools, for "social studies", US history is grades 8 and 9, while US government is grade 10. What did you study instead at these grade levels?

Re:Cheese photo leads to Liverpool drug dealer's downfall by logicchains on Monday May 24, 2021 @08:29AM (#27263559)
It's literally what the constitution itself says: "We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness." The vast majority of Americans are not Silicon Valley technocrats who reject any kind of deontological ethics.
Re:Cheese photo leads to Liverpool drug dealer's downfall by wfleming on Monday May 24, 2021 @10:40AM (#27264880)
As others have pointed out - that's not the constitution.

From a philosophical perspective, though, I agree that Jefferson and others saw those rights as fundamental human truths. They were saying "people already have these rights, we promise the government won't infringe on them", not "the government grants people these privileges". (Of course, who qualified as "people" continued to be a matter of debate. And some of the "fundamental" rights later enumerated in the bill of rights, specifically the third, seem like pretty localized of-their-place-and-time concerns in retrospect.)

I think what prompted my comment and some of the other replies to pc86 was that the beginning of this comment thread was discussing some fairly specific applied legal concepts (e.g. "parallel construction") from a practical perspective of applied law. So replying to that thread with a point about political philosophy from an entirely different country is a bit of an odd tangent. Re-reading the comment, I do think that's how it was intended, but I think the context made it easy to misinterpret it as suggesting that Americans believe everyone in the world should abide by our political philosophy. Which is certainly regrettably true of some Americans, but I hope it doesn't describe anywhere close to most of us.

Re:Cheese photo leads to Liverpool drug dealer's downfall by ghaff on Monday May 24, 2021 @01:21PM (#27267110)
>From a philosophical perspective, though, I agree that Jefferson and others saw those rights as fundamental human truths. They were saying "people already have these rights, we promise the government won't infringe on them"

In general, that's almost certainly true. But there was also genuine disagreement between the Federalists and Anti-Federalists over the power of the central government and the Bill of Rights was essentially an effort to craft a compromise that could be ratified. Madison whittled down a long list of suggested rights and liberties to 12 amendments. Some of which (as in the first amendment, right to a trial, etc.) are fairly fundamental. Others of which, perhaps most of all the third as you say, fairly clearly grew out of Revolutionary War concerns.

Re:Cheese photo leads to Liverpool drug dealer's downfall by sjy on Monday May 24, 2021 @08:36AM (#27263608)
That’s the Declaration of Independence. The Constitution came 11 years later (and did not, even then, include the Bill of Rights).
Re:Cheese photo leads to Liverpool drug dealer's downfall by benjohnson on Monday May 24, 2021 @08:51AM (#27263720)
As I understand it, the Bill of Rights was considered redundant by many people - and some thought that enumerating the rights line by line was dangerously limiting them.
Re:Cheese photo leads to Liverpool drug dealer's downfall by FridayoLeary on Monday May 24, 2021 @10:08AM (#27264525)
Not sure where, but i heard once that the constitution was actually only intended to be a temporary document until a more reasonable draft could be hammered out. Even its authors didn't imagine it would still be relevant 200 years later.
Re:Cheese photo leads to Liverpool drug dealer's downfall by sumtechguy on Monday May 24, 2021 @02:57PM (#27268335)
The first one was more temporary while they figured out what they had just did. (things like how do we pay the bills)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Articles_of_Confederation

That is why the one we are under is basically the 2nd revision of that.

Re:Cheese photo leads to Liverpool drug dealer's downfall by Mauricebranagh on Monday May 24, 2021 @11:23AM (#27265428)
In the US (and associated territories) I think you mean.
Re:Cheese photo leads to Liverpool drug dealer's downfall by toomanybeersies on Monday May 24, 2021 @02:48PM (#27268205)
> but most in the US (myself included) would say that the US Constitution doesn't grant anybody any rights. It codified inalienable rights that exist for all people merely by virtue of their existence

And many outside the USA would disagree with your position that a 200 year old document, written in part by slave owners, is the sole source of truth of our inalienable rights.

I for one disagree with the concept of immutable, codified constitutions entirely. I grew up in New Zealand, a country with no codified constitution, and yet somehow a country with a far better track record in human rights than the USA.

Re:Cheese photo leads to Liverpool drug dealer's downfall by adventured on Monday May 24, 2021 @03:34PM (#27268698)
> And many outside the USA would disagree with your position that a 200 year old document, written in part by slave owners, is the sole source of truth of our inalienable rights.

Their disagreement also is meaningless, fortunately.

Whether the documents were written in part by Martians or slave owners doesn't by itself alter the words on the documents, as such rationally what is solely to be judged is what was written, not how people feel about some of the contributors. If the world went by the standard you're floating, the last several thousand years of history and all successful political systems of human liberty have to be necessarily obliterated, including New Zealand's entire political system and system of law, which is inherited from a thus poisoned history involving European slavery and conquest.

The US, as with most of Latin America, inherited enormous European slavery and has spent its entire existence dealing with the fact of that history and its intense consequences. What has New Zealand confronted that compares to that? Nothing remotely close (and yes I'm familiar with the history of New Zealand).

> and yet somehow a country with a far better track record in human rights than the USA.

The benefits of being a tiny, largely irrelevant westernized country formed merely a century ago and long after slavery was outlawed in the West. New Zealand's existence has been an exceptionally easy and sheltered one compared to most every other nation, and good for them.

What responsibilities globally does New Zealand have? Practically none. It's free to not matter, in the best way possible. It doesn't have to make hard decisions that risk altering the world. It's like a cute little trinket country, lots of preaching and little responsibility. It never has to step inbetween two warring parties going at it in a civil war and decide which side to support, who is right and who is wrong (North Korea attacking South Korea, North Vietnam attacking South Vietnam), or choose not to get involved at all and have that similarly be judged by history just the same as a superpower capable of intervening (and arguably with a moral responsibility to do so in some cases). It doesn't have to decide if it's rational to launch a war to stop a genocide of Muslims in Europe (Kosovo). It doesn't have to decide whether to protect Ukraine against an invading Russia. It doesn't have to decide if it's worth going to war with China to try to save democratic, peaceful Taiwan. It doesn't have to make a decision about maintaining or not maintaining a global superpower military (which comes with severe, inevitable moral consequences whatever direction you choose to go with that). It never has to make any globally consequential decisions what-so-ever, decisions that can remake the planet; it can be a very nice, easy place to be, the life of a sheltered, small population island that rides on the prosperity and protection of other larger successful nations.

Dropping context around the birth & existence of New Zealand and its particulars, is convenient and makes your premise very unrealistic. The US was born into a context of European sin and had no choice in the matter. Make any other decisions around the founding documents at the time and you don't get a US to begin with (as demonstrated by the civil war that it took to smash slavery in the southern states a century later). Which simultaneously doesn't excuse any mistakes the US has made since then, however context always matters, and New Zealand has had a trivially easy existence by comparison. There isn't a single nation of global importance without some terrible history behind it and there is a reason for that (it's impossible in actuality; only in theory is it not).

Re:Cheese photo leads to Liverpool drug dealer's downfall by xtian on Monday May 24, 2021 @04:51PM (#27269548)
No one outside of the US or perhaps a minority within NATO takes this kind of ahistorical apologetics seriously. They see the US for what it is. As an American, my most fervent hope is that believing these sorts of stories becomes untenable here as well.