News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Decentralised Applications Don’t Work by lmm on Sunday May 23, 2021 @09:17PM (#27260235)
Counterthesis: decentralised applications are losing popularity because XMPP was so awful that it poisoned the view of decentralisation. Pre-XMPP everything was decentralised and federated. Post-XMPP decentralisation became synonymous with less-good clones of centralised systems, and both new systems and existing decentralised systems started moving towards centralisation. Decentralisation will come back again when the best systems are decentralised.
Re:Why Decentralised Applications Don’t Work by emteycz on Sunday May 23, 2021 @09:46PM (#27260379)
Just a coincidence. Most people have no idea what XMPP was, never even cared, and joined the change.
Re:Why Decentralised Applications Don’t Work by lmm on Sunday May 23, 2021 @10:21PM (#27260544)
Most ordinary users have no idea. But there's a cultural generation of developers who tried to use Jabber in their high school / college years, found out how much it sucked, and carried that experience consciously or unconsciously into their programming careers.
Re:Why Decentralised Applications Don’t Work by astura on Monday May 24, 2021 @08:32AM (#27263584)
There's no "cultural generation," nobody I knew in college ever attempted to use Jabber because we were all just fine with using AIM. Shrug

Even if there was it would be a minority opinion among a company's developers, and developers have very little to no say in business decisions anyway.

Re:Why Decentralised Applications Don’t Work by emteycz on Monday May 24, 2021 @02:25AM (#27261548)
Sure, but that isn't important in any way. Programmers have much less influence on business decisions that that, and practically none on the society at large. If it was so good we'd be using it now.
Re:Why Decentralised Applications Don’t Work by Zak on Sunday May 23, 2021 @10:21PM (#27260543)
XMPP was created to provide an open alternative to the proprietary instant messaging systems that popped up in the mid 1990s, but wasn't usable until several years after several of those had gained significant popularity. I suspect the number of people who tried XMPP and rejected it in favor of something proprietary is tiny in comparison to those who never heard of it.

IM may be the first category where an internet application first appeared in a modern, user-friendly, full-featured form in a proprietary implementation before there was a standardized implementation.

Re:Why Decentralised Applications Don’t Work by throwaway2556 on Monday May 24, 2021 @03:33AM (#27261866)
If anyone wanna try out XMPP, Conversations is a good client for android, available on fdroid. Dino is a good Linux client. IMO dismail and trashserver seem to be good public servers, if you don't wanna host yourself [1][2].

[1] https://dismail.de/

[2] https://trashserver.net/en/

You're gonna hear some saying it's all oh so secure. But be aware of tradeoffs [3].

[3] https://infosec-handbook.eu/blog/xmpp-aitm/

Re:Why Decentralised Applications Don’t Work by Jiejeing on Monday May 24, 2021 @05:21AM (#27262424)
This is… an interesting take. You mean that everything before the 1999 XMPP PoC was decentralized, and XMPP killed it? (despite the actual situation at the time being split between closed and centralized networks, like MSN, ICQ, etc). And XMPP is to blame for the failure of all the other decentralized systems (that have nothing in common) that came between then and now?

Additionally, considering several hundred million people use XMPP on a daily basis (and even more use something that started out based on XMPP, e.g. whatsapp), saying that XMPP is so terrible that it killed everything is so weird that it would need some facts to back it up.

Re:Why Decentralised Applications Don’t Work by lmm on Monday May 24, 2021 @10:07PM (#27271924)
> This is… an interesting take. You mean that everything before the 1999 XMPP PoC was decentralized, and XMPP killed it? (despite the actual situation at the time being split between closed and centralized networks, like MSN, ICQ, etc). And XMPP is to blame for the failure of all the other decentralized systems (that have nothing in common) that came between then and now?

I mean that instant messaging was the first time (on the internet, at least) that centralized networks beat decentralised networks (whereas centralised competitors to email, the web, etc. had lost), and the legacy of that is why many subsequent network systems (that indeed have very little in common) have been built as centralised rather than decentralised. And I've gradually reached the conclusion that the reason the centralised networks won that one was not because they were uniquely good, but that XMPP was uniquely bad.

> Additionally, considering several hundred million people use XMPP on a daily basis (and even more use something that started out based on XMPP, e.g. whatsapp), saying that XMPP is so terrible that it killed everything is so weird that it would need some facts to back it up.

Actually I see the fact that modified forks of XMPP have been so much more successful than mainline XMPP as a demonstration that XMPP's design makes a lot of unforced errors.