Re:Google Wave is not dead yet - now at Apache
by nextparadigms on Monday July 04, 2011 @05:42AM
(#2725995)
I hope they change the interface. The first thing I found odd about Wave, was that it needed a 1 hour demo when they first showed it. That was probably because it was focused towards developers, though, which is another mistake they made.
But I think the UI was 60% of the problem. When I first started using it, my brain started to hurt. They didn't even follow the golden rule. They had 2 same width columns in there. And everything looked cluttered and complex. Not very intuitive at all.
Another issue with it was confusing marketing. They called it e-mail 2.0, when it was nothing like that. People used it more as a collaboration tool. I had to use it every day for 6 months, too, and I didn't like using it at all.
Now, whoever even compares Google+ with Wave and says Google+ might fail the same as Wave, simply doesn't get it. They are worlds apart. From the moment I even saw the video ads, I had the opposite feeling about it than I had about Wave - a very positive feeling. And I keep having it after using it many hours a day.
Re:Google Wave is not dead yet - now at Apache
by tseabrooks on Monday July 04, 2011 @11:33AM
(#2726787)
I'm a huge fan of Wave's UI and wave in general. My friends and I have used it every day since it's release. We love it and our only complaint is that it is occasionally sluggish.
Re:Google Wave is not dead yet - now at Apache
by ChrisArchitect on Monday July 04, 2011 @09:18AM
(#2726455)
to this day I have yet to see any major UI problems -- and I have used Wave alot in real collaboration situations. It has worked excellently for just that, collaboration. Only thing missing is a gTalk chat window/which the original Etherpad has so I will probably move to that as a wave replacement.
Re:Google Wave is not dead yet - now at Apache
by belthesar on Monday July 04, 2011 @10:45AM
(#2726660)
Wave isn't dead, period. If you watch traffic sources while accessing Google+, you can see wave.google.com being called. The underlying tech has been incorporated, if only at an API level, in Google+.
Re:Google Wave is not dead yet - now at Apache
by JoachimSchipper on Monday July 04, 2011 @07:24AM
(#2726197)
I think the reasoning is that Apache is about the only place where you have a strong open-source community that is acceptable to/has experience with "the enterprise" (see: their various Java projects).
Re:Google Wave is not dead yet - now at Apache
by Gorbzel on Saturday July 09, 2011 @09:25PM
(#2746769)
Exactly?
Wave, OpenSocial, OpenOffice: a bunch of great open ideas that never got support from their original corporate overlords. So they're dumped into the Apache Incubator, where they die a slow death.
It's really a shame. I remember investigating a project that would have solved a big need I had at the time, but was worried about a couple of bugs. I remember almost going with it, since I had faith that an Apache-backed product wouldn't langish. 18 months later still no commits.
But I think the UI was 60% of the problem. When I first started using it, my brain started to hurt. They didn't even follow the golden rule. They had 2 same width columns in there. And everything looked cluttered and complex. Not very intuitive at all.
Another issue with it was confusing marketing. They called it e-mail 2.0, when it was nothing like that. People used it more as a collaboration tool. I had to use it every day for 6 months, too, and I didn't like using it at all.
Now, whoever even compares Google+ with Wave and says Google+ might fail the same as Wave, simply doesn't get it. They are worlds apart. From the moment I even saw the video ads, I had the opposite feeling about it than I had about Wave - a very positive feeling. And I keep having it after using it many hours a day.
Both Wave and OO.o are fairy complex projects and I'm afraid that the pace of their development will suffer severely without a strong company backing.
Wave, OpenSocial, OpenOffice: a bunch of great open ideas that never got support from their original corporate overlords. So they're dumped into the Apache Incubator, where they die a slow death.
It's really a shame. I remember investigating a project that would have solved a big need I had at the time, but was worried about a couple of bugs. I remember almost going with it, since I had faith that an Apache-backed product wouldn't langish. 18 months later still no commits.